Need help what am I doing wrong?

Willy43

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Sep 28, 2016
Messages
79
Reaction score
16
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
20170326_114021.jpg
20170326_113957.jpg
20170326_114053.jpg
unnamed.jpg


My tank is seven mouths old every thing was going great all corals was growing and seemed happy. Now it looks like there starting to die. I have one that doubled it size then it died.



Phosphate undetectable with my test kit

Nitrite undetectable with my test kit

Alkalinity 8 tested with Hanna Checker

Calcium 410 to 420 tested with Red Sea

PH 8.4



I use BRS two part and dose every day I have a very low bio load so I dose Red Sea Coral Colors ABCD ones a week at 4 ml and Red Sea Reef Energy A&B ones a week at 4ml. I use SB Reef Lights they come on a 7 am with low blue and I ramp up to 12 with the lights set at 85% blue 32% white that runs till 5pm and then ramps down.

What am I doing wrong? I have some green hair algae.
 
What test kit do you have?

You corals look like the are starving. Were you feeding the lps?

Nitrates should/could be around 2 to 5 ppm
Phosphates around .05 to
.20 ppm.

Ther phosphate number is the one I was having problems with. It also the most debated. But you do need phosphates.
 
I feed around twice a week with BRS reef chili I feed the fish every day with marine S twice a day
 
Last edited:
I was wondering if that is what I was doing wrong.

I run gfo and bio pellets should I stop running them for a while and see what happens?
 
Tank may be starving with no Po4 or No3. You need some of both for corals to flourish, especially LPS corals;)
 
Check your alkalinity. From your ph I'd say it's likely high.
Also your nutrients are crazy low it seems. Are you running gfo? Or chem media with gfo?
 
I was wondering if that is what I was doing wrong.

I run gfo and bio pellets should I stop running them for a while and see what happens?
Yes. If you find you need to add back, do so very slowly and test as you go.
 
Should I add any thing or let the phosphates and nitrite come up by them self by feeding like I have been?
 
I was wondering if that is what I was doing wrong.

I run gfo and bio pellets should I stop running them for a while and see what happens?
This exact thing happened to my son's tank almost 2 years ago.
Diesel helped me through it.

Yes take gfo off line, reduce flow through bio-pellet reactor and feed. You may need to add nitrates (spectricide stump remover) and phosphates (phytofeast ). Those are what I add.

Keep testing. Since you don't really have anything else in you tank you can afford to go slow.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the help I removed bio pellets I left a small amount of GFO I have problems with green hear algae I left carbon. I have Chaeto in the sump.
 
Thanks for the help I removed bio pellets I left a small amount of GFO I have problems with green hear algae I left carbon. I have Chaeto in the sump.
Gha and most algaes will grow with even less nutrints than corals need. While your numbers are low it's a good time to scrub and add CUC so it has a hard time growing back.
 
Thanks for the help I removed bio pellets I left a small amount of GFO I have problems with green hear algae I left carbon. I have Chaeto in the sump.
I reread my thread you pull gfo off line completely but bio-pellet need to be stepped down. Reduce the flow through your reactor.

Diesel explains it on second page.

http://www.marsh-reef.org/showthread.php?t=48405
 
Gha and most algaes will grow with even less nutrints than corals need. While your numbers are low it's a good time to scrub and add CUC so it has a hard time growing back.

I have a CUC

Thank you

Water change water change water change

I just did a water change. I do around 20gl a week it is a 120 tank

Thank you



I reread my thread you pull gfo off line completely but bio-pellet need to be stepped down. Reduce the flow through your reactor.

I will read the post

Thank you
 
20170326_152931.jpg
20170326_152833.jpg
20170326_152816.jpg
20170326_152904.jpg
20170326_152931.jpg
Here are some pictures of what I have pleas over look the wiring I a working on trimming every thing out.

20170326_152939.jpg


20170326_152804.jpg
 
Magnesium is separate from the two. Part with low magnesium your calcium can't be absorbed by corals coralline algae ex.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top