Sleeping Giant
Proud Canadian Reefer
Like how you hooked up the skimmer overflow
My Little NPS Experiment
- Build Thread
- Thread starter 58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Sleeping Giant
Proud Canadian Reefer
That's a big setup for your skimmer. Not what I was expecting lol
Looking great so far.
Looking great so far.
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
When I started looking into the project I wasn’t planning to go that big, but everything I read seemed to basically say making a decent skimmer is easier if you just go bigger.
So I decided to skip the computer modelling and multiple prototypes and just go as big as I easily could.
So far the only thing I don’t really like about the design is the lack of clear components. Hopefully it doesn’t need too much adjustment or troubleshooting.
Thanks for the Selcon recommendation. I will try to grab some in my next order.
I am also debating when to add some macro algae and if I should add something like Oyster Feast to the feeding mix.
I am going to have to dig up some of the older pictures from the camera mounted there. I should be able to use them to get a better idea of how the gorgonian is growing and if I need to enhance my food.
Sleeping Giant
Proud Canadian Reefer
I make a concoction, lol a weeks worth
Seachem:
Reef plus-3 capful
Reef complete-3 capful
Garlic guard-1/4 capful
hikari frozen fish food:
4 cubes-Krill (orange)
4 cubes-Ocean plankton (orange)
4 cubes-mysis shrimp (purple)
4 cubes-Spirulina Brine Shrimp (green)
5-6 cubes-Baby Brine Shrimp (pink/red)
1 tsp-reef roids
10 drops- Selcon
Tank water in container until full.
It's crazy, but good, lol
Seachem:
Reef plus-3 capful
Reef complete-3 capful
Garlic guard-1/4 capful
hikari frozen fish food:
4 cubes-Krill (orange)
4 cubes-Ocean plankton (orange)
4 cubes-mysis shrimp (purple)
4 cubes-Spirulina Brine Shrimp (green)
5-6 cubes-Baby Brine Shrimp (pink/red)
1 tsp-reef roids
10 drops- Selcon
Tank water in container until full.
It's crazy, but good, lol
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
That is a crazy recipe. No wonder your tank looks so happy!
I looked at getting a couple of those frozen foods to try, but couldn’t quite come to terms with the cost of shipping.
I did end up getting some Selcon though. Will hopefully get around to trying it out soon.
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
I finally got time to get the skimmer setup and it took quite a bit of fiddling.
I am pretty sure the issue is that my pump height is a couple inches different that what I tested at. When I ran it in the actual setup there were no bubbles going into the skimmer. For a quick fix hooked an air pump up to the Venturi hose.
Seconds after startup the bubbles came up into the collection cup.
It only took a few minutes to fill my temporary collection cup (with bubbles). I am hoping after break in the skimmate will improve.
The air pipe produced a lot of bubbles.
Going to turn it off for the night. Still have a couple pvc joints to glue going into the pump, so don’t want an overnight disaster.
The bubble piles look to be shrinking already and the tank is looking significantly clearer after running for about 30 minutes.
It’s not crystal clear, but is a significant improvement from earlier today.
I am pretty sure the issue is that my pump height is a couple inches different that what I tested at. When I ran it in the actual setup there were no bubbles going into the skimmer. For a quick fix hooked an air pump up to the Venturi hose.
Seconds after startup the bubbles came up into the collection cup.
It only took a few minutes to fill my temporary collection cup (with bubbles). I am hoping after break in the skimmate will improve.
The air pipe produced a lot of bubbles.
Going to turn it off for the night. Still have a couple pvc joints to glue going into the pump, so don’t want an overnight disaster.
The bubble piles look to be shrinking already and the tank is looking significantly clearer after running for about 30 minutes.
It’s not crystal clear, but is a significant improvement from earlier today.
SaltyWaffles
Community Member
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2021
- Messages
- 34
- Reaction score
- 65
- Location
- Cleveland Ohio
- What state or country do you live in
- Ohio
I would love to know how this is going!
Sleeping Giant
Proud Canadian Reefer
Any update?
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
Will have a more detailed update soon. Just been having some issues with this guy keeping me from Reef2Reef lately.
The Sun Coral are doing well. They seem to be shooting up little ones on the open skeleton. (I have some better shots waiting to be pulled off a real camera).
The Finger Leather is not looking so hot lately. I think some of the branches are thinning and I’m not seeing many polyps out during feeding time.
Algae is still doing great.
Skimmer is working. I am not longer running a filter socks and parameters seem to be in check. Also loving how much clearer the water is.
Here is this weeks haul.
The Sun Coral are doing well. They seem to be shooting up little ones on the open skeleton. (I have some better shots waiting to be pulled off a real camera).
