Mushroom ID??

johnyboy · Sep 17, 2017

Hey guys,

I have this beautiful mushroom colony and I'm dying to know the exact name of them. I think I have an idea of what they are but interested in hearing your thoughts ! Thanks !

Reef on [emoji225][emoji226]

ChiCity · Sep 17, 2017

Looks like a sweet discosoma

ritter6788 · Sep 17, 2017

ChiCity said:
Looks like a sweet discosoma

Agreed

johnyboy · Sep 17, 2017

ritter6788 said:
Agreed

I looked online and it said it's the pants dropper? I'm not sure but but this mushroom is even sicker in person it's unbelievable

nautical_nathaniel · Sep 17, 2017

Looks like it would drop your pants based on the weight of how much money you would need to bring to the store to buy it haha

johnyboy · Sep 17, 2017

pensacola-aquarist said:
Looks like it would drop your pants based on the weight of how much money you would need to bring to the store to buy it haha

lol indeed. I'm pretty sure it is the pants dropper from legendary corals!

ritter6788 · Sep 17, 2017

Unless you got it from them it's not. Even if it looks the same you don't have the lineage. It's just a discosoma. Name it what you want. Those are nice shrooms but they aren't rare or worth a ton. The common name would be a nuclear sunset shroom likely.

Just because a vendor names something and jacks up the price doesn't make it worth more or something that's rare. They are great shrooms but you can find them for $10-$30 easy.

Waters · Sep 18, 2017

I feel like I am watching Pawn Stars and the prospective seller just got shot down by the local expert lol.

DSC reef · Sep 18, 2017

ritter6788 said:
Unless you got it from them it's not. Even if it looks the same you don't have the lineage. It's just a discosoma. Name it what you want. Those are nice shrooms but they aren't rare or worth a ton. The common name would be a nuclear sunset shroom likely.

Just because a vendor names something and jacks up the price doesn't make it worth more or something that's rare. They are great shrooms but you can find them for $10-$30 easy.

+1 on this. Just like some montipora I saw recently in a sale that looked exactly the same but a vendor had 2 different names and that commanded a 200 dollar difference. No matter though, nice shrooms nonetheless.

johnyboy · Sep 18, 2017

Waters said:
I feel like I am watching Pawn Stars and the prospective seller just got shot down by the local expert lol.

I didn't get shut down but anyone. That guys opinion doesn't mean **** she just had to ruin a thread because he's jealous and doesn't have this mushroom hahaha

johnyboy · Sep 18, 2017

ritter6788 said:
Unless you got it from them it's not. Even if it looks the same you don't have the lineage. It's just a discosoma. Name it what you want. Those are nice shrooms but they aren't rare or worth a ton. The common name would be a nuclear sunset shroom likely.

Just because a vendor names something and jacks up the price doesn't make it worth more or something that's rare. They are great shrooms but you can find them for $10-$30 easy.

That can apply to the entire hobby. Get off my thread and stop trying to ruin people's threads just cause your jealous

johnyboy · Sep 18, 2017

ritter6788 said:
Unless you got it from them it's not. Even if it looks the same you don't have the lineage. It's just a discosoma. Name it what you want. Those are nice shrooms but they aren't rare or worth a ton. The common name would be a nuclear sunset shroom likely.

Just because a vendor names something and jacks up the price doesn't make it worth more or something that's rare. They are great shrooms but you can find them for $10-$30 easy.

This is the pants dropper from LC corals so shut you mouth

meir · Sep 18, 2017

johnyboy said:
That can apply to the entire hobby. Get off my thread and stop trying to ruin people's threads just cause your jealous

You asked ppl for their thoughts, if you're not interested in what ppl have to say then kindly leave the forum. But you have no right to be disrespectful to other members, and also, nobody's jealous of you or your mushroom, It's a small piece of flesh that's only worth something because other ppl say it is, my two cents.

ritter6788 · Sep 18, 2017

johnyboy said:
This is the pants dropper from LC corals so shut you mouth

I stand by what I said. Enjoy your mushroom.

meir · Sep 18, 2017

As well as you're acting like a child in this situation, a child look at these situations as everyone is jealous and trying to ruin what they have, while in actuality we are all happy for each other, each person gains their own reef gems that others may never have the chance to grab, doesn't mean we're jealous to the point of disrespect. Whatever you do, don't be rude to other members as it cheapens everyone's opinion on you.

themcnertney · Sep 18, 2017

Well then...

johnyboy said:
This is the pants dropper from LC corals so shut you mouth

ReeferBee · Sep 18, 2017

By colony you mean two or three shrooms? LOL
I hope your kidding. These are just some middle of the mall shrooms. Nothing fancy nothing special. I'm glad you like them but I highly doubt anyone is jealous

DSC reef · Sep 18, 2017

johnyboy said:
That can apply to the entire hobby. Get off my thread and stop trying to ruin people's threads just cause your jealous

Are you kidding man? Gave you honest info and wasn't rude at all and you respond like That? Nobody ruined your thread but you. What a joke. Good luck getting someone to help you out again, especially over a weed of a coral. It's a named mushroom, whoaaaaa!!!!

NewSaltWaterGuy · Sep 18, 2017

johnyboy said:
That guys opinion doesn't mean **** she just had to ruin a thread because he's jealous and doesn't have this mushroom hahaha

johnyboy said:
That can apply to the entire hobby. Get off my thread and stop trying to ruin people's threads just cause your jealous

johnyboy said:
This is the pants dropper from LC corals so shut you mouth

*begins reading thread* oh that's cool. hope someone can ID this for him.

*someone ID's this*
"NO THATS NOT IT SHUT YOUR MOUTH!"

Me: ;Nailbiting;Watching