Need advice on cycle

  • Thread starter Thread starter Vinh
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Vinh

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 4, 2015
Messages
205
Reaction score
80
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I'm on day 19 of cycle. Seems like an eternity but I can't believe it's only been a little over two weeks. I have seen ammonia go up 4 PPM and back down to 0 PPM. I started the cycle with a shrimp. I have read so much conflicting information on ghost feeding. While I wait for nitrites to come down should I ghost feed?

Ammonia: 0 ppm
Nitrites: 7 ppm (this is a bit of a guess due to API test; definitely 5+ ppm)
Nitrates: 60 ppm (not sure if I should do a WC during cycle to reduce; nothing in tank other than dry rock and dry sand)
 
No water changes until your cycle is done, you want as much bacteria built up as possible.
Is the shrimp still decaying in the tank? Or did you remove it? Or is it gone?
 
Shrimp is gone. Since it's a 10 gallon I only used half a shrimp.
 
Would bi-spira work even if I'm in the middle of the cycle?
 
In my opinion it didn't hurt my cycling process, I use it each time I notice any sign of stress in my tank
 
I'm so tempted to try it but I'd rather just practice some patience and let it run its course. I'll see where I'm at in a couple days then consider it.

I'm still wondering if ghost feeding is necessary at this point and if I should be concerned about the rising nitrate levels?
 
Gotta keep the shrimp in the tank or a shrimp in the tank until the cycle is done. Need an ammonia source, not just a one time boost.
 
So if shrimp has completely decayed and cycle is not done I need another source of ammonia? So I guess that means I need more shrimp or ghost feed, right?
 
I always start my tank with one and only by Dr Tim , that stuff works great and you should be through your cycle in just a day or so !! IF there is an ammonia source i.e. The shrimp .. I would use a fish though, but that's just me!! Either way good luck and no water changes yet !!!
 
Another way to consider a cycle is that there's a specific finish date, not that rock is done maturing but in regards to bacteria handling a typical entry bioload, the things we want for our tank. The finite point of dry rock cycling is simply the 2-4 ppm digestion test using a high quality, non API ammonia test kit.

When the dry rocks and the water they are in can be spiked to 2-4 ppm using cleaning ammonia (speed, exact measures vs variability of shrimp decay) and that hq test kit shows true zero in 24 hours, then you can add a fish or some light coral loading and simply begin. Expect and deal with algae issues early on since the rock is highly reflective white vs allelopathic coralline, but it's generally nice to know a finite time exists in every form of tank cycling where a reasonable starting point can be found plainly.

Removing guesswork out of reefing is prime prime in being able to make a reef live a very long time. There is no harm waiting arbitrary weeks past a set point either...the point is also having the option for a repeatable starting point among new tanks as well. If you are wondering how long established bacteria will live once you stop keeping registered ammonia levels, the answer is longer than it will take you to start. Once established many modes of feed acquisition exist for nitrifers and the mixed bacteria they live among.(communal support)

these alt feed gaining factors are never considered in aquarium cycling threads, but in a microbiology thread they'd be discussing twenty ways bacteria gain feed(ammonia) even when humans withhold. First one of twenty at least: death of mixed heterotrophs in close association * decay-proteins-ammonia etc

2. Organic nutrient reserves captured in floc among crevices that takes a very long time to become inert (meanwhile is bac substrate)
 
Last edited:
I would continue with a fishless cycle... It is very hard on fish to go through the ammonia spikes that occur during a cycle and they will very likely not make it through the process... Like others have said you will need a source of ammonia throughout the cycle. Good luck, and welcome to R2R!
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top