Never give up on a coral...

Shredded

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Oct 4, 2015
Messages
293
Reaction score
372
Location
Yukon
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I read this statement once and took it with a grain of salt but have come to have some belief in it....
Anyone have this happen to them?
I am a beginner, to coral that is. I have had marine tanks since i was 10, glass tank, undergravel filter, corner filter with floss and carbon, and a fluorescent tube, yea I'm old. So kids are grown, new house and I got back in to the hobby. Full blown 300 gallon reef about 14 months old now. I have lost a lot of coral, I feel totally stupid but I think I am learning as things have started to survive and grow. Most of the time, when a stick died, out it came, however, there are a couple of instances where I didn't do that. 3 months in, I bought some random frags glued them throughout the tank and all died. I pulled them out and trashed them. There was no doubt in my mind they were dead. No tissue, totally white and odorless. One however was glued down tight and I left it. Algae covered it, eventually coraline algae turned its bleached skeleton purple and pink. Then, a month ago, I saw a spot on it. Didn't pay much attention but the spot has continued to grow. Yesterday I put on a pair of magnifiers and that coral is coming back after a solid year of deader then dead. So a couple of months ago I bought a Red Planet. I put it about mid level, it went from red and green to red, then to brown. I pulled it down to a lower level but it was too late and it bleached and died. I left it where it was in back. It was quickly covered in the different colors of opportunistic red and green algae. Really disappointed. I hate killing things. While I was looking at the year old coral and freaking out, I glanced at the Red Planet. I was amazed to see polyps and new growth over the old skeleton. It was not just a bleached coral that was just not dead and still had life, it was plating over the old skeleton. Now I am freaked out about all those that I had thrown away. Some were expensive and very nice. Now, this probably wouldn't happen to all but wow, I will never throw another coral away!
 
Have read this happening to LPS. I have a dead bubble coral that I am really hoping it comes back. Right now it is at the algae phase :-( and there are some sponges growing on it.
 
Posted a thread on this I little while ago, and I will still swear to it. Red Planet is THE hardiest Acropora. I have had very similar experiences with this one, amazing isn't it?
 
I currently have a miami orchid that I have revived from 1 polyp it’s about 3” big now
 
I have never heard of this happening to coral that was grown over by algae coming back from the dead.
I hope it is true, and I am wondering if that is where “Jesus Stag” got its name from?

Following, and I do believe in the other Jesus.
Thanks for starting this thread.
 
I have a JF BeachBum that had algae grow all over it and looked dead... no color or anything... i had it in a frag tank... just recently put it in my reefer xl 425 and the algae was eaten up and the piece is slowly coming back... ill get a good picture of it tonight... I thought for sure it was a goner, but couldnt give up on it... very excited about this!!!
 
I will try to get a pic of the 1 year old dead piece this evening and post it. I have had a coral bleach before and not die. Once moved to a better location they repopulated their zooxanthellae and are doing well. I had several recently get a bleached spot, no color, bone white and no polyp extension while the rest of the coral looked amazing with full color and pe but within a week the area returned to normal. Have no idea why. The reason that I bought the magnifiers was to be able to examine coral closely. The Red Planet, while I am definitely thrilled as this is my second one and can't figure out what I am doing wrong, doesn't blow me away as much as the other. To describe how it looked is best said as being a piece of coral rubble. I guess it just takes one cell to survive somewhere deep in the coral.
 
Last edited:
I will try to get a pic of the 1 year old dead piece this evening and post it.
Interestingly, I just had a similar experience. I had a dead coral that had started to algae over so I pulled it and tossed it. That was over 6 months ago. This week I noticed something odd growing on the rock where it used to be. Sure enough I have a new tiny coral growing in that spot. It must have left just enough living material behind when I pulled it to keep growing unnoticed.
 
Interestingly, I just had a similar experience. I had a dead coral that had started to algae over so I pulled it and tossed it. That was over 6 months ago. This week I noticed something odd growing on the rock where it used to be. Sure enough I have a new tiny coral growing in that spot. It must have left just enough living material behind when I pulled it to keep growing unnoticed.
I had something similar, I bought a rather large red montipora capricornis and it died for one reason and another, so I pulled it out, but maybe four months after, that I noticed a very small red coral growing out of where the large coral had once been. Now today it is still growing nicely.
I am starting to believe these corals in our tanks can come back from just about anything.
 
