The coloring does look nice on it, the pic was taken with a crappy phone camera. I didn't think it was a Mummy Eye either but he said he was told that the owner said it was and supposely anther person claimed it was as well. He is asking $70 for the top one and $60 for the bottom one.
He used clippers of some type to cut the chalice, I told him next time use a Dremel tool. At least he did do a Iodine dip.