Interesting . The only thing living before I started the h2o2 method was a delicate little convict tang. I dosed 1 ml per 5 gallons for 3 weeks, and started restocking. I now have numerous tangs and other delicate fish in my once velvet ridden system, without ever going fallow, only dosing h202. I will say, I started off with 1 ml per 10 gallons and slowly ramped up to 1 ml per 4 gallons. I saw no adverse reactions in anything, including macro algae, shrimp, and anemones. Zoanthids would close up immediately but would open back up shortly after.
Maybe your problem was lighting. Light degrades h2o2 very fast. I dosed the hydrogen peroxide twice a day, exactly 12 hours apart. Once at 7:20 in the morning, 2 hours before lights on, and again a 7:20 pm, an hour after lights off. I had to modify the lightning schedule, but it may have made all the difference.