Mind blown. More zoox in anemones from low light.

  • Thread starter Thread starter 2Sunny
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

2Sunny

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 24, 2010
Messages
482
Reaction score
761
Location
Pound Ridge, NY
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So, my new anemone has twice deflated and expelled zoox. (I am not wanting to discuss this issue and respect others opinions but I am NOT a fan of Cipro and believe it does more harm than good so don't bother suggesting that.) I have seen this behavior before in my anemones of the past and so I wasn't overly concerned, but I did a quick search of Google to try and see what the scientific literature had to say when I ran across this comment:

The brown stuff that's often discharged from anemones, and coral, is actually zooxanthellae (The algae that lives within them.) This is very common with newly introduced critters. If the anemone came from a low light environment, it's likely to have a large population of zooxanthellae.

This was the total opposite of what I thought, but makes perfect sense as my tank has high light so if it were true then my anemone would be expelling zoox because it doesn't need as many zoox as it had deep in the ocean. So, I Iooked for evidence that this counterintuitive fact might be true when I found this study:

Depth Influence on the Zooxanthellae Abundance and Primary Productivity of Branching and Massive Corals on Bama Beach Baluran National Park

and son of a gun the latest research shows that to be true. The study showed the zoox in coral is highly correlated with depth and INCREASES with depth. Once one thinks about it, it does seem logical as higher light give zoox more energy so lower light would require more zoox to create the same energy.

Anyways, like I said, mind blown!
 
Ok. I’m totally with you here. Everyone says they need high light etc but I honestly bet it depends on the individual and where it was harvested. If it was close to the surface, it will want more light. If not, it will like less. I’m trying acclimated a magnifica and it HATES bright light - today it expelled zoo during my white light exposure. An animal shouldn’t take months to years to acclimate to light. Listen to your individual animal.
 
so the problem is with leds, more than anything, and with leds less is more. You can always raise numbers once you get good growth and color, but if you start to high, you only get very slight decay and no growth and terrible color


Start low and work your way up. NOT the other way around
 
Having to do that says you are making the animal adjust to what you want, not the other way around. Not saying that’s bad if you need light but it is what it is. Listen to your individual animal.
 
Having to do that says you are making the animal adjust to what you want, not the other way around. Not saying that’s bad if you need light but it is what it is. Listen to your individual animal.
Nonsense. In nature you have cloudy months. Sunny days. And sunny months. Corals have billions of years of evolution adapting to various lighting conditions. The point here is it is better to go from low to high. Than high to low.
 
That makes no sense whatsoever
 
I hadn't kept an anemone since back in the power compact days. When I decided to build a small anemone only tank, I did all sorts of reading on what PAR to aim for with my light. EVERYTHING I read said "SPS level" light which, I'm assuming, means 250+ PAR.

I spent some time with a PAR meter mapping my tank and saving light "schedules" at different PAR levels. I used the dead center of my 10g cube as the reference point, and saved 125, 145, 165, 185, etc. With such a small tank I could hit 300+ with my light.

Anyway... When I added the first anemone I decided to start low and then move up, so I set my schedule to 165 PAR. The BTA I added hid for a week and the RFAs ran for shade. So I decided to lower it to 125 PAR and everything was out, puffy and happy within a few days. For now I'm just letting it ride because all 3 BTAs and the RFAs seem to be quite content with the way things are.
 
Hooz, exactly my point. Mine love lower par levels, and would not grow or split at all under SPS levels. I started with one. Now over 200 not counting the ones I gave away or sold.
 
I’ve seen my torches do this during times when my lights are on for longer than normal. My guess is that when light conditions are higher intensity or on for longer periods than the host animal is used to, the zooxanthellae reproduce inside the host at a rate higher than the host is used to. When this happens the host ejects to increased populations to maintain stasis. So it’s possible that animals that are not acclimated to a higher light intensity or photoperiod will experience zooxanthellae rejection when the populations grow faster than the host can handle. I would not recommend antibiotic treatment in this instance as this is likely an acclimation issue and not pathogen related.
 
I think @outhouse gave a pretty good argument and solid evidence to back himself up.

Corals take months and months to die from lower lighting, while corals can die/bleach over a day from high light.

Definitely take it slow if you don’t have a par meter on hand.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top