Mimic saddle puffer OR Valentini Puffer

[Eva Rose]

Can anyone share experiences or advice on either the Mimic Saddle Puffer (a filefish) (Paraluterus prionurus) OR the true Valentini puffer it mimics in a reef tank...
-Which picks less @ LPS & soft corals?
-Does either pester other fish (nip fins etc.)?
-I've heard the Mimic (Paraluterus prionurus) is often reluctant to feed, once in the display tank (if is housed with more active fish (like tangs or anthias). I don't know anyone who has owned a Valentini.
My husband really wants one ( either species). But I'm researching them first.

 

[sundog101]

I have a valentini puffer

1. He does not nip at coral very much
2. No problems with nipping or aggression (keep in mind I have heard of some nipping at fins)
3. He eats like a pig.

The only complaint I have is that he will eat an occasional snail or hermit. I would not keep one in a tank with small inverts.

 

[Eva Rose]

I have a valentini puffer

1. He does not nip at coral very much
2. No problems with nipping or aggression (keep in mind I have heard of some nipping at fins)
3. He eats like a pig.

The only complaint I have is that he will eat an occasional snail or hermit. I would not keep one in a tank with small inverts.

Thanks!

 

[eatbreakfast]

I've found them both to be fairly comperable. Each may nip a little, but usually not too bad.

 

[Eva Rose]

I've found them both to be fairly comperable. Each may nip a little, but usually not too bad.

Thanks!

 

[sundog101]

I've found them both to be fairly comperable. Each may nip a little, but usually not too bad.

How is the filefish around inverts?

 

[eatbreakfast]

Hermits and snails may get picked on, but anything bigger should be fine.

 

[tyler1503]

I'd get the valentini. Even if it picks at coral, it's worth it. I've never owned a fish I enjoyed more! They eat like pigs and will quickly become a favourite.
I'll be getting another when my new build is up and running