Oh no..dang that died fast (My first dead sps)

wolfen281

Active Member
View Badges
Joined
Jun 14, 2020
Messages
156
Reaction score
176
What state or country do you live in
Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi-

Everything was fine when I went to bed. In the morning, I woke up to a completely white frag...sad.
It really happens that fast?

2-22-2022 dead coral.jpeg



All other sps corals appear fine.

This was a new frag I bought that had been in the tank for ~ 5 days. The other 5 frags, as seen in the rack, are fine.

Is this just a thing that can happen?
Should I look for a cause?
Or should I just keep things as they are and observe other corals?

Thanks for any observations/comments/suggestions

Kim


6 month old 90 gallon
Tank parameters 2/21/22 @1454
SG: 1.025
temp: 78.4
ph:8.4
dKH: 9.0
Nitrate: 1.1
phosphate: 0.04
Ca: 440
Mg: 1350
22 gal water change 2/19/22

additives:
TM All for reef dosing 12 mls/day
Microbacter 7 1X week
Korallen Sponge Power 2X/week
AcroPower 5ml every other day
Phytoplankton 30ml/day
 
Yes, it can happen that fast.

I lost two frags in the past week the exact same way.... went to bed and they were fine, next day, almost completely white.

I ran all my tests and found out that Nitrates were 0. got 0.0 on back to back Hanna nitrate tests. couldn't believe it. First time that has ever happened. my nitrates have always been low, but pretty steady between 2ppm and 5ppm, low but always there..... not sure what caused them to bottom out completely. I've been dosing nitrate for a few days now and nothing else has died off, so hopefully the losses stop with just those two frags.

I'd run a full series of tests on your tank and see if anything is out of line.
 
Yes, it can happen that fast.

I lost two frags in the past week the exact same way.... went to bed and they were fine, next day, almost completely white.

I ran all my tests and found out that Nitrates were 0. got 0.0 on back to back Hanna nitrate tests. couldn't believe it. First time that has ever happened. my nitrates have always been low, but pretty steady between 2ppm and 5ppm, low but always there..... not sure what caused them to bottom out completely. I've been dosing nitrate for a few days now and nothing else has died off, so hopefully the losses stop with just those two frags.

I'd run a full series of tests on your tank and see if anything is out of line.
It's funny because yesterday I did test the normal things, and everything was fine.

I have had issues with 0 nitrates so I dose NeoNitrate when the level starts to fall below 1.

I have not done a ICP test yet on my tank. I do have an ATI packet just waiting for me tho. Probably time to do it.

Thanks
 
Yes, sometimes that just happens with new frags. If your water tests are all good, no other corals showing signs of stress, and no recent changes, I would just chalk it up to stress from shipment/moving.
 
This is the true test! Your system appears fine. You got your rhythm, and BANG! You lost your new SPS frag.

If you are a young grasshopper you will assume that everything is chaos and start changing lights, flow, chemistry etc and then the rest of your frags will burn to the ground.

If you are a mature reefer, you will understand that some frags that underwent shipment can die. Wildcut frags are much more likely to die and freshly cut frags that were immediately sent also have a chance of dying.

Keep your head up, and focus on the future. Good luck!
 
I always check for pests with RTN. Just incase but +1 was just stressed probably and didn’t make it.

when it’s params you’ll normally see SOME STN first. If polyps open and nothing stressing any of the others definitely don’t chase anything.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top