New to this site!

Ok, just started my new tank. Should I add fish first or coral??


  • Total voters
    19
  • Poll closed .

FastandCurious

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Aug 1, 2020
Messages
225
Reaction score
368
Location
02151
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
hey all,
Ive just started my first saltwater baby and I'm excited to see what she turns into. Ive had freshwater tanks in the past but it's been a while and saltwater is sooo different! I'm almost finished my cycling and adding fish soon. Any advice for a reef tank virgin? Lol I'll any and all help I can get. Thanks!!
Screenshot_20200801-200525_Photos.jpg
 
You may want to check out this R2R article to help you get started:

 
It's a nice looking tank so far! My best advice is to not put anything you wouldn't want long term in your tank. Don't buy test run ugly paly's just to see if they will live. Don't buy a test run damsel to see if he lives. Things are hard to remove and can become invasive. So take your time and plan everything you want in your tank.

I didn't do this and ended up throwing away half my rocks because they were covered in palys and xenia. I also had a stubborn damsel that I could never catch.
 
Polish_20200506_011127297.jpg


Absolutely go slow. I would add a couple fish once your cycled completely. You still have to go through the "ugly" stage.

Best advice I can give with a completely sterile tank is to add a couple pieces of live rock to your dry rock for some biodiversity. Rock from the ocean shipped to you or some from a LFS. Helps immensely with microfauna and bacterial strains you need. Better than bottled bacteria that you can add to your tank.

The link @Peace River posted is a great read!

Great advice by everyone!
 
With what looks like all dry rock and no live rock, I’d wait a good 2-4 months before adding corals. I’d add your fish and let them get established and let the rock mature then try some easy corals.

Welcome, you’ll enjoy this side much more than freshwater.
 
It's a nice looking tank so far! My best advice is to not put anything you wouldn't want long term in your tank. Don't buy test run ugly paly's just to see if they will live. Don't buy a test run damsel to see if he lives. Things are hard to remove and can become invasive. So take your time and plan everything you want in your tank.

I didn't do this and ended up throwing away half my rocks because they were covered in palys and xenia. I also had a stubborn damsel that I could never catch.
Thanks! Yea I at first heard good things about damsels being great first fish additions but the more I read the more I realized that they are not the best fish, are territorial and can be real di*ks lol. I have a pretty good idea of what I want: pair of clowns (of course lol), Royal gamma, bengai, a benny, a Gobi and some cleaners. My 2 stars that I want to add I heard need a few more months of waiting for a more established tank: a green Mandarin and a copperband butterfly. But we'll see how it goes! Any other suggestions? I'm open and flexible to some changes =)
 
You may want to check out this R2R article to help you get started:

Ok thanks!
 
Tank looks really nice

welcome16.gif
 
Polish_20200506_011127297.jpg


Absolutely go slow. I would add a couple fish once your cycled completely. You still have to go through the "ugly" stage.

Best advice I can give with a completely sterile tank is to add a couple pieces of live rock to your dry rock for some biodiversity. Rock from the ocean shipped to you or some from a LFS. Helps immensely with microfauna and bacterial strains you need. Better than bottled bacteria that you can add to your tank.

The link @Peace River posted is a great read!

Great advice by everyone!
Thanks! I did live rock and live sand and luckily I have a pretty great salt water Aquatics store relatively close by that's helped a lot with my millions of questions lol and from whom I bought my tank that did the install. But there's so much I'm still learning. But since we've all been stuck home for the most part now I thought this might be a good time to start this bc I've been trying to for almost 2 yrs now. 'Thank god for the internet' --has been my motto for the past 2 weeks lol
 
Welcome to the fun and challenge! On the damsels, I have had success so far with a very small yellow tail that I put in last in my 29 gallon. I have two clowns and a royal gramma also. He is so beautiful! Let your other fish get well established first if you want one. But you may end up taking him back for an exchange if he does decide to be the boss of the whole tank.

1596336572171.png
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top