Oxydators and their fight against parasites.

  • Thread starter Thread starter atoll
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
Hi,
I also saw another post you made about the use of an oxidator in a reef tank. After reading your post, I did a little research and then bought the A size for my 120gallon DT 2 days ago.

One question.
I bought it mainly to help fight an ICH outbreak.
I do qt all my fish but I only do observation. That was obviously not enough.
So I have two clowns and one tang showing white spots since one week.
The question is how should I dose the Oxidator. All the recommendations I find are only for better water quality and clarity. But I did not find anything how to propper use it in an ICH event.
I bought the 35% and I have very good RoDI water to mixe it to the recommended dosage.


Thank you so much for your answer. It would be highly appreciated

Ok, how big is your tank capacity wise and how well stocked with fish?
 
Ok, how big is your tank capacity wise and how well stocked with fish?
Its a new system, only 4 months.
fish stock:

purple tang
two spot bristhletooth tang
2 clowns
5 chromis
cleaner wrasse
Watchman goby
6 line wrasse
They are all young but really active and all eating a lot.

it’s a 120 gallon with 25 gallon sump.
not a lot of rock work and maybe 1inch sand.

thanks so so much for your advice and help.
 
Its a new system, only 4 months.
fish stock:

purple tang
two spot bristhletooth tang
2 clowns
5 chromis
cleaner wrasse
Watchman goby
6 line wrasse
They are all young but really active and all eating a lot.

it’s a 120 gallon with 25 gallon sump.
not a lot of rock work and maybe 1inch sand.

thanks so so much for your advice and help.
12% with 2 catalysts in that case. The peroxide in will last you about a week
 
Hi,
I also saw another post you made about the use of an oxidator in a reef tank. After reading your post, I did a little research and then bought the A size for my 120gallon DT 2 days ago.

One question.
I bought it mainly to help fight an ICH outbreak.
I do qt all my fish but I only do observation. That was obviously not enough.
So I have two clowns and one tang showing white spots since one week.
The question is how should I dose the Oxidator. All the recommendations I find are only for better water quality and clarity. But I did not find anything how to propper use it in an ICH event.
I bought the 35% and I have very good RoDI water to mixe it to the recommended dosage.


Thank you so much for your answer. It would be highly appreciated
I once had two clowns getting ich in my DT. The way I treated this was to take out the clowns and use the tank transfer method (I used buckets). In this way - I took away the infection source for a week. At the same time - I let my Oxydator run in the DT in order to take care for newly hatched larvaes. It was a lower concentration compared with Atoll´s suggestion (6 %) but I did nor dare to run it higher because I had a lot of corals in the tank. Today I run 12 % and 3 catalyst in a heavily stocked coral tank without problems - you learn by doing. I would prefer to take out the affected fish and do a daily bucket transfer for 7 days with them. I use 10 L buckets - a power head and prepare a new bucket with 50% new water and 50 % old water every day. Move the fishes with a net and NO feeding. If you feel you must feed - feed around 5 hours before the transfer but very little. Keep the buckets in the dark and in room temperature.

Sincerely Lasse
 
12% with 2 catalysts in that case. The peroxide in will last you about a week
If this is the dosing for treatment.
how long should I go with that and how would be a normal dosage after that treatment dosing?

again, highly appreciated your help!
 
I once had two clowns getting ich in my DT. The way I treated this was to take out the clowns and use the tank transfer method (I used buckets). In this way - I took away the infection source for a week. At the same time - I let my Oxydator run in the DT in order to take care for newly hatched larvaes. It was a lower concentration compared with Atoll´s suggestion (6 %) but I did nor dare to run it higher because I had a lot of corals in the tank. Today I run 12 % and 3 catalyst in a heavily stocked coral tank without problems - you learn by doing. I would prefer to take out the affected fish and do a daily bucket transfer for 7 days with them. I use 10 L buckets - a power head and prepare a new bucket with 50% new water and 50 % old water every day. Move the fishes with a net and NO feeding. If you feel you must feed - feed around 5 hours before the transfer but very little. Keep the buckets in the dark and in room temperature.

