Not Sure What to Make of This

Bryce Peterson

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Nov 29, 2015
Messages
373
Reaction score
300
Location
Odessa, Washington
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I have had this piece for 3 months. It started out brown and infested with red bugs. I just took it out of my qt after treatment. Overnight, it turned from brown to what you see now. Is it bleaching? Dying? Idk. Also have no idea what it is and what light/flow it requires. Any help would be appreciated.
20160103_112604.jpg
20160214_120840.jpg
20160103_112604.jpg
 
ahhhh. bummer. looks like it got shocked going from one to the other.
check the PH, and salinity between the 2 tanks and the light level(prob not the cause) that was likely what did it.
slow acclimation is important even tank to tank. no guarentee(I have 2 pieces that one went pale even though its the SAME FRAG cut in half and have been 3 inches from each other since ive had them.
theres a very slim chance it will pull through.
 
Water should be pretty close. I was using dt water to do a 50% water change every two days (Pico qt). The main changes were in light and flow. One thing I forgot to mention is that the frag smelled like the tide flats when I pulled it out of Qt. Actually stunk up my dt for a few days. I do see a few polyps on the base, but not very optimistic
 
Water should be pretty close. I was using dt water to do a 50% water change every two days (Pico qt). The main changes were in light and flow. One thing I forgot to mention is that the frag smelled like the tide flats when I pulled it out of Qt. Actually stunk up my dt for a few days. I do see a few polyps on the base, but not very optimistic
thats what SPS smell like in general. they secrete a mucous to act as a waterproofing and sunscreen when the tide gets so low it comes out of the water.. past that it was likely just dying.
should and is are 2 different things. check it out. I did the same thing recently. even after the new cube had settled for weeks I had a ph drop(noticed the skin on my testers coming off.) added a hob fuge and outside airline and fixed it. and waited another couple weeks:D

ill post up a pic of a tester before and after. its on my phone
 
What I did to it.
c0fa4a9d852c241447c365f23c3d0d19.jpg

1eb40ea11a0388a1a4799eb8c1dd1dae.jpg


Couple days ago
3ef05cdacfbc0fc7cdd0cc13a4065d06.jpg

095fd0f634c2c965138f91c0edfbda5f.jpg


Btw. Those pics are only about five days apart. Kinda stoked on that.
SPS newb here.

add
the bta and other sps ,toadstool favia chalice plates and zoas were not affected.

hows that for weird. scared the heck outta me.
 
What I did to it.
c0fa4a9d852c241447c365f23c3d0d19.jpg

1eb40ea11a0388a1a4799eb8c1dd1dae.jpg


Couple days ago
3ef05cdacfbc0fc7cdd0cc13a4065d06.jpg

095fd0f634c2c965138f91c0edfbda5f.jpg


Btw. Those pics are only about five days apart. Kinda stoked on that.
SPS newb here.

add
the bta and other sps ,toadstool favia chalice plates and zoas were not affected.

hows that for weird. scared the heck outta me.
I do great with everything but acros. Haven't quite figured them out yet. I have one surviving oregon tort that did a partial stn. It made a comeback, but growing very slowly.
 
When moving a coral from any tank to another tank always check the DKH and place at a low light level area of the tank. Simple things can cause great problems.
 
For mine, it was a simple tank transfer. Understand this is over the course of a month. From a JBJ 30g to a 30 cube. Ususal rinse and scrub. SPS all out of the tank into the dt, acclimated even with testing. Rinse and scrub day. Wait, wait some more test. test. sofites Back in, btas back in some stonys back in. put the small stick testers in. couple days in I saw the skin start coming off a couple. tested and the ph had dropped. No Idea why. Indor heat?
dunno. My big SPS pieces were still in the dt. so I added the hob fuge n chato and an airstone (tanks next to a window pump outside) couple 5 mil doses of kalk over the next several days. stopped the kalk, everything settled in after a week or so. waited a couple more weeks to add the Big SPS pieces(scared s less at this point).
all good now. DT and 30 always shared the same salinity and ph until that day. I dont test daily.
it was only ever the sticks that were affected. since then all taking off nicely.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top