Newly arrived acro tenuis is White/green.

TbSaysNo

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
May 13, 2022
Messages
435
Reaction score
112
Location
Denmark
What state or country do you live in
Other International
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Is this normal? Do they just have to adjust? I turned lighting Down to 15% and it’ll slowly ramp up over the next 21 days.
image.jpg
image.jpg
image.jpg
image.jpg
second picture is a rainbow acro
image.jpg
 
I have a homewrecker that came to me like that, it's been almost a year and still looks like this, didn't grow, just base growth
 
Are you testing par before making that acclimation decision? A lot of unknowns here with your setup but usually 15% on any LED light is not gonna do a whole lot for acropora like that especially if it just came out of high par system. You may be hitting it with 0 par currently and over 21 days thats gonna cause problems. If you get some mag racks you can do 10% down acclimate lights up over a week or so while also raising the corals up using the racks. In my experience this is a nice way to do it. Just for reference in my person experience I blast acro in my tank with close to 500 par at peak hours and when I get new ones I acclimate starting at -10% par, corals are down low about 4 inches from the sand bed and move up an inch or so every day. I only do 48 hours of -10% acclimation but I bring them up the tank wall over the course of (2) weeks. This is just something that works for me and is in no way correct for everyone.
 
That's normal. I am running metal Halide and LED and I've had some that expelled All their zooxanthellae and came back. Here is an example of one that is coming back now. This was a couple of days after receiving.

20230215_214934.jpg



This is hard to see, but it's coming back gradually.

20230223_131551.jpg


I will add that PAR, water flow, and nutrients all matter A Lot!
 
That's normal. I am running metal Halide and LED and I've had some that expelled All their zooxanthellae and came back. Here is an example of one that is coming back now. This was a couple of days after receiving.

20230215_214934.jpg



This is hard to see, but it's coming back gradually.

20230223_131551.jpg


I will add that PAR, water flow, and nutrients all matter A Lot!
this coral it's almost all dead, there's even algae/dino covering most parts of it
 
this coral it's almost all dead, there's even algae/dino covering most parts of it
Think so? Here's another before and after of another Acropora Donei that I've brought back and these are all Maricultured from Indonesia. If you know anything about Maricultured, they are almost impossible to keep long term, much less bring back from death.

Before Pic, it actually deteriorated worse than this Pic :

Screenshot_20230223_134500_Gallery.jpg



This is it as of 5 minutes ago. It lost a little color yesterday as it fell into another colony and is still a bit upset. The front shot is under 14k Metal Halide so it looks a bit light, I don't edit these photos. The second shot is a top down of the same Acropora Donei, today as well.

Screenshot_20230223_134613_Gallery.jpg


Screenshot_20230223_135253_Gallery.jpg


Screenshot_20230223_134645_Gallery.jpg
 
Think so? Here's another before and after of another Acropora Donei that I've brought back and these are all Maricultured from Indonesia. If you know anything about Maricultured, they are almost impossible to keep long term, much less bring back from death.

Before Pic, it actually deteriorated worse than this Pic :

Screenshot_20230223_134500_Gallery.jpg



This is it as of 5 minutes ago. It lost a little color yesterday as it fell into another colony and is still a bit upset. The front shot is under 14k Metal Halide so it looks a bit light, I don't edit these photos. The second shot is a top down of the same Acropora Donei, today as well.

Screenshot_20230223_134613_Gallery.jpg


Screenshot_20230223_135253_Gallery.jpg


Screenshot_20230223_134645_Gallery.jpg
obviously you are experienced, hope you can bring it back!
 
Is this normal? Do they just have to adjust? I turned lighting Down to 15% and it’ll slowly ramp up over the next 21 days.
image.jpg
image.jpg
image.jpg
image.jpg
second picture is a rainbow acro
image.jpg
That is not normal. It looks like it had a rough trip. Do you have any pics of what you were purchasing though from the vendor?

@Hurricane Aquatics you did an amazing job bringing that acro colony back, but I'd still say that it arrived looking way worse for wear and I'd be unhappy with that being the received good, depending on the seller's photo.
 
obviously you are experienced, hope you can bring it back!

