Need Help Deciding Next next piece of lighting upgrade

SpradleBags

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 1, 2017
Messages
102
Reaction score
104
What state or country do you live in
Texas
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Tank specs
Yr old 48"x18"x30" 120 gallon with 20 gallon sump
100lbs live rock
Few brain corals, frog spawn, pearl bubble, red worm brain, couple Monti cap frags, few Zoa colonies, large green star polyps colony, candy cane coraL, trumpets, couple mushrooms, few pieces of leather coral
CURRENT eFlux DC pump 3,170 gph(running half capacity)
2 AI primes with blues and UV %115 and whites 40%)

Lighting has seemed to be sufficient for my current corals, but I want to step it up a notch and be able to add some entry level SPS and would like to see some better coral growth. I've been looking at adding a AI Hydra 26 2 puck or the ATI T5 hybrid. My question is which one would be more beneficial for my tank at this point. Which one will help the best with coral color and growth. I will eventually be adding both, but which piece do yall think would be best to add first
 
I can certainly attest when I added 4 Ati T5 bulbs to my Hydra 26 I got a much better results as far a spread and a completely different color that was much more pleasing to my eyes, I ran the tank for about 6 months like that and I really did not see any difference in growth although some of the corals had a different hue when running the T5's. Not knocking the T5's some people grow some fantastic SPS corals as their only light source.

HTH
Mark
 
Lighting has seemed to be sufficient for my current corals, but I want to step it up a notch and be able to add some entry level SPS and would like to see some better coral growth.

How are you defining "stepping up a notch"?

Are you sure the corals in the tank want more light?

Pls forgive the answering of your question with questions. :D

But I get suspicious when someone claims victory AND wants to change things all in the same sentence. ;)

A lot of times following through on a plan that begins like that ends up being a case of fixing what isn't broken, if you take my meaning.

I'd be curious how much light is going into the tank now? Do you know the PAR or lux anywhere on the surface?

I'd also be curious which corals you're looking to add, if you have any specifics in mind. (A wish list?)

You also claim you'd like to see better coral growth.

"Better growth" is almost certainly not a function of lighting, so if that's a real priority or maybe even the main priority, then I would seriously reconsider the lighting change and consider all other factors first.

Flow, chemical stability and nutritional stability are all far more likely to have a big impact on the corals health and growth. (I.e. Pumps too soft? Dosing by hand or not testing? Are you filtering N or P out of the tank?)

Another angle to consider since you claim things are going well presently is whether "better coral growth" is even a good goal to have.

"Yes" if you're farming coral, perhaps.

But if you're the coral or just a regular reef-keeper, then the answer may be No.

There is evidence that corals which grow at a more moderate pace are healthier and more resilient than faster-growing coral. 2¢

If you're for-sure on the upgrade, then I think I'd just go with the Hydra 26 upgrade and skip the rest of the plan. Maybe even replacing both Primes you have now instead of adding to them.

Hanging and wiring is simpler with just two lights, but the coverage is a little more flexible if you keep the Primes.

You'll want a light meter to make sure the corals you have don't get shocked by the new lights.

You'll have to acclimate them to the new lights with the old intensity levels before you start upping the intensity (if that's your intention).

Not sure if you're keeping any form of ULNS, but if you are be very careful making lighting changes if there's no PO4 in the water.
 
I would go with the t5 hybrid from aquatic life and just add your existing LED’s to that.. your AI primes will work with their fixtures. IMO you will see better overall results vs upgrading just the LED’s
 
I've been looking at adding a AI Hydra 26 2 puck or the ATI T5 hybrid.
Just to clarify, the ATI hybrid as in their led / T5 powermodule fixture? That would be a wonderful light and truly top notch in my opinion. Or perhaps you are referring to the Aquatic Life fixture but wrote ATI by mistake?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top