Reefer525XL
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jan 13, 2017
- Messages
- 834
- Reaction score
- 604
Thought the same, however Im sure it will sell for less in the US if its ever an option.
Neptune trident
- Thread starter reefwiser
- Start date
- Tagged users None
wheelman76
New Member
- Joined
- Dec 25, 2015
- Messages
- 14
- Reaction score
- 17
I notice that everyone keeps mentioning that they plan on doing less tests than the default 4x / day for alkalinity , and 2x daily for calcium and magnesium , so they can stretch the reagents to last longer. If you listen carefully to the video , Terrence says that "you can test more often if you'd like " but he doesn't say anywhere , that you can test less often to make your reagents last longer. Once they sell you the Trident , they make a lot more money selling reagents , so I'm guessing that the default setting , is going to be the minimum that you can run each test daily , with the option of running tests more frequently if you choose.
Maybe Terence can clarify this for us ?
Maybe Terence can clarify this for us ?
Reefer525XL
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jan 13, 2017
- Messages
- 834
- Reaction score
- 604
There is another video where it is said you can test less frequent if you wanted to. I'll try and find it
Drauka99
Active Member
From asking Jim Welsh directly at MACNA he seemed to imply that 4x test per day was going to be a minimum. Has to do with the life span of the reagent. I believe he said that reagent would last around a month at that testing cycle frequency. Reagent packs (all 3) were estimated to be $40. So Alk test 4x a day and the price point for a month is $40 (~120 tests)... that's much cheaper than the $15-$20 for 25 or so tests with a Hanna and you're getting Calcium and Mag tests included in that as well.
Potatohead
Valuable Member
It's not "much cheaper" when you are forced to run eight tests per day. Right now with Hanna alk, Salifert Mag/Cal I might spend $80-100 in tests kits/reagents per year, and that's testing alk every second day and the others once a week. If you can't change the 4x/2x/2x dosing of the Trident that is $480 in reagents per year alone.
Drauka99
Active Member
What I am saying is that if you compare the number of tests then the per test cost is cheaper. My thought process is that if someone is wanting to invest in an automated water tester then they would be wanting to test more frequently than every few days or weekly. 4x per day seems like a very good compromise to saving reagent and seeing usage trends in your tank.
To me the explanation of reagent potency and lifespan seemed reasonable for the 4x per day testing, I mean what use is stretching out the reagents if they begin giving false results?
To me the explanation of reagent potency and lifespan seemed reasonable for the 4x per day testing, I mean what use is stretching out the reagents if they begin giving false results?
At this point I would hope that all but our usual detractors could give us the benefit of doubt and assume that this is not some grand evil conspiracy. More official details will follow very soon. We see this as a game-changing technology for reefkeepers, we are very excited about what we have been able to do, and ultimately bring to the hobby.
Stay tuned.
Stay tuned.
Last edited:
ShawnSaucier
Well-Known Member
I bet more than we think
Potatohead
Valuable Member
That's a lot better then
Testing alk four times a day can make sense if you can get rid of the diurnal swings, but that could only happen if alk dosing was automated based on the results. Testing mag/cal twice a day is nothing but major overkill.
alexnyc22
Active Member
Some people can afford to drive Ferrari’s and others can only afford a Honda. You ultimately get what you pay for though. If you’re willing to pay to have the luxury of having a system to test your water then you do so. If not then keep testing. R&D costs money, employees need to get paid, no matter how much it may be for the love of the hobby it’s still a business. Nobody works for free especially in today’s world.
Maximus
Valuable Member
Honda driver here, although my son drives a BMW
. I fully agree with your statement. Not everyone will be able to afford new technology. I cannot wait for this to come out and feel that the price is reasonable. If this isn't the holy grail of reefkeeping, then I don't know what is!
alexnyc22
Active Member
Honda driver here, although my son drives a BMW
I meant no offense to Honda drivers btw haha
dankreef
Well-Known Member
I think it sounds sweet. No problem upgrading here have classic. But I think they should have shot for once a day all 3. And done something different with reagent size / cost. If the dosing were 1/4 of the times that means cost would be what roughly 7 or 8$ a month . Everyone knows 4x daily is a lot.