That is not normal. It looks like it had a rough trip. Do you have any pics of what you were purchasing though from the vendor?

@Hurricane Aquatics you did an amazing job bringing that acro colony back, but I'd still say that it arrived looking way worse for wear and I'd be unhappy with that being the received good, depending on the seller's photo.

Thank you. Yes, they definitely had a rough trip. I don't think they are that bad off. I've seen Acros come in and within 2 hours of unpacking and putting in your system, they look just like the photos of when you bought them.

I've also seen them, the majority of them, come in pale like above as they get stressed and a bit cold. There are so many variables when keeping Acropora. Flow and water quality being the most important.

I see a lot of people trying to keep a mixed reef with Acropora. It's definitely been done as there are many tanks to see. However, the flow requirements for Acropora will destroy most LPS. I'm not sure what the OP has as far as other corals or his/her parameters.

The best thing you can do is let the seller know with photos when they arrive or within a few hours of being in your tank. That way you can see how they do and follow up before any guarantee period, if there is any.
 
Are you testing par before making that acclimation decision? A lot of unknowns here with your setup but usually 15% on any LED light is not gonna do a whole lot for acropora like that especially if it just came out of high par system. You may be hitting it with 0 par currently and over 21 days thats gonna cause problems. If you get some mag racks you can do 10% down acclimate lights up over a week or so while also raising the corals up using the racks. In my experience this is a nice way to do it. Just for reference in my person experience I blast acro in my tank with close to 500 par at peak hours and when I get new ones I acclimate starting at -10% par, corals are down low about 4 inches from the sand bed and move up an inch or so every day. I only do 48 hours of -10% acclimation but I bring them up the tank wall over the course of (2) weeks. This is just something that works for me and is in no way correct for everyone.
I am not testing PAR, as i do not own a tester. My acros are currently in the middle of my 24 inch high aquarium. Due to this comment, i switched it to 50% and 7 day acclimation
 
I am not testing PAR, as i do not own a tester. My acros are currently in the middle of my 24 inch high aquarium. Due to this comment, i switched it to 50% and 7 day acclimation
Ok, best of luck and just give them some time.
 
I am not testing PAR, as i do not own a tester. My acros are currently in the middle of my 24 inch high aquarium. Due to this comment, i switched it to 50% and 7 day acclimation
Cool, keep us posted. If there's an aquarium store near you it might be worth asking if you can borrow their meter, most LFS are good about that, you could also query the local forums to see if you can get a loaner, alternatively BRS does a program where you can buy one and send it back for a small restocking fee.
 
Cool, keep us posted. If there's an aquarium store near you it might be worth asking if you can borrow their meter, most LFS are good about that, you could also query the local forums to see if you can get a loaner, alternatively BRS does a program where you can buy one and send it back for a small restocking fee.
Hi again. Update;

The acros are looking good except for the one who looked bad already. My new micromussa has shrinked today? It looked super great yeaterday
 

Attachments

  • 43A15806-7E6C-4658-A6D5-8B09BC103A99.jpeg
    43A15806-7E6C-4658-A6D5-8B09BC103A99.jpeg
    131.1 KB · Views: 36
  • 9B961915-7128-4E37-A470-3777D49E710C.jpeg
    9B961915-7128-4E37-A470-3777D49E710C.jpeg
    156.1 KB · Views: 35
  • 402F7CB3-7C11-48E5-9B75-7F1CA8BA9A11.jpeg
    402F7CB3-7C11-48E5-9B75-7F1CA8BA9A11.jpeg
    183.9 KB · Views: 34
  • 50999791-4956-456D-B9C2-5F416BAA74A1.jpeg
    50999791-4956-456D-B9C2-5F416BAA74A1.jpeg
    148.8 KB · Views: 33
Here is photos of the rest of my corals
 

