Lighting for an aqueon 40 gallon breeder 2017-18

Best option

  • LED

    Votes: 19 70.4%
  • T5

    Votes: 8 29.6%

  • Total voters
    27
I just got $110 in gift cards for aquarium adventure, my LFS. and just sealed up the championship in fantasy football for 200 and the trophy! So I may do two AI prime HD's. I love the reviews and if the LFS has them for 215 or less then I'll go that route. Love the wifi control and how they look with tank mounts.
 
I like the HOB idea. I have a aquaclear 70 on that 7.5 in pic....110 wouldn't fit...lol.
Here is the tank I am escaping from... The Fluval 13.5. The power head was moved due to company coming over and they don't need to see how sand gets blown everywhere. Havent done coral yet either because I knew this tank was temporary! I will miss this rock... Detritis is bad too, phophate remover packet ran out. Get new one tomorrow!

1225172049.jpg
 
You will be fine with 2 to light it up. Stick with soft corals though and some lps.
I prefer softies just because of the movement and response to flow. I am ok with the price now as well as I just won another 900 in fantasy football lol. I will create a build thread so that people can throw opinions and suggestions my way! Next question. If I pressure wash the rocks how bad will phosphates be? If it was already cured!
 
We have the same preference in coral Dick! Gorgonians are great too. Pressure washing probably won't rinse the phosphate as it's pretty embedded in the rock. I'm having a cycling issue myself because I had to rush the 75 since the nano had issues during my move. Although I'm not the best to comment on that issue. This forum has been great though, lots of great reefers to help others along!
 
We have the same preference in coral Dick! Gorgonians are great too. Pressure washing probably won't rinse the phosphate as it's pretty embedded in the rock. I'm having a cycling issue myself because I had to rush the 75 since the nano had issues during my move. Although I'm not the best to comment on that issue. This forum has been great though, lots of great reefers to help others along!
From what I can gather is phosphates even in extremely high levels will not harm fish or invertebrates. The majority of reefers just have issues because of the god awful algea blooms. I just don't want to wait 6 months for my rocks to go in the tank!
 
I know the feeling! I'm dealing with the cycle in display tank & watching the evolution take place. 2 tangs are going nuts & getting fat though [emoji4]
 
UPDATE!!! I went with the Fluval Marine and Reef 2.0 25000k 46 WATT with programmable wifi day night options. My rock and dr Tims 1 and only come thursday!

1514353663392187307672.jpg


15143536973531630165427.jpg


1514353723099-1611816693.jpg


1514353760875-1010898074.jpg


1514353797819-1248630932.jpg
 
$169.99 for the light $99 for the wifi adapter

Don't take this the wrong way...

I think that's a terrible light for the price, like almost as bad as orbit marine. I'm seeing PAR values online of 236/94/55 at 6/12/18" deep, respectively. You'll be hard-pressed to grow anything, especially LPS, with under 100 PAR, so any corals on the sandbed will probably stagnate and not grow.

I have the same tank (40b), I run a single sbreef basic 16 ($135) about 12" off the water. I removed all the lenses to fix some shading issues and it's doing great - I keep SPS near the top, and LPS/softies wherever I want, everything is growing fine. Sure, I'd love to have another so I can put the lenses back on...or better yet another plus a pair of t5 (one in front, one behind) for shadowing, but overall if anyone was looking for a cheap way to light a tank I'd definitely go with sbreef. I'm holding out on doing any lighting upgrades with grand plans for a larger tank in the relative near future...everything is growing "fine" though, so no reason to change anything right now...could I get better growth, maybe, rather wait and see on a bigger tank in a year.

You're going to want to leave the lighting off for the cycle anyways...assuming you're doing a fishless cycle on dry rock, plan on 4-6 weeks of cycle before you can put any corals or fish. IMO you should also order dr tims ammonium chloride for $4 and make sure your bacteria can "eat" 2ppm of ammonia into nitrate within 24 hours before adding fish. The weeks it will take for that to happen is plenty of time to return your $270 worth of light+wifi adapter and buy a better light. You can get the sbreef basic 16" for $135, and see how corals do with and without the lenses, or pickup the 32" version for $275 and not worry about it. If you want ramping, sbreef has a wifi version of the 16" black box for $260. If you want something with control of individual channels, and don't want to go the sb+t5 route, I'd probably go with a reefbreeders photon v2 fixture - the 24" version for $350 should be sufficient for a mixed reef if mounted high enough.
 
Last edited:
Don't take this the wrong way...