I fragged a few frags i felt were goners 2 have come back, last night I was able to grab the tip of my strawberry shortcake pray for me since this is my 2nd Attempt those really hate Kh swings
 
Last edited:
Here is a terrible frame grab from a video. R2R is not too advanced on video uploads I have found. If you look close at the algae covered plug on the sand you can see a tiny green patch and some small polyps. This is a red planet frag that was completely dead, visually. I knocked it off the rock months ago. Just recently did some work to get this particular system in better shape for SPS again and to my surprise I saw this tiny area of life. I got my first frag of RP probably 8 or 9 years ago.. through countless hurricanes and tank crashes and I still have many pieces from that original frag. Very hardy coral.
IMG_2526.jpeg
 
Here is a terrible frame grab from a video. R2R is not too advanced on video uploads I have found. If you look close at the algae covered plug on the sand you can see a tiny green patch and some small polyps. This is a red planet frag that was completely dead, visually. I knocked it off the rock months ago. Just recently did some work to get this particular system in better shape for SPS again and to my surprise I saw this tiny area of life. I got my first frag of RP probably 8 or 9 years ago.. through countless hurricanes and tank crashes and I still have many pieces from that original frag. Very hardy coral.
IMG_2526.jpeg

I have a small frag that I thought was dead, some kind of monti. There was algae all over it but recently there is about 5 polyps in the centre of the algae. Will it slowly over grow the algae if I leave it alone or should I try and remove the algae from around the live centre?
 
I have a small frag that I thought was dead, some kind of monti. There was algae all over it but recently there is about 5 polyps in the centre of the algae. Will it slowly over grow the algae if I leave it alone or should I try and remove the algae from around the live centre?
You could probably lend it a helping hand and brush away some of the algae. Just be careful not to hurt the remaining polyps. I will probably remove the algae on this piece next time I do a WC just to give it a clean area to regrow.
 
I have a JF BeachBum that had algae grow all over it and looked dead... no color or anything... i had it in a frag tank... just recently put it in my reefer xl 425 and the algae was eaten up and the piece is slowly coming back... ill get a good picture of it tonight... I thought for sure it was a goner, but couldnt give up on it... very excited about this!!!

8701b42fe49d4ef7244c77eda89d018c.jpg

This is what it looked like when I got it...
4dd262743bbffd14bb693383e8214c16.jpg
78d723581a706b4cc9385f0a4d7e3840.jpg

Didnt have any pictures of it when It looked dead, but you can see its somehow coming back...
 
IMG_4767.jpg

This is my frag. It was just sitting in the frag rack and should have been removed but as you see good job I didn't.
 
To my knowledge this hasn't been observed and properly reported from out "in the wild"?

Close maybe:
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2009/apr/22/coral-barrier-reef-australia

If you think about this, it actually is probably a survival mechanism. Reefs get wiped out, storms, mass bleaching... etc. It may take a very long time for a reef to recover fully, but when conditions are right, that surviving cell can take off, but that is just a blip in the time earths timeline. It is truly amazing. I took a picture of mine last night with my phone, sorry it really sucks but I don't own a nice camera. (I put all my money into this hobby, reworking my lighting now, but that's for another thread) I will try to get a better one this weekend. I have all of these corals now that have finally started growing and once I gave them all the once over last night, I spent the rest of the evening looking at this little spec of life. It is growing rapidly. Right now, it is brown and after a year, i really don't remember what the original color was!. So here it is, doesn't look like much but literally, this is a year, most of the calcium carbonate skeleton was gone, just brittle walls left and probably held together by calcareous algae and has become part of the rock. The outer black circle is the whole coral, removed from its plug originally and glued into a hole in the rock. Size comparison by the turbo snails above. The center ring is the fluffy brown life coming back from one of the corals pockets. I swear it is coral tissue. Very obvious in person, but my phone camera sucks.
IMG_7771.png
 
Had a nice stylo colony bleach completely due to a temp swing because of a malfunctioning heater during the winter. It was a nice piece, that grew between a green slimmer and a red planet. I couldn't tanke it out as I feared i would break the other colonies around it. So figured would do it sometime but never did. The colony was all white, with tissue falling off. Something I would never believe would recover.

3 months later I could see some purple polyps in some places and it completely came back. Like it is stated here, never give up, you will never know
 
Have read this happening to LPS. I have a dead bubble coral that I am really hoping it comes back. Right now it is at the algae phase :-( and there are some sponges growing on it.
i seeing same in my bubble coral...thought was dead and now tissues were growing outer part of skeleton.. so nature has something for it
 
i seeing same in my bubble coral...thought was dead and now tissues were growing outer part of skeleton.. so nature has something for it

How long from 'death' to growing new tissue?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top