Sincerely Lasse
Hi,

thank you very much for your advice.
The clowns are not the only infected ones.
the tangs show a few spots as well and even the cleaner wrasse is scratching on the rocks.
All my fish where in 4 weeks qt before putting into the DT. But it still came in somehow.

They are all very healthy and eating a lot. Also no signs of heavy breathing or so. I think leaving them in the DT and support them with the best possible conditions will be my way to go.

thanks again.
chris
 
If this is the dosing for treatment.
how long should I go with that and how would be a normal dosage after that treatment dosing?

again, highly appreciated your help!
It's not a dosing for treatment it's a constant dose. Your not attacking the spots on the fish but hopefully the spores and assisting the fish to fight the disease through increased oxygen in the water aids the fishes respiratory system.
I have never used an Oxydator to cure white spot directly as it never becomes a problem in my tank. I have had fish with what I believe was white spot show it soon after introduction but it never took a hold in my tank and the existing fish never appeared to contract it.
 
It's not a dosing for treatment it's a constant dose. Your not attacking the spots on the fish but hopefully the spores and assisting the fish to fight the disease through increased oxygen in the water aids the fishes respiratory system.
I have never used an Oxydator to cure white spot directly as it never becomes a problem in my tank. I have had fish with what I believe was white spot show it soon after introduction but it never took a hold in my tank and the existing fish never appeared to contract it.
As I understand this, only the fish can cure it by themselves. My only option is to help them as much as I can und trust their immune system.
It is a bit frustrating, because I did put a lot of effort in qt them all. Even set up a different system for coral qt and followed the highes qt rules and it still came into my DT.

I also have a good UV system running since the beginning.
Also stress shouldn’t be a factor. Everybody in the tank is super happy.

So, oxidator is adjusted to your dosage advice and I am not so sure what else I can do.
I guess waiting and hope for the best.
 
Which type of UV-C ? Some UV-C will accelerate the breakdown of H2O2 thats goes out in the water. If you can arrange that the intake to the UV-C is in one end of the aquarium - close to the bottom and the outlet in the other hand - and also close to the bottom you will combine two ways of fighting the parasite. If you create a bottom stream - more of the freswimming parasites will enter the UV-C hence killed - the H2O2 that enter the UV-C will be "activated" of the UV-C and its radicals will spread among the bottom. (its the radicals that will kill the free swimming stage)

Sincerely Lasse
 
As I understand this, only the fish can cure it by themselves. My only option is to help them as much as I can und trust their immune system.
It is a bit frustrating, because I did put a lot of effort in qt them all. Even set up a different system for coral qt and followed the highes qt rules and it still came into my DT.

I also have a good UV system running since the beginning.
Also stress shouldn’t be a factor. Everybody in the tank is super happy.

So, oxidator is adjusted to your dosage advice and I am not so sure what else I can do.
I guess waiting and hope for the best.
I stopped using UV many years ago since I started using Oxydators. I make a lot of my own foods but also use frozen foods to which I add cod liver oil and krill oil. I make enough to feed my fish for approximately 5 days feeding 23 times per day.
So to recap.Good water quality + high oxygen content + high redox + Oxydator with 12% peroxide and 2 catalysts + real food like what the fish would eat on the reef + 2 lots of oils added to the food is what I attribute to healthy long lived disease free fish.
 
Which type of UV-C ? Some UV-C will accelerate the breakdown of H2O2 thats goes out in the water. If you can arrange that the intake to the UV-C is in one end of the aquarium - close to the bottom and the outlet in the other hand - and also close to the bottom you will combine two ways of fighting the parasite. If you create a bottom stream - more of the freswimming parasites will enter the UV-C hence killed - the H2O2 that enter the UV-C will be "activated" of the UV-C and its radicals will spread among the bottom. (its the radicals that will kill the free swimming stage)

