New Acro Frags & "Fresh"water?!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Uriken
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Uriken

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Sep 16, 2021
Messages
165
Reaction score
147
Location
Cleveland, Ohio
What state or country do you live in
Ohio
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hello gang. I'm normally just a reader of the various posts and not a poster but I wanted to share an experience that especially at the time had me a bit ruffled that resulted in questions. I had an order of Acro frags being shipped yesterday. Due to having to work the grind everyday I asked my girlfriend (who I'm trying to educate on saltwater but at this point knows only that the hobby deals with water), if I could have them shipped to her place since she was off work and then she could get them over to my place into quarantine sooner in the day. I had a quarantine bucket with balanced saltwater prepared with a wavemaker in it running in my living room for the coral arrivals. That way she had something to put them in until I got home and could take it from there. Unfortunately I had my RODI still hooked up to the sink and was making water for drinking and dispensing it into used plastic tea jugs that were rinsed out. She had one of those days where she was in 10 directions and actually ran late and showed up 30 minutes before I got home from work (So the shipping to her house did little). Trying to hurry and have it done before I got home she grabbed my small quarantine 1 gallon tank I have; filled it with freshwater from the tea jugs I was making, and dropped in the first Acro with a small powerhead/pump. Upon leaving work I texted her to ask if things were ok. Her response was "I'm doing the corals now,....I just put the 1st one in and I'm going to get the others in the tank in a minute. I used the water your making now in the jugs." So I hurry and call as I realized my under shorts will need changed. She doesn't answer "of course". Then I send her a text to state, "That's freshwater and not saltwater!!!" To get to the point. I get home and of the 4 frags, clearly 1 was in freshwater for I don't know how long but taken back out of the tank and put into its open bag it was shipped in while the 3 others were still sealed. The quarantine tank was emptied and dried and put back away on the shelf and she said she didn't do anything yet so just relax.
My question is the coral that I know she had in the freshwater is now in question. It looks all white but I am seeing still the little colored polyps coming out of the pores slightly. Does anyone have any thought on if it would have effected it to the point it wont come back and make it? My guess is it was possibly in the freshwater for 15 minutes or more.
Also, my frags on a couple had a bit of hair algae and I usually do the peroxide scrub on the base when I see this but never did it on Acros to know if it bothers them?
Thanks for reading my long winded drama. Any suggestions or comments I'd appreciate. I hate being the guy that has fish or corals die; especially cause of things like this.
 
Maybe...? I’ve left corals out in small containers (while glueing, etc.) not realizing how quickly the temperature drops, but I haven’t had any left in RO water for any period of time. I guess just wait and see.

Semi-related, trying to lasso my better half into my fish endeavours has been... an “adventure”. So you’re not alone!
 
SOme corals can be exposed to rain water at low tide so I'd guess there's a chance it might survive. It's one of those situations to hope for the best but expect the worst.
 
I'm hoping it pulls through. I really don't know how long it was in the water as she is sticking to her story it never made it into the freshwater for the sake of an argument. I really don't care,..things happen and people make mistakes so I wouldn't be yelling and screaming over it. Id just rather know how long it was in there for the sake of maybe getting the frag to pull through even though it seems like there's not much that can be done accept wait and see.
 
Just a quick update: The coral that went for a freshwater swim at length as of last night has some color again and showing nice little hairs from the pores.
I think I may have got lucky on this one. I cant stand being the guy that kills stuff even with it being a propagated frag. Fingers crossed it stays in the positive direction.
Thanks everyone who chimed in.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top