ME Coral for Ca, Alk and Mg

mrtian97

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 16, 2015
Messages
802
Reaction score
156
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Anyone experience in using ME Coral supplements for Ca, Alk, and Mg. Seems their price is cheaper than BRS 2 parts.
I am currently using Kalk as ATO (only 60% of saturation), and manual dose the Ca, Alk, and Mg to supplement with Red Sea. Cost seems a lot more for the Red Sea supplements. I like to continue this without going to saturation level with my Kalk, seems working well with my corals (mixed reef).

Thanks
 
The quality should be perfectly fine. I'm wondering how you concluded ME Coral costs less than BRS, however.

It is hard to compare since ME does not seem seems to sell by weight, but when the BRS page says 1 gallon ($20) they mean 1 gallon of dry supplement, which they say on the label weighs 3.5 pounds, while for ME corals ($12) they say it makes 1 gallon of liquid supplement (not sure on the concentration of that liquid).
 
Thanks Randy, didn't know that BRS selling by weight. Will check it out
 
Thanks Randy, didn't know that BRS selling by weight. Will check it out

They sell by volume of the solid, but if you look at their product labels in the bottle pictures on their web site, they also give the weight of the dry material in it. :)
 
ME makes some nice stuff, but it is a lot more expensive than BRS. But Mark states his stuff is pharmaceutical grade chemicals he's using.
 
ME makes some nice stuff, but it is a lot more expensive than BRS. But Mark states his stuff is pharmaceutical grade chemicals he's using.

I don't want to sound like an advertisement for BRS, but BRS uses that grade from some of their chemicals as well, but not for sodium carbonate. :)

"BRS Bulk Calcium Chloride is produced using only the best pharmaceutical grade material available and meets strict BRS purity standards. "
" BRS Bulk Magnesium Sulfate is produced using only the best pharmaceutical grade material available and meets strict BRS purity standards."
"BRS Bulk Magnesium Chloride is produced using only the best pharmaceutical grade material available and meets strict BRS purity standards. "
 
yep, I think BRS would works the same. Maybe after I use up the ME, I will try the BRS.

At least ME is already cheaper than RedSea A,B,C
 
Since we are comparing ME to BRS. I think Randy works for them? LOL. Many people including myself have been using BRS for years. It is cheaper if you buy bulk and mix. At least for the time being? Most people that have switched from brs have seen a difference in quality. Its visible after mixing, as ME clears quicker. Its noticable on potency as brs users have to dial back their dose when switching to ME. After a few weeks people say they see a difference in their coral colors. I have seen and heard this 1,000 times. Just keep your ears open and listen to those who grow and import the nicest corals in this country. Randy really doesnt and hasnt used either ME or BRS he doses Kalk which works for his softy tank but not ME SPS tank. Randy mentioned above that BRS Kh is not USP? That doesnt sound good? I think the mag chloride and mag sulfate are significantly different. As for BRS stating they are Pharmaceutical------Many reefers have asked BRS for copies of their coa or certificate of analysis. This shows if the material has passed or met the quality standards based on purity and impurites found in the product. BRS will not show them to anyone? ME will! So all I say is try it and see if there is a difference as others have found. As mentioned above---its cheaper and better than anything at the LFS. BRS is direct or 1-800? Should your LFS exist in 5-10 years? Or are you happy only buying online? ME supports LFS by letting them make a profit by giving you the ability to have quality products down the street when you need it. Maybe they even have nice corals? Or do you only buy on line 1-800?
 
Since we are comparing ME to BRS. I think Randy works for them? LOL. Many people including myself have been using BRS for years. It is cheaper if you buy bulk and mix. At least for the time being? Most people that have switched from brs have seen a difference in quality. Its visible after mixing, as ME clears quicker. Its noticable on potency as brs users have to dial back their dose when switching to ME. After a few weeks people say they see a difference in their coral colors. I have seen and heard this 1,000 times. Just keep your ears open and listen to those who grow and import the nicest corals in this country. Randy really doesnt and hasnt used either ME or BRS he doses Kalk which works for his softy tank but not ME SPS tank. Randy mentioned above that BRS Kh is not USP? That doesnt sound good? I think the mag chloride and mag sulfate are significantly different. As for BRS stating they are Pharmaceutical------Many reefers have asked BRS for copies of their coa or certificate of analysis. This shows if the material has passed or met the quality standards based on purity and impurites found in the product. BRS will not show them to anyone? ME will! So all I say is try it and see if there is a difference as others have found. As mentioned above---its cheaper and better than anything at the LFS. BRS is direct or 1-800? Should your LFS exist in 5-10 years? Or are you happy only buying online? ME supports LFS by letting them make a profit by giving you the ability to have quality products down the street when you need it. Maybe they even have nice corals? Or do you only buy on line 1-800?
@marke , wasn't your avatar the ME logo, until just moments ago? Do you work for ME? If so, why are you referring to them in the third person?

