Milwaukee Refractometer

Gtinnel

10K Club member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 20, 2020
Messages
22,053
Reaction score
30,514
Location
Charleston, WV
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Someone local to me is selling a Milwaukee MA871 digital refractometer for a very cheap price and I was wanting to know if it would work for testing the salinity of my tank. I know the Milwaukee MA887 gets used for reef tanks fairly often but the MA871 is sold for homebrewing. From what I have read about it online it'll still work to test the salinity of water, I would just have to take the value that it gives me and convert it to ppt or specific gravity. I was hoping someone could confirm this before I buy it.
 
Personally, I think refractometers are kind of over kill. A basic $5 hydrometer that can be tested against a calibrated refractometer works just as well and never needs to be re-calibrated.

I did mine about 7 years ago. I still have both. Now I calibrate my refractometer once a year and test it against my hydrometer. Every time my hydrometer checks out at 0.005 above the refractometer. They are not very accurate out of the box. But calibrate it to a good refractometer and note the error rate. Then they never change... at least not over 7 years! And it's way easier to use.

Just my 2 cents worth.
 
I have a hydrometer that I've never liked using all that well because I dont feel like I get consistent reading. I've been using a cheap handheld refractometer that I've had for nearly 15 years and everytime I test it with calibration fluid it never needs adjusted. So I actually think that using the Milwaukee digital refractometer would probably be more work to use, but I am always interested in some new electronic gadget, ecspecially when I can get it for a phenomenal price.
 
Someone local to me is selling a Milwaukee MA871 digital refractometer for a very cheap price and I was wanting to know if it would work for testing the salinity of my tank. I know the Milwaukee MA887 gets used for reef tanks fairly often but the MA871 is sold for homebrewing. From what I have read about it online it'll still work to test the salinity of water, I would just have to take the value that it gives me and convert it to ppt or specific gravity. I was hoping someone could confirm this before I buy it.


Buy it and don't look back. Get some calibration fluid and call it a day. Definitely not overkill if you feel it works for your needs. I love mine and would never use anything else. Just my $0.02.

Also, be sure to zero it every once in a while it RO/DI water (with zero salt added).
 
I would not recommend this refractometer unless you already have it.

It is trying to measure too wide of a range and so has inadequate sensitivity/accuracy, IMO. It can work, and is probably as good as a cheap refractometer.

It has a stated accuracy of +/- 0.2 % Brix. See below, translating that to +/- 1 ppt.



Brix Refractometers

A commonly manufactured type of refractometer is called a Brix refractometer. Its scale usually reads in Brix, or % Brix (percent Brix). These refractometers are used in many industries to measure the concentration of sugar in water such as in the soft drink industry. They can be used to measure seawater’s salinity, but are not always precise enough around the range of seawater’s refractive index to be useful. A resolution of 0.2% Brix is common, and that is borderline acceptable for the reasons detailed below.

Table 4 shows the relationship between seawater salinity, refractive index and % Brix. If a refractometer has a resolution (not accuracy, but resolution, which is the finest amount it can distinguish) of 0.2 % Brix, then that translates to about +/- 1 ppt. So the best resolution would translate to 35 ppt seawater reading 34-36 ppt, which may be adequate for reef aquarists. A Brix refractometer that reads 0 to 10 % Brix with a resolution of 0.1% Brix might be a fine choice for determining seawater salinity in a reef aquarium, (although they are not inexpensive). Some Brix refractometers have a resolution of 0.5 % Brix or even 1% Brix, and they would not be suitable choices.
 
Thanks for the information and the link. I have not bought it and I guess I'll pass on it. The cheap refractometer than I have been using seems to work for my needs, so I will just stick with that.
 
Totally agree. Wish I read this before I bought mine. 3 consecutive readings with the seawater fluid they provided (supposed to be 1.025) calibrating with the calibration fluid they provided were 1.020, 1.023, 1.000.
 
I have one and i havent had any known issues, although i "Test it" with RO water before i do actual readings from my tank.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top