Sincerely Lasse
Hi Lasse,

its a UV-C from the German company Aquamedic. The inlet is coming from the overflow and the outlet is in the sump chamber where the return pump is located.
so it sucks in from the overflow and blows out at the return.
The oxidator is in the middle of the sump, so in between UV inlet & outlet.
I could install that in a different way. I could also put all corals and the inverts in the quarantine tank for some time and treat all fish in the DT.
But my problem with that is,
Everything in that aquarium is really really happy and the growth of corals, fish and my BTA is great. After putting the anemone (sunburst BTA) in the tank, it decided to walk around the tank for two days and settled right in the most perfect spot in the middle of the tank and the clowns are constantly in it and loving it.
So everything started perfect since my start in November.
“Only” the white spots on some fishes since 5 days are not planed.
But their behavior and agility are just normal ( besides some scratching).

So in short words. I am more than happy to put any effort and money into a solution but I would love to do those things without interacting with the fish, coral and everyone else in there so much.
Because I am very afraid to loose that perfect balance

I know that this thread is mainly about the oxidator but I am honestly thankful for any advice from someone with your or @atoll experience.

Thanks heaps!!!
 
I stopped using UV many years ago since I started using Oxydators. I make a lot of my own foods but also use frozen foods to which I add cod liver oil and krill oil. I make enough to feed my fish for approximately 5 days feeding 23 times per day.
So to recap.Good water quality + high oxygen content + high redox + Oxydator with 12% peroxide and 2 catalysts + real food like what the fish would eat on the reef + 2 lots of oils added to the food is what I attribute to healthy long lived disease free fish.
Thank you so much for that comment.
I am on the right path than and those comments from an experience person are giving me a lot of hope that if I don’t freak out and do “stupid” and unnecessary things, this ICH situation is manageable without doing a half restart.
 
Which type of UV-C ? Some UV-C will accelerate the breakdown of H2O2 thats goes out in the water. If you can arrange that the intake to the UV-C is in one end of the aquarium - close to the bottom and the outlet in the other hand - and also close to the bottom you will combine two ways of fighting the parasite. If you create a bottom stream - more of the freswimming parasites will enter the UV-C hence killed - the H2O2 that enter the UV-C will be "activated" of the UV-C and its radicals will spread among the bottom. (its the radicals that will kill the free swimming stage)

Sincerely Lasse
Thank you so much for that comment.
I am on the right path than and those comments from an experience person are giving me a lot of hope that if I don’t freak out and do “stupid” and unnecessary things, this ICH situation is manageable without doing a half restart.
Good luck and be sure to keep us posted.
 
its a UV-C from the German company Aquamedic. The inlet is coming from the overflow and the outlet is in the sump chamber where the return pump is located.
I do not really know their lamps but I found some description of them that indicate that this PL-L lamps are of the type that catalyze H2O2.

The Ich parasite is hatch in the sand or substrate. UV-C without combination with peroxide can only kill the larvae inside the UV-C - it means that the newly hatched larvae must be sucked up by the UV-C before they hit a fish. If the intake to the UV-C is in the bottom of the aquarium and you have a stream in the bottom forward to the inlet - the chance that the newly hatched parasite will be sucked up and killed is much, much higher

If you temporary put the oxidator in the DT - it could be more effective. You will see on the corals if you have a too high amount of non catalyst H2O2 coming out from the oxydator.

Sincerely Lasse
 
For those of us who are unfamiliar with oxidators, can you point us to some resources on what it is? I'm reading this thread, but not sure I actually understand what it is we're talking about. At first I thought it was like an ozone generator... now I'm thinking it's more like h2o2 dosing?
 
For those of us who are unfamiliar with oxidators, can you point us to some resources on what it is? I'm reading this thread, but not sure I actually understand what it is we're talking about. At first I thought it was like an ozone generator... now I'm thinking it's more like h2o2 dosing?
 
Thanks! This post from that thread seems to have the info I needed:

Oxydator’s: What are they how do they work and what benefits do they bring.

I have been using Oxydator’s for many years with great results in my marine tanks. They are powered by Hydrogen peroxide and help to eliminate and keep at bay cyno. An Oxydator will elevate the oxygen of the aquarium water reducing stress and aiding water quality. A number of Seahorse breeders both home and commercial employ them in their systems and have found they help with the survival rate of Seahorse fry.