The Finger Leather is not looking so hot lately. I think some of the branches are thinning and I’m not seeing many polyps out during feeding time.
Algae is still doing great.
Skimmer is working. I am not longer running a filter socks and parameters seem to be in check. Also loving how much clearer the water is.
Here is this weeks haul.
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
As much as I hate going there, I ended up at the giant "LFS" for some supplies. I managed to get what I needed, but succumb to an impulse purchase. They had some cool Molluscs that I hadn't seen in any of the other LFS.
Got to say though, this place really needs to up their game. All of the fish they had were dead and the only living things they had that looked healthy enough to bring home were a couple species of Molluscs and tank full of Lobsters. I wish they had smaller Lobsters though. The ones they stock are always too big for my tank.
And don't get me started on their equipment selection, it is appalling for a place this big.
...so I have an Oyster in my tank now.
Other purchases were some coral food (clams and frozen shrimp), milk, cucumbers, and burgers.
Jokes aside, I was curious how alive some of the Little Neck Clams and Oyster I was getting were.
I diluted some fresh saltwater down to 20 ppt and cooled it way down after getting home. I was making ro/di that day, so I ran the waste into a bucket and set my tub of salt water in it. I used the water water to help keep things cool longer.
I also put an ice pack into the salt tub to get it nice and chilly for the clams, since they felt like they had just come off ice (curbside pickup, so not sure how they are stored).
After the water felt really cold I dumped the clams and oysters in.
There was also an airlift pump in the tub to keep things from being too stagnant.
It was hard to see the Oysters at first, but the clams didn't take long to open up and stick out their siphons. I fed them some Reef Roids and went to bed.
The next day I removed the clams (still looked healthy) and froze them. As cool as it would be to have one in my tank, I don't really know what they eat and have nowhere near a deep enough sand bed for them.
At this point the water had warmed up to room temperature (~20C / 68F) and I removed the inner container. This made viewing the Molluscs a lot easier. With the clams removed the Oysters were a lot easier to see.
After the disruption the Oysters opened back up. They seemed to close fairly quick if the container got bumped, so I think that means they were adjusting well. I was feeding them roughly a half teaspoon of Reef Roids twice a day.
The two days later I changed the water out with new water at a salinity of 23.5 ppt.
A day after this I picked one of the smaller Oysters that was opening and closing quickest and transferred it to my tank. The rest were still in decent shape, so this wasn't an easy choice.
So far the lone Oyster has been in my tank for about 2 days. It seems to have been fine just being dropped directly into the tank (~20C -> 23.5C and 23.5 ppt -> 35 ppt) .
I have turned the skimmer off to try to maximize particles in the water for it to eat, but I am thinking I will soon transfer it to the upper tank and turn the skimmer back on. I was originally worried it wouldn't survive and quickly foul the little tank.
The Sun Coral is still doing well. Here is a slightly better picture of the little ones that are popping up in the vacant space. I am hopeful that they will grow up to have tentacles, since the original colony does not seem to be growing theirs back.
It is almost not worth posting this photo, but the Red Finger Leather is showing some improvement. It is putting out more polyps on a couple of the branches for the past few days.
Other changes to the tank include switching to Granulated Ferric Oxide (GFO) instead of PhosGuard, and adding Selcon and PolypBooster to the food. I also tried drippping the PolyBooster into the tank before feeding a couple of times.
The switch to GFO went smoothly, phosphate levels seem to be fairly stable since switching and my initial guess on the amount to use seems to have been correct.
The addition to Selcon is still up in the air. I am not seeing any sort of miracles, but I am not seeing any obvious issues. I am going to keep using it and see what happens.
I am not impressed by the PolypBooster. So far I am seeing no difference between when I use it or don't. I have stopped using it with this tank, but plan to try it again with some photosynthetic coral later. I noticed that some of my other photosynthetic coral responded really quickly to the addition of Red Sea Reef Energy AB+, so I am hoping the PolypBooster may have similar results. The coral in this tank don't seem to respond to Reef Energy either.
I also had a good algae harvest recently, not that you could tell the difference after.
Got to say though, this place really needs to up their game. All of the fish they had were dead and the only living things they had that looked healthy enough to bring home were a couple species of Molluscs and tank full of Lobsters. I wish they had smaller Lobsters though. The ones they stock are always too big for my tank.
And don't get me started on their equipment selection, it is appalling for a place this big.
...so I have an Oyster in my tank now.
Other purchases were some coral food (clams and frozen shrimp), milk, cucumbers, and burgers.
Jokes aside, I was curious how alive some of the Little Neck Clams and Oyster I was getting were.