I have reasons to believe that ME may very well have a superior product, but I do prefer transparency when vendors are posting about their own products in forums, *if* that is what is happening here.
 
Since we are comparing ME to BRS. I think Randy works for them? LOL. Many people including myself have been using BRS for years. It is cheaper if you buy bulk and mix. At least for the time being? Most people that have switched from brs have seen a difference in quality. Its visible after mixing, as ME clears quicker. Its noticable on potency as brs users have to dial back their dose when switching to ME. After a few weeks people say they see a difference in their coral colors. I have seen and heard this 1,000 times. Just keep your ears open and listen to those who grow and import the nicest corals in this country. Randy really doesnt and hasnt used either ME or BRS he doses Kalk which works for his softy tank but not ME SPS tank. Randy mentioned above that BRS Kh is not USP? That doesnt sound good? I think the mag chloride and mag sulfate are significantly different. As for BRS stating they are Pharmaceutical------Many reefers have asked BRS for copies of their coa or certificate of analysis. This shows if the material has passed or met the quality standards based on purity and impurites found in the product. BRS will not show them to anyone? ME will! So all I say is try it and see if there is a difference as others have found. As mentioned above---its cheaper and better than anything at the LFS. BRS is direct or 1-800? Should your LFS exist in 5-10 years? Or are you happy only buying online? ME supports LFS by letting them make a profit by giving you the ability to have quality products down the street when you need it. Maybe they even have nice corals? Or do you only buy on line 1-800?

We've had these discussions before and I'm surprised you are making the claims again in the way you are:

https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/w...y-calcium-and-magnesium-are-you-using.231628/



I'm still waiting in that thread from January for you to clarify what exactly it means that 1,000 reefers dose less. Less of what to achieve what? Also waiting to hear what you mean by mixing clear. What mixed into what looks more clear than what?

As I noted there, the dosing claim makes no sense for dosing an aquarium based on weight, but if folks are dosing by dry solid volume, then if one product is fluffier than another, you will dose less volume even though you may be dosing the exact same amount of chemical. One should not use dry volume recipes with new materials until the bulk density is checked to see if the recipe needs to be changed. So if one or more of your products just has less fluffiness, that might explain the observations, while not really being an advantage that I can see.
 
I have used both BRS and MECoral. I used BRS for about 4 months and a local reefer told me I should try MECoral. I honestly was leery but I trust the guy that told me so I ordered a batch of KH, Calcium, and Mag. It got to my door within a week and not only did I get what I ordered but got 3 different samples. Coral food, dip, and glue. When I mixed it up I have never seen anything mix so fast and clear I'm talking not even a minute it was crystal clear. Been using it since and no offense to Randy I saw a difference and also I know it's hard to believe but my corals received better color within weeks. I have before and after shots and it is very impressive. Only problem is my phone doesn't do it justice can't seem to figure out how to take a good pic. I do like BRS very much and still get stuff from them. Some of the stuff they say kinda aggravates me though. ME is the best and there glue is the best by far and there coral food is imho the best also there amino acid is very good and oh yeah there coral dip is the only dip I have successfully dipped soft skin acros in and not peeled the flesh off. I have no affiliation with ME or BRS just use there stuff and not trying to brag but I have the nicest tank I've ever seen in person and several of my friends agree and have also switched to ME. I love there products and will use them as long as I can. Oh btw Red Sea 2 part is the worst stuff I've ever used by far also Mark is a great guy
 
MECoral Rocks hard
All the pics where tiny frags 6months ago and some are new all colors have increased drastically since using MECorals products. Believe it or not but before you run your mouth I suggest you try it yourself it's not gonna break the bank I think for a gallon it's like 13$. I would suggest getting there glue it is amazing

IMG_3152.JPG


IMG_3157.JPG


IMG_3174.JPG


IMG_3176.JPG
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top