Lighting giving me a little trouble

dman3572

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 31, 2015
Messages
41
Reaction score
33
Location
pocatello ID
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So I've been looking into starting a saltwater tank recently. I've been reading everything I can get my hands on, but I'm still having a little trouble with lighting. Ive been in the freshwater business for a few years and I'm now wanting to switch over. I don't want the whole spiel on how they take a lot more work or how there hard or only should be done by the "professionals" I'm determined to start one and that's that. So the passed few months I've read hundreds of articles and books and things about everything about saltwater tanks. I'm doing a reef tank so the lighting has been giving me some trouble. I'm staying away from halides but I've been looking into LED and T5's. I don't have the biggest budget right now but I would like to know the pros and cons that you guys have had with them. Which ones work, don't work, which ones are expensive, which ones are cheep, nice things they come with or don't come with, which ones are best for reef tanks. Stuff like that
 
I do not feel they tank more work, I know they cost a lot more to start up and keep going.
I am running three types of lights right now... this is all also going to depend on the size of your tank and what you will need.

Tank one is a 29gal running Chinese LED's and It is keeping softies and anemones alive with growth (and fish)
Tank two is a 5 gal frag tank, I am running a kessil over it and my SPS/LPS/zoa's are loving it. I have seen great growth in that tank in the month is has been running
Tank three is running T5HO's, it is a 20 long and I have see moderate grown from that tank of softies and SPS
 
So I've been looking into starting a saltwater tank recently. I've been reading everything I can get my hands on, but I'm still having a little trouble with lighting. Ive been in the freshwater business for a few years and I'm now wanting to switch over. I don't want the whole spiel on how they take a lot more work or how there hard or only should be done by the "professionals" I'm determined to start one and that's that. So the passed few months I've read hundreds of articles and books and things about everything about saltwater tanks. I'm doing a reef tank so the lighting has been giving me some trouble. I'm staying away from halides but I've been looking into LED and T5's. I don't have the biggest budget right now but I would like to know the pros and cons that you guys have had with them. Which ones work, don't work, which ones are expensive, which ones are cheep, nice things they come with or don't come with, which ones are best for reef tanks. Stuff like that

What size tank?
 
I had the same situation you were in. Left freshwater to go salty, and originally I used the cheaper option of using T5's. In a lot of ways I find that they're highly reliable. A T5 brand with a good reputation will allow healthy coral growth.

There were a few drawbacks to the T5's that brought me over to LEDs:
1. Energy consumption - the T5's in their fixture would get quite hot as they ran all day. While it wasn't enough to cause a problem in my tank, I saw faster evaporation, more salt creep, not to mention the electricity consumption obviously caused an increase in my electric bill.
2. Horrible unwanted algae growth - When I bought a few coral that had higher light demands, I kept my T5's on more often to satisfy them. However, that led to a terrible algae spike. It took me almost a month or two to get rid of - lots and lots of turbo snails, lighting blackouts (no lights for 3 days), and even vacuuming out the algae on my sand. Was such a NIGHTMARE.
3. No ability to adjust the lights gradually or automatically - Being on a budget, I thought that a timer was a silly luxury that I really didn't need. However, when I went out for an evening after work or spent the weekend away from my tank, that meant that my lights were sitting on (or off) for an extended period of time. That's not a good thing. Plus, there's no dimmers on T5's (that I've seen!) that allow you to adjust the lighting levels instead of abruptly slamming your corals with light or immediately taking it away. Lowering the lights slowly is better for the coral and is really excellent for acclimation.

Being on a budget, I searched my butt off to find something affordable. I have a 20 gallon tank at the moment, and I bought "Current USA" brand LEDs from Amazon. I think I got the 36-gallon lighting system for $140? It hurt to buy at first, but I am SO SO happy I did. It was just worth getting rid of the headache. While I would say to peruse EBay for lighting systems as well, I've heard some serious horror stories about getting garbage from China. If you choose to go that route, I would absolutely consult one of the members of this forum first. Personally, I love my lights.

The only complain I have about my LEDs is this:
Being a 20 gallon tank with enough wattage to support 36 gallons, I accidentally bleached a bunch of my coral :( You'll have to read the art of adjusting your light levels, but once you do, you never have to worry about your lights being on or off and at what levels again.