I diluted some fresh saltwater down to 20 ppt and cooled it way down after getting home. I was making ro/di that day, so I ran the waste into a bucket and set my tub of salt water in it. I used the water water to help keep things cool longer.
I also put an ice pack into the salt tub to get it nice and chilly for the clams, since they felt like they had just come off ice (curbside pickup, so not sure how they are stored).
After the water felt really cold I dumped the clams and oysters in.
There was also an airlift pump in the tub to keep things from being too stagnant.
It was hard to see the Oysters at first, but the clams didn't take long to open up and stick out their siphons. I fed them some Reef Roids and went to bed.
The next day I removed the clams (still looked healthy) and froze them. As cool as it would be to have one in my tank, I don't really know what they eat and have nowhere near a deep enough sand bed for them.
At this point the water had warmed up to room temperature (~20C / 68F) and I removed the inner container. This made viewing the Molluscs a lot easier. With the clams removed the Oysters were a lot easier to see.
After the disruption the Oysters opened back up. They seemed to close fairly quick if the container got bumped, so I think that means they were adjusting well. I was feeding them roughly a half teaspoon of Reef Roids twice a day.
The two days later I changed the water out with new water at a salinity of 23.5 ppt.
A day after this I picked one of the smaller Oysters that was opening and closing quickest and transferred it to my tank. The rest were still in decent shape, so this wasn't an easy choice.
So far the lone Oyster has been in my tank for about 2 days. It seems to have been fine just being dropped directly into the tank (~20C -> 23.5C and 23.5 ppt -> 35 ppt) .
I have turned the skimmer off to try to maximize particles in the water for it to eat, but I am thinking I will soon transfer it to the upper tank and turn the skimmer back on. I was originally worried it wouldn't survive and quickly foul the little tank.
The Sun Coral is still doing well. Here is a slightly better picture of the little ones that are popping up in the vacant space. I am hopeful that they will grow up to have tentacles, since the original colony does not seem to be growing theirs back.
It is almost not worth posting this photo, but the Red Finger Leather is showing some improvement. It is putting out more polyps on a couple of the branches for the past few days.
Other changes to the tank include switching to Granulated Ferric Oxide (GFO) instead of PhosGuard, and adding Selcon and PolypBooster to the food. I also tried drippping the PolyBooster into the tank before feeding a couple of times.
The switch to GFO went smoothly, phosphate levels seem to be fairly stable since switching and my initial guess on the amount to use seems to have been correct.
The addition to Selcon is still up in the air. I am not seeing any sort of miracles, but I am not seeing any obvious issues. I am going to keep using it and see what happens.
I am not impressed by the PolypBooster. So far I am seeing no difference between when I use it or don't. I have stopped using it with this tank, but plan to try it again with some photosynthetic coral later. I noticed that some of my other photosynthetic coral responded really quickly to the addition of Red Sea Reef Energy AB+, so I am hoping the PolypBooster may have similar results. The coral in this tank don't seem to respond to Reef Energy either.
I also had a good algae harvest recently, not that you could tell the difference after.
Attachments
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
I turned the skimmer back on yesterday. There was enough foam being generated from the upper tank’s drain that I needed to have it on to avoid an overflow.
Also the surface of the lower tank was starting to look pretty unpleasant.
I just moved the Oyster in to the top tank. I noticed it’s movement is slower than a couple days ago. Hopefully the higher concentration of food up top helps.
The Sun Coral looks pretty unhappy in the picture above because I just cleaned it off with the turkey baster. There was quite a bit of left over food between the polyps. It was looking quite good before that.
I am starting to suspect that the Red Finger Gorgonian (which I mistakenly called a Red Finger Leather in my last post) is being bothered by the large quantity of pods in the tank. They don’t appear to be eating it, but seem to like eating food that sticks to it.
My current plan is to see if I can blow them off a couple times a day. Hopefully that will buy me some time to think about how I want to reduce their population and help me verify that is the actual problem.
Also the surface of the lower tank was starting to look pretty unpleasant.
I just moved the Oyster in to the top tank. I noticed it’s movement is slower than a couple days ago. Hopefully the higher concentration of food up top helps.
The Sun Coral looks pretty unhappy in the picture above because I just cleaned it off with the turkey baster. There was quite a bit of left over food between the polyps. It was looking quite good before that.
I am starting to suspect that the Red Finger Gorgonian (which I mistakenly called a Red Finger Leather in my last post) is being bothered by the large quantity of pods in the tank. They don’t appear to be eating it, but seem to like eating food that sticks to it.
My current plan is to see if I can blow them off a couple times a day. Hopefully that will buy me some time to think about how I want to reduce their population and help me verify that is the actual problem.
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
Image dump. I had a nice reply, but miss clicked and lost it.