Attachments

  • 699C6A5A-28BD-402D-A159-4EF6A7EED5D3.jpeg
    699C6A5A-28BD-402D-A159-4EF6A7EED5D3.jpeg
    289.7 KB · Views: 31
  • D12F28DB-5681-4708-99EC-8B6C89879277.jpeg
    D12F28DB-5681-4708-99EC-8B6C89879277.jpeg
    267.5 KB · Views: 30
  • EA4FFF28-2028-40FB-915C-5C8EE2B321E2.jpeg
    EA4FFF28-2028-40FB-915C-5C8EE2B321E2.jpeg
    52.5 KB · Views: 31
  • F94AD570-0071-450F-A72E-EFFA44CEBC21.jpeg
    F94AD570-0071-450F-A72E-EFFA44CEBC21.jpeg
    71.7 KB · Views: 27
  • 696B6F00-6BD7-4639-923B-1DC68B127F90.jpeg
    696B6F00-6BD7-4639-923B-1DC68B127F90.jpeg
    115.9 KB · Views: 30
  • 7DBCC1FF-D865-4B9D-B608-2A3A087B2A9A.jpeg
    7DBCC1FF-D865-4B9D-B608-2A3A087B2A9A.jpeg
    153.2 KB · Views: 29
  • 4FB1D10C-E7CF-41AA-BB0B-B076CFD80FA6.jpeg
    4FB1D10C-E7CF-41AA-BB0B-B076CFD80FA6.jpeg
    107.1 KB · Views: 31
  • 3BE7C87C-1898-4C22-B8AA-9856A8D0680C.jpeg
    3BE7C87C-1898-4C22-B8AA-9856A8D0680C.jpeg
    170.7 KB · Views: 31
I recently had a Tenuis bleach after being dipped in a Red Sea dip. What dip did you use? Here’s my Tenuis after dipping and three weeks later… it’s coming back. These pictures also taken under 14k halides.

DC3E9394-83B7-43D9-9E85-665BF83C953D.jpeg
EEE9481E-642B-4A3F-A0FA-2C4B75619F21.jpeg
 
I’m one of those people that will leave a coral that looks dead in the tank for much longer than most would . Sometimes they come back.

here is an acro from September 26 2021 that was almost 98% dead… algae growing on the skeleton and everything and one day I noticed some life…. The next pic is the same coral on Feb 5 2023. It looks even better today.
Good luck and don’t throw out the ugly ones on impulse! ;)
7647A219-11DE-44D8-AAF2-1A82991A84A9.jpeg
8E23CE8B-2EDC-4EC4-9538-796D4BA2FE90.jpeg
 
I recently had a Tenuis bleach after being dipped in a Red Sea dip. What dip did you use? Here’s my Tenuis after dipping and three weeks later… it’s coming back. These pictures also taken under 14k halides.

DC3E9394-83B7-43D9-9E85-665BF83C953D.jpeg
EEE9481E-642B-4A3F-A0FA-2C4B75619F21.jpeg
I did not dip my acros as I heard that they don’t like that. I firmly checked for AEFW before putting them in. I dip every other coral tho
 
I did not dip my acros as I heard that they don’t like that. I firmly checked for AEFW before putting them in. I dip every other coral tho
I’ve stopped using Red Sea dip and have gone back to Bayer. Dipping is a choice, it seems like most people and retailers who keep/ sell acros dip.
 
Cool, keep us posted. If there's an aquarium store near you it might be worth asking if you can borrow their meter, most LFS are good about that, you could also query the local forums to see if you can get a loaner, alternatively BRS does a program where you can buy one and send it back for a small restocking fee.
I talked with the vendor and they Said it looked fine, and that it still had polyps out.

this is How it looks, and How it should have looked
 

Attachments

  • 2A8338CF-0ACF-44B0-9523-B820C8D24C0B.jpeg
    2A8338CF-0ACF-44B0-9523-B820C8D24C0B.jpeg
    208.7 KB · Views: 42
  • 9198D680-869B-4FEE-B64E-740431BBFB45.jpeg
    9198D680-869B-4FEE-B64E-740431BBFB45.jpeg
    175 KB · Views: 56
  • 2C2741F1-2E6E-47EE-8980-89DD957BBAE0.jpeg
    2C2741F1-2E6E-47EE-8980-89DD957BBAE0.jpeg
    162.1 KB · Views: 60
  • 32B05058-49A5-4EC6-AA28-FBD2A96CC7DC.png
    32B05058-49A5-4EC6-AA28-FBD2A96CC7DC.png
    414.1 KB · Views: 61

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top