I received my new test kit today and I decided to test nitrates with my api first. Api shows zero. I then tested with the nyos and it showed a reading of 25-35ppm. That’s when I panicked. I tested it 3 times and it came out the same. So which one is the most accurate. The range between the two are pretty extreme. Thoughts?
Nitrates high ! Tests between api and Nyos
- Thread starter bellasdad0911
- Start date
- Tagged users None
TX_Punisher
Valuable Member
- Joined
- Jun 8, 2017
- Messages
- 1,420
- Reaction score
- 792
I believe it! I used salifert during my cycle. I was getting 20-25ppm constantly for weeks. I would take a sample to my lfs which had API. API showed 0 consistently.
After 2 months my salifert shows 5.
After 2 months my salifert shows 5.
rkpetersen
walked the sand with the crustaceans
For hobbyist level nitrate testing I'd personally go with Red Sea, Nyos, or Giesemann, in that order.
Braves Fan
Valuable Member
Whats the difference between hobbyist level nitrate testing and non hobbyist level testing,,, I am guessing that means vendors,,, how are they, non hobbyist,, testing differently than the rest of us?
I have been fighting a Nitrate battle in my tank,,, started in 100 range with my Salifert test kit
I have it down to the low end of the 25 range,,, just a tad more and I will be in the 10 range,, did a couple of large water changes,, a couple smaller water changes as the number got lower,, have been dosing 10 ml of vinegar per day,,, used a sand vacuum , ran the hose into a filter sock and cleaned the sand bed, really good,, in the tank except under my rock,,, running my skimmer wet,, feeding my fish a lot less,, any less and the fish won't be eating ,, like I said,, got the number down to the low 25 range and that number is staying there,,, for several weeks,,, cant crack into the 10 range,,, now I am wondering how good that number really is that I am getting from my Salifert test kit,, never thought about getting another test kit and trying that,,,
I have been fighting a Nitrate battle in my tank,,, started in 100 range with my Salifert test kit
I have it down to the low end of the 25 range,,, just a tad more and I will be in the 10 range,, did a couple of large water changes,, a couple smaller water changes as the number got lower,, have been dosing 10 ml of vinegar per day,,, used a sand vacuum , ran the hose into a filter sock and cleaned the sand bed, really good,, in the tank except under my rock,,, running my skimmer wet,, feeding my fish a lot less,, any less and the fish won't be eating ,, like I said,, got the number down to the low 25 range and that number is staying there,,, for several weeks,,, cant crack into the 10 range,,, now I am wondering how good that number really is that I am getting from my Salifert test kit,, never thought about getting another test kit and trying that,,,
Last edited:
tdileo
Valuable Member
Non hobbyist as in just about dead accurate. Triton test quality each time, but most people aren’t making enough extra cash to be able to afford equipment that high of quality. I don’t think it is THAT important to test nitrates, and I personally don’t even test anything except alk and once a month calcium. I just judge based off of my acros color and if they start to look weird I will test other params
Flippers4pups
Fins up since 1993
As long as everything looks good, don’t freak out. I shoot for 10-20 N03 in my system.
bellasdad0911
Active Member
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2017
- Messages
- 239
- Reaction score
- 122
Ok well that makes me feel slightly better. I just tested ammonia on my api and it reads between .25 and .50 after a dose of prime. So what does that tell me? Nitrites are dead zero. This tank is 6 months old. So should I do a 20 gallon water change ?
Flippers4pups
Fins up since 1993
Sounds like the tank recycled at some point. Not good. I would question the test kit though. Take a sample to your LFS and have them test to verify ammonia reading.
API test kit is not accurate after adding prime. Seachem says so on their website, from their faqs
I believe API is Salicylate, so I should say less reliable, rather than not accurate
I believe API is Salicylate, so I should say less reliable, rather than not accurate
Flippers4pups
Fins up since 1993
API test kit is not accurate after adding prime. Seachem says so on their website, from their faqs
Good catch!
bellasdad0911
Active Member
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2017
- Messages
- 239
- Reaction score
- 122
Interesting find, so in other words it could be a false reading. During all this madness I noticed my turbo snails spawned and I have hundreds of baby white turbos everywhere. I also noticed a pod outbreak too which is exciting.
I picked up these two colony’s today from a grand opening of a lfs locally hense why I was on overload of testing. I have been doing this for 20 years and had amazing sps dominant talks however it’s a new experience every time regardless.
I picked up these two colony’s today from a grand opening of a lfs locally hense why I was on overload of testing. I have been doing this for 20 years and had amazing sps dominant talks however it’s a new experience every time regardless.
bellasdad0911
Active Member
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2017
- Messages
- 239
- Reaction score
- 122
Tested my water tonight. Ammonia is zero. So could have been the prime causing a false reading. Nitrates still 25-30ppm on the nyos. Everything looks happy for now. Just need to drop the nitrates.