I think that's a terrible light for the price, like almost as bad as orbit marine. I'm seeing PAR values online of 236/94/55 at 6/12/18" deep, respectively. You'll be hard-pressed to grow anything, especially LPS, with under 100 PAR, so any corals on the sandbed will probably stagnate and not grow.

I have the same tank (40b), I run a single sbreef basic 16 ($135) about 12" off the water. I removed all the lenses to fix some shading issues and it's doing great - I keep SPS near the top, and LPS/softies wherever I want, everything is growing fine. Sure, I'd love to have another so I can put the lenses back on...or better yet another plus a pair of t5 (one in front, one behind) for shadowing, but overall if anyone was looking for a cheap way to light a tank I'd definitely go with sbreef. I'm holding out on doing any lighting upgrades with grand plans for a larger tank in the relative near future...everything is growing "fine" though, so no reason to change anything right now...could I get better growth, maybe, rather wait and see on a bigger tank in a year.

You're going to want to leave the lighting off for the cycle anyways...assuming you're doing a fishless cycle on dry rock, plan on 4-6 weeks of cycle before you can put any corals or fish. IMO you should also order dr tims ammonium chloride for $4 and make sure your bacteria can "eat" 2ppm of ammonia into nitrate within 24 hours before adding fish. The weeks it will take for that to happen is plenty of time to return your $270 worth of light+wifi adapter and buy a better light. You can get the sbreef basic 16" for $135, and see how corals do with and without the lenses, or pickup the 32" version for $275 and not worry about it. If you want ramping, sbreef has a wifi version of the 16" black box for $260. If you want something with control of individual channels, and don't want to go the sb+t5 route, I'd probably go with a reefbreeders photon v2 fixture - the 24" version for $350 should be sufficient for a mixed reef if mounted high enough.


Please don’t take this the wrong way but the Ecotech Radion is a top of the line light. All other lights are compared to it. If you decide to upgrade then you will be pleasantly surprised.
 
@Daltrey Sorry I was replying to OP and his Fluval light! Radions are indeed top of the line, would be my go-to choice in its price range for sure. Edited my comment for clarity.
 
Don't take this the wrong way...

I think that's a terrible light for the price, like almost as bad as orbit marine. I'm seeing PAR values online of 236/94/55 at 6/12/18" deep, respectively. You'll be hard-pressed to grow anything, especially LPS, with under 100 PAR, so any corals on the sandbed will probably stagnate and not grow.

I have the same tank (40b), I run a single sbreef basic 16 ($135) about 12" off the water. I removed all the lenses to fix some shading issues and it's doing great - I keep SPS near the top, and LPS/softies wherever I want, everything is growing fine. Sure, I'd love to have another so I can put the lenses back on...or better yet another plus a pair of t5 (one in front, one behind) for shadowing, but overall if anyone was looking for a cheap way to light a tank I'd definitely go with sbreef. I'm holding out on doing any lighting upgrades with grand plans for a larger tank in the relative near future...everything is growing "fine" though, so no reason to change anything right now...could I get better growth, maybe, rather wait and see on a bigger tank in a year.

You're going to want to leave the lighting off for the cycle anyways...assuming you're doing a fishless cycle on dry rock, plan on 4-6 weeks of cycle before you can put any corals or fish. IMO you should also order dr tims ammonium chloride for $4 and make sure your bacteria can "eat" 2ppm of ammonia into nitrate within 24 hours before adding fish. The weeks it will take for that to happen is plenty of time to return your $270 worth of light+wifi adapter and buy a better light. You can get the sbreef basic 16" for $135, and see how corals do with and without the lenses, or pickup the 32" version for $275 and not worry about it. If you want ramping, sbreef has a wifi version of the 16" black box for $260. If you want something with control of individual channels, and don't want to go the sb+t5 route, I'd probably go with a reefbreeders photon v2 fixture - the 24" version for $350 should be sufficient for a mixed reef if mounted high enough.
To each their own I guess. I tend to trust my LFS when they sell me products, since the warranties are better, and if it's broken I get a new one in 5 minutes with no waiting on shipping. Nobody said this was the only light or the permanent light. There likely wont be coral in it for 8 months to a year. I don't care much for LPS and the tank will not be overloaded with coral. Also prefer direct on lid lighting because the mounting is easier. Was going to go with 2 AI primes because I like the look of those hanging. but the price for two plus the mounts was asinine
 
Wait for a used ATI 6-8 bulb fixture. Very likely you'll run into a 36x6 ATI for 250 - 500. That's your best bet in your price range.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top