Hopefully tomorrow I have time to explain a bit more.
Short story is I lost the Gorgonian, Sun Coral is still hanging in there, started dosing vinegar again and liking the results.
Hopefully tomorrow I have time to explain a bit more.
Short story is I lost the Gorgonian, Sun Coral is still hanging in there, started dosing vinegar again and liking the results.
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
Finally got fed up with algae clogging everything. I ramped down the lighting by about an hour a day and tried removing most of it manually when I got to 0 hours a day.
Everything has been much better since. Coral are growing faster, maintenance is significantly less, and the tank looks a lot nicer inside.
Also swapped out the custom skimmer for the old Aquamaxx one. Decided to try it again while I had the other one offline for cleaning. So far it is working well. Not sure what changed, but it isn’t overflowing so far.
I think the main changes since last time are no lights, carbon dosing and mostly feeding brine shrimp now.
Also had the main heater die (failed off) last week (Eheim Jager). Tank was down at about 22C for about 2 days while I got a replacement. Coral didn’t seem to mind though. Using dual Fluval M heaters on an Inkbird now. They were the only ones in stock at the time, but if they last they will probably be my goto heater. Really like how their thermostat was pretty accurately calibrated out of the box. I never managed to get the Jager properly calibrated and was just using the Inkbird for temperature control. Now actually using the Inkbird as a backup instead of as the primary means of temperature control.
Everything has been much better since. Coral are growing faster, maintenance is significantly less, and the tank looks a lot nicer inside.
Also swapped out the custom skimmer for the old Aquamaxx one. Decided to try it again while I had the other one offline for cleaning. So far it is working well. Not sure what changed, but it isn’t overflowing so far.
I think the main changes since last time are no lights, carbon dosing and mostly feeding brine shrimp now.
Also had the main heater die (failed off) last week (Eheim Jager). Tank was down at about 22C for about 2 days while I got a replacement. Coral didn’t seem to mind though. Using dual Fluval M heaters on an Inkbird now. They were the only ones in stock at the time, but if they last they will probably be my goto heater. Really like how their thermostat was pretty accurately calibrated out of the box. I never managed to get the Jager properly calibrated and was just using the Inkbird for temperature control. Now actually using the Inkbird as a backup instead of as the primary means of temperature control.
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
ATO also got clogged with algae a while back and dumped a good portion of the reservoir into the tank. Tank was a couple millimetres from the top when I found it. That was the final issue that convinced me to try running without algae.
The Sun Coral didn’t seem too upset by the salinity swing. I think it dropped down to about 30ppt.
Brought things back into check by removing a bunch of water (to reduce water level) and letting evaporation bring the salinity back to normal.
The Sun Coral didn’t seem too upset by the salinity swing. I think it dropped down to about 30ppt.
Brought things back into check by removing a bunch of water (to reduce water level) and letting evaporation bring the salinity back to normal.
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
Good weather today and the windows were open most of the day. I think they liked that.
Currently feeding 2 cubes of frozen brine shrimp in the evening.
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
I have the Nero 3 running on random. Whatever speed it was on when feeding today was working great for this guy. It is hard to see, but looked like he caught about 4 or 5 brine shrimp.
I adjusted the timing of the pump that exchanges water between the two tanks. It will now be running when I wake up in the morning.
I am hoping to start dosing vinegar directly onto the hydroids. I tried a couple in the sump and it seemed to kill them fairly quickly.
I wanted the pump on for this so I don’t significantly change the chemistry in the upper tank for too long.
Also of note I haven’t seen any hydroids in the sump for a while. It seems like most food is fairly quickly consumed in the upper tank. Hopefully this means the vinegar treatment actually worked and they didn’t just starve around the same time.
I adjusted the timing of the pump that exchanges water between the two tanks. It will now be running when I wake up in the morning.
I am hoping to start dosing vinegar directly onto the hydroids. I tried a couple in the sump and it seemed to kill them fairly quickly.
I wanted the pump on for this so I don’t significantly change the chemistry in the upper tank for too long.
Also of note I haven’t seen any hydroids in the sump for a while. It seems like most food is fairly quickly consumed in the upper tank. Hopefully this means the vinegar treatment actually worked and they didn’t just starve around the same time.
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
Not sure if I am seeing any changes in the hydroid situation, but the coral don’t seem to mind carbon dosing in their tiny tank.
OP
OP
58e970b2-3f88-4897-87ba-5
Active Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2020
- Messages
- 228
- Reaction score
- 391
- Location
- Ontario
- What state or country do you live in
- Canada
I stopped carbon dosing in the tank. There is too much chaos in my life lately for hitting it at the right time (pumps on). Just getting down to feed the coral is tough some days.