All in all, I would say don't take the route I did by trying to save $ at first, because it cost me in the long run (and now I have unused aquarium supplies all over my house). LEDs all the way :)
 
I had the same situation you were in. Left freshwater to go salty, and originally I used the cheaper option of using T5's. In a lot of ways I find that they're highly reliable. A T5 brand with a good reputation will allow healthy coral growth.

There were a few drawbacks to the T5's that brought me over to LEDs:
1. Energy consumption - the T5's in their fixture would get quite hot as they ran all day. While it wasn't enough to cause a problem in my tank, I saw faster evaporation, more salt creep, not to mention the electricity consumption obviously caused an increase in my electric bill.
2. Horrible unwanted algae growth - When I bought a few coral that had higher light demands, I kept my T5's on more often to satisfy them. However, that led to a terrible algae spike. It took me almost a month or two to get rid of - lots and lots of turbo snails, lighting blackouts (no lights for 3 days), and even vacuuming out the algae on my sand. Was such a NIGHTMARE.
3. No ability to adjust the lights gradually or automatically - Being on a budget, I thought that a timer was a silly luxury that I really didn't need. However, when I went out for an evening after work or spent the weekend away from my tank, that meant that my lights were sitting on (or off) for an extended period of time. That's not a good thing. Plus, there's no dimmers on T5's (that I've seen!) that allow you to adjust the lighting levels instead of abruptly slamming your corals with light or immediately taking it away. Lowering the lights slowly is better for the coral and is really excellent for acclimation.

Being on a budget, I searched my butt off to find something affordable. I have a 20 gallon tank at the moment, and I bought "Current USA" brand LEDs from Amazon. I think I got the 36-gallon lighting system for $140? It hurt to buy at first, but I am SO SO happy I did. It was just worth getting rid of the headache. While I would say to peruse EBay for lighting systems as well, I've heard some serious horror stories about getting garbage from China. If you choose to go that route, I would absolutely consult one of the members of this forum first. Personally, I love my lights.

The only complain I have about my LEDs is this:
Being a 20 gallon tank with enough wattage to support 36 gallons, I accidentally bleached a bunch of my coral :( You'll have to read the art of adjusting your light levels, but once you do, you never have to worry about your lights being on or off and at what levels again.


All in all, I would say don't take the route I did by trying to save $ at first, because it cost me in the long run (and now I have unused aquarium supplies all over my house). LEDs all the way :)

I've been looking into the current usa lighting and they've really caught my eye. I really like the variety of them. They are a little more expensive than the T5s but if the LEDs are a better quality then What's an extra 30-40 bucks right?
 
I'd shy away from the current leds.

My friend is running evergrow d120 full spectrum over his frag tank. Looks great with the extra colors, and reasonable priced.
 
I'd shy away from the current leds.

My friend is running evergrow d120 full spectrum over his frag tank. Looks great with the extra colors, and reasonable priced.

Thanks for the advice. Current usa was the only LED brand that didn't cost an insane amout. I'll look into the evergrow too!
 
I'm curious - what is your reasoning behind avoiding them? I've never used other brands before, only seen them used in the hobby. I always contributed their coral "quality" difference to my inexperience in the hobby comparatively. I've got a larger tank I want to set up soon and I would be open to other brands (that hopefully don't break the bank [emoji14])

I'd shy away from the current leds.

My friend is running evergrow d120 full spectrum over his frag tank. Looks great with the extra colors, and reasonable priced.
 
I'm curious - what is your reasoning behind avoiding them? I've never used other brands before, only seen them used in the hobby. I always contributed their coral "quality" difference to my inexperience in the hobby comparatively. I've got a larger tank I want to set up soon and I would be open to other brands (that hopefully don't break the bank [emoji14])

Not sure which one you have, But their earlier ones left a lot to be desired. Their new ones might be ok. What size larger tank are you looking to light?

Just my opinion, Full spectrum is the way to go now.
I'm actually looking at lighting a small frag tank. I had an AI nano that didn't live up to what was expected.

My display tank is lit with an ATI dimmable t5.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top