My Clementines or not, please vote!

[roninmagik1]

Hey all,

i traded for these My Clementine zoas. I need an opinion from everyone whether or not, these are the real deal. The person that i traded with is a nice guy, and he sent me pictures beforehand, he explained that when they're smaller, they look My Clementines, but as they get bigger, they look different. i don't know about that, if the day comes that i trade it to someone else, would i feel right representing these as My Clementines? you interweb user shall be my judge and jury! =)
So please if anyone out there can chime in, i'd appreciate it. even more cool would be if other people had pics of their my clementines, all grown up for comparison purposes!

Thanks, Jason

 

[JMMJ13902]

Definitely not "my clementine".

Here is my pic of my clementine.

My clementine should have an orange dot in the middle and the skirts are red/orange. The background should be blue/purple.

 

[JMMJ13902]

The one you posted looks like some kind of morphed from "fire&ice" zoas. Looks like it's a bad trade. Sorry

 

[hybridazn]

Yea not even close to a my clementine

 

[reid429]

Yup he ripped ya

 

[Sabellafella]

Their not,theres a bunch of zoas that come in that look exactly like that, jmm photo is them

 

[Sabellafella]

if you live in ny ill give you a 3 polyp frag for free

 

[roninmagik1]

Sabellafella, thanks for the offer, i'm in Florida though. i appreciate it anyhow, generosity like yours is one of the things that makes the community a better place! =)

 

[Sabellafella]

Sabellafella, thanks for the offer, i'm in Florida though. i appreciate it anyhow, generosity like yours is one of the things that makes the community a better place! =)

Wwc has them, they are acually one of my favorite zoas and i see you got quite a collection there lol

 

[roninmagik1]

It's ironic, but the person who i traded with, he told me he got them from a wwc live sale. I recommended he use this thread as evidence, and if wwc has good customer support, maybe they would admit they made a mistake and send him a replacement frag. He seems like a really nice guy, and i don't think he was trying to rip me off at all.

Every comment and vote says that these are not My Clementines, so thank you everyone for your input! gotta love the hive mind of the interwebs!!
Ps...thanks for the compliment, my collection is getting there, i'm slowly but surely working my way up! =)

 

[roninmagik1]

Last thing, the person I traded with was upfront with me from the start, and sent me multiple picturse, gave me a great trade, even if those aren't clementines, so I didn't get cheated or anything... He threw in a great freebie, so I still got a great trade!

 

[Sabellafella]

Last thing, the person I traded with was upfront with me from the start, and sent me multiple picturse, gave me a great trade, even if those aren't clementines, so I didn't get cheated or anything... He threw in a great freebie, so I still got a great trade!

I was about to say wwc in their livesales they have "Clementine"zoas and not "myclementine" on their livesales you never kno they might morph the same