Not a chalice? Identification help?

[cheese]

Hi everyone, I got this coral a while ago and thought it was a chalice, but I looked at it the other night, and it has a ton of tentacles out, and more flesh then I thought chalices had, could it be something else? (When the lights are on its fleshy bits are very flat, not fluffy at all) The two last photos are after the lights turned off.

 

[fishguy242]

Nice piece...
@encrustingacro Id ?

 

[lopez052308]

Maybe a echinata hard to tell

 

[skydirt]

I thought echinata also

 

[cheese]

Maybe a echinata hard to tell

After looking those up that looks pretty similar, thank you!

 

[encrustingacro]

Echinophyllia