Must I dose?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Misbar
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Misbar

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 1, 2019
Messages
112
Reaction score
96
Location
Pennsylvania, USA
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'm planning for a 25 gallon lps/ softies tank. If I use Red Sea salt https://www.bulkreefsupply.com/aquarium-salt-mix-red-sea.html and do water water changes twice a week, will there be a need to dose? (Assuming water changes using this salt will replenish the element levels).

I'm sure there are a ton of variables depending on how stocked the tank is...


Thanks,

Misbar
 
You likely won't -have- to dose if you keep up with that water change schedule, but your tank will appreciate the stability that dosing adds. It all comes down to your tank's alkalinity and calcium consumption. If it's low enough you're probably fine to handle that with water changes, but if it gets much higher than that the stability dosing offers is worth the effort.

I'm running a 40g mixed reef of mostly LPS and softies with a few small SPS frags (birdsnest and stylo) and I recently started dosing because the tank is consuming about 0.3 dKH per day. So over a seven day period my alkalinity is dropping over 2 dKH. I suspect a lot of that is being consumed by the coralline algae though so you should certainly keep that in mind even if you're just keeping LPS and softies.

Also, dosing doesn't have to be expensive. I just picked up the BRS 2-part package with the mixtures, jugs and measuring cups for less than $50 and I dose by hand each day. At my current usage rate, this should last me well over a year if not longer unless my tank's consumption increases. Sure it could get expensive if you add dosing pumps and nice dosing containers to the mix, but simple 2-part dosing by hand is dirt cheap and as I said, my tank is much happier for it.
 
Last edited:
You likely won't -have- to dose if you keep up with that water change schedule, but your tank will appreciate the stability that dosing adds. It all comes down to your tank's alkalinity and calcium consumption. If it's low enough you're probably fine to handle that with water changes, but if it gets much higher than that the stability dosing offers is worth the effort.

I'm running a 40g mixed reef of mostly LPS and softies with a few small SPS frags (birdsnest and stylo) and I recently started dosing because the tank is consuming about 0.3 dKH per day. So over a seven day period my alkalinity is dropping over 2 dKH. I suspect a lot of that is being consumed by the coralline algae though so you should certainly keep that in mind even if you're just keeping LPS and softies.

Also, dosing doesn't have to be expensive. I just picked up the BRS 2-part package with the mixtures, jugs and measuring cups for less than $50 and I dose by hand each day. At my current usage rate, this should last me well over a year if not longer unless my tank's consumption increases. Sure it could get expensive if you add dosing pumps and nice dosing containers to the mix, but simple 2-part dosing by hand is dirt cheap and as I said, my tank is much happier for it.
That seems reasonable. I guess I will start out and monitor the parameters as they grow. If they begin to take in elements to the point of instability I will attempt dosing.

Thanks for clearing this up for me guys,

Misbar
 
I've got a 15g tank and do two 2.5 gallon water changes a week with an elevated level salt.

The first year I had mostly bubbletip and rock flower nems. Plus zoa's and mushrooms. Waterchanges kept my alk and calcluim pretty stable.

But after a year of growth and some new LPS additions I'm losing about 1dkh a week. If I start missing some waterchanges I think the numbers might get out of control.

Right now I'm hand dosing, to get a feel of what my tank needs. But I still may go a different route in the future.

Dosing pump and switch to a regular level salt
Auto waterchanges and increase the amount per week.
Kalkwasser or something in the ATO

But you got 10g on me and if you stay away from the encrusters you can go a while longer than. Me. But I love them chalices.
IMG_20190815_133822.jpg

GL
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top