Ok....when do you give up on going the "natural route"

I am sorry for all your trials. I have used chemi-clean in two different tanks. They are FOWLR tanks, but not solely as I have GSP in them. The Chemi-Clean did a really good job on my cyano, I did have to treat twice. A couple of months apart.

There are people with very solid beliefs on “natural” vs chemical intervention! Truth is our glass boxes aren’t natural. That being said I try to use the least products I can, but would use something if it was recommended by a trusted source. Chemi-Clean was suggested by my trusted LFS. So if you follow all the directions it can give you relief from cyano until you are able to get past your surgeries and are able to take other actions, if it doesn’t solve the problem.

I see it is returning in my 75, but it is gone from my 160 and it has been 6 months since I last used it.

I have also been dosing the 160 with NOPOX and Phosphate-E to reduce nutrients.
 
I have a microscope and will check and post parameters and pics in a day or two! I'm having a minor surgery tomorrow, so things were quite rushed today, but wanted to get the water change done before I couldn't for a week since it's been 21 days.

My understanding was that there was no other way to deal with byropsis other than the Fluconazole, Magnesium (I wasn't comfortable attempting this technique), or hydrogen peroxide (the way my rock is stacked this would have been an insane project.)

I don't know if you want all the way back to my OP, but I did add bacteria, a ****-ton if pods for weeks, have a refugium with Chaeto, dose Phyto, tried MB7, turned down lights, lots of water changes with manual removal - everything you just suggested is what I was doing for months before the byropsis started going crazy. Both the byropsis and the Cyano were there from day 1. They came with the tank. I'm more than happy to abandon the Chemclean idea and go back to everything else. Pods and Phyto will be here in 2 days :) Hadn't thought of putting more bacteria in again, but that's a good idea.

I'm honestly not one of those impatient folks - I can be quite a lazy reefer, and right now I have big back and neck problems so I try to stretch out tank work as much as possible. I just got really overwhelmed with all of the byropsis that was taking me 2 hours every few days to clean out and didn't know what else to do. Sounds like I followed the wrong advice. Seems like there is a LOT of if in the topic and that's a huge bummer.

I have a Trachy in there and a few other corals I'm nervous about cutting the lights back to 6 hours. The previous guy was running two Ai Primes and I pulled it back to one because I felt it was excessive, so they are already adjusting to that. If you think that's not a big deal I can try it, but they look so great right now I am hesitant. It's the only dang thing going right in there!
I had a GHA jungle mixed with briopsis according to my coral vendor. It covered every rock. I took the steps above along with raising magnesium to 1500 which turned the algae white on the ends and made manual removal easier. I had cleaners but added 3 urchins and 2 turbos who mowed it down. Daily removal is essential and placing the big eaters in the middle of the jungle forces them to eat their way out.

This is a battle that will not be over in weeks but in months. If you do it properly all that area with GHA and briopsis will eventually be covered in coralline which out competes it. This is what occurred in mine

If you now have dinos, which your microscope will tell you, there are natural approaches to employ but it starts with maintaining proper parameters.
 
I just found an interesting article. Did not read it all, just glanced through it.

​

 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top