I have spent a lot on equipment that has been retired before its time.
I bought a 120 gallon tank with two corner overflow boxes, pre drilled. Everything I read, said a sump is the best way to go. So I purchased a sump and all the values and plumbing. After a year or so I capped off the predrilled holes, and got rid of the sump, filter socks and plumbing. Perfectly fine sump, in the garage with a lot of plumbing fittings.
When I had the sump, I had an in-sump skimmer, that I ended up not being happy with, and replaced it. So when I got rid of the sump, I also ended up with a perfectly fine in-sump skimmer sitting in the garage.
Replaced the sump with Fluval FX6 canister. Everything ran much smoother and quieter. Did not keep up with the maintenance, and it caused water quality issues. FX6 is next to the Skimmer in garage.
Then I purchased an AquaClear HOB that pumped water from the overflow back into the display. Nice filter, but after a few months, determined something else would work better/easier.
Current setup: HOB Skimmer pumping water out of one corner overflow back to the display. BRS dual canister for PhosGuard, bio media, whatever, pumping water out of the other overflow back into the display. Water heater in the overflow. ATO underneath the tank. Inside the display, two powerheads. For water changes, all the water is siphoned out of the two overflows and some from the display. Pretty simple. Water quality is perfect
Lessons Learned
I bought a 120 gallon tank with two corner overflow boxes, pre drilled. Everything I read, said a sump is the best way to go. So I purchased a sump and all the values and plumbing. After a year or so I capped off the predrilled holes, and got rid of the sump, filter socks and plumbing. Perfectly fine sump, in the garage with a lot of plumbing fittings.
When I had the sump, I had an in-sump skimmer, that I ended up not being happy with, and replaced it. So when I got rid of the sump, I also ended up with a perfectly fine in-sump skimmer sitting in the garage.
Replaced the sump with Fluval FX6 canister. Everything ran much smoother and quieter. Did not keep up with the maintenance, and it caused water quality issues. FX6 is next to the Skimmer in garage.
Then I purchased an AquaClear HOB that pumped water from the overflow back into the display. Nice filter, but after a few months, determined something else would work better/easier.
Current setup: HOB Skimmer pumping water out of one corner overflow back to the display. BRS dual canister for PhosGuard, bio media, whatever, pumping water out of the other overflow back into the display. Water heater in the overflow. ATO underneath the tank. Inside the display, two powerheads. For water changes, all the water is siphoned out of the two overflows and some from the display. Pretty simple. Water quality is perfect
Lessons Learned



