Ok, I got everything tested and the fixture hung. The 24" heatsink has way better coverage than the 18" did, granted, I added 30 more LED's to the 24" build, but nonetheless, I'm much happier with the coverage of the 24 incher.
First the original. This is a 36" Current Nova Extreme 6-bulb T-5 with 3 year old bulbs. One of the mounting feet broke which is why it is sitting on the board on the left side.
I used some drawer slides to mount the MakersLED fixture to the underside of the shelf. I thought it would make it easy to slide the fixture in and out to get it out of the way if I needed to work on the tank.
So here is the fixture on. The picturtes don't really show the true color and I don't know why...the photos of the Nova are pretty color accurate but these come out looking VERY pink. Maybe I'll reload Photoshop on my PC and see if I can get a more realistic representation of how it looks to the naked eye. Something else to mention is that these pics were takes with NO optics on the fixture. I have 40 degree optics that I need to install to get the light in the tank. As you can see in the pics, with the fixture so high above the tank, a lot of it is on the back wall. The optics will fix that. I only have 24 (from the original 18" fixture build) and the rest on order. I'll post some more pics once all the optics are installed. This is all colors on (RB, NW, HV, OCW) approximately 50%.
I ran the fixture for about 2.5 hours yesterday before the lights went off. I had the lid on the driver box closed so I could see how warm everything got. I'm going to have to add a fan to the box. The drivers were not hot, just warm, but that was at 50% intensity and only after a few hours. I imagine in the summer, at 100% these things will put out a bit more heat. Better to have a fan in there than let them cook.
Currently I only have one fan hooked up on the heatsink. The heatsink was completely cool to the touch after 2.5-3 hours of running. This surprised me because the 18" fixture I had running previously was quite warm (with half as many LED's but no fan). I really don't see a need for the second fan but I'll probably hook it up anyway.