Oxydator’s have been used in Europe for many years in freshwater aquariums. The peroxide is not administered directly into the tank (and so is far safer) but uses a catalyst to break the hydrogen peroxide down in activated oxygen and water. The process increases redox and helps cleans the aquarium water and keep it gin clear eliminating any yellowing. The effect in many ways is similar to ozone but no electricity is used as the Oxydator is self-powering.

I have introduced many reefers in the UK, USA and other countries to the virtues and use of Oxydator’s over the years as little appeared to be known about them.

Due to the Oxydator's oxidizing capacity, your water quality will be improved and many harmful contaminants in your water will be neutralized. Oxydator’s are also an aid to fighting algae problems.

The benefits of adding hydrogen peroxide to an aquarium in cases of acute oxygen deficiency, water putrefaction and water turbidity, spawn fungus, or for enriching the well-being of your fish have been known for a long time.

Söchting Oxydator’s breaks the Hydrogen peroxide down into oxygen (O2) and water (H2O).

The advantage: Your aquarium's water quality will be fundamentally improved and problems such as those aforementioned will be greatly hindered.

The Söchting Oxydator breaks down hydrogen peroxide into water and oxygen:2 H2O2 ----------------------------> 2 H2O + O2

My Oxydator is situated in the rear RH side of the tank almost out of view however it could just as easily be put in one of the rear filter chambers.

using the catalyst the peroxide is broken down in the Oxydator and defuses out through a pin hole under the bell housing. Only pure oxygen and water are released nothing else and no peroxide directly enters the aquarium etc..

When in use you might just be able to see some microscopic oxygen bubbles leaving the reactor for a little while while it settles down. Some of the bubbles are so small that they don't tend to rise but leave the Oxydator and drift horizontally in the water column.

I have never witnessed any adverse effects from these bubbles on any of my corals or fish. The appearance of these fine bubbles happens mainly after first introducing the Oxydator and after each refilling. From time to time larger bubbles are released esp after filling and introduction, again these are of no concern or danger. More info here.http://www.oxydator.de/english/soechting_oxydators.htmlThis is a quote from Dan Underwood, owner and operations of seahorsesource.com.

"As mentioned above, the Oxydators work by the catalyst reacting with the peroxide. This releases the gas inside the device and the gas O2 rises. As it expands. Using the recommend size Oxydator and the recommended solution, I have not been able to get a peroxide reading in a tank. When I have increased the strength several times that of the recommendation, I did get peroxide readings.

I too have done peroxide dosing on tanks. Even when dosing 5 to 10 mg/L daily, I have found the Oxydator’s worked better. My guess is because they are constantly working in a slow regulated way”

There are 4 Oxydator’s in the range the Mini, D, A and W. Note the “W” version is very large and only recommended for ponds and large systems.

MODEL SPECIFICATIONS FROM THE OXYDATOR WEB SITE. Mini D AHeight. 6cm 8.5cm 18cmDiameter 4cm 8.5cm 9cmAquarium size up to 30Ltrs 100Ltrs 400LtrsPeroxide lasting Approx 4weeks 2 -4weeks 2 to 8 weeks Each model comes with its own catalysts one each for the mini and “D” models 2 with the “A” model. More catalysts can be bought if needed but they are everlasting more or less. Up to 11% food grade hydrogen peroxide can be bought via the net in various quantities inc eBay (UK). If buying 11% then you can dilute it using RO water almost doubling the initial quantity which is very cost effective, Finally Just how long the peroxide last is influenced by a number of factors esp temperature and number of catalysts used as in the “A” model which comes with 2.
 
I stopped using UV many years ago since I started using Oxydators. I make a lot of my own foods but also use frozen foods to which I add cod liver oil and krill oil. I make enough to feed my fish for approximately 5 days feeding 23 times per day.
You mean feeding 2 to 3 times a day?
Yes?
 
I do not really know their lamps but I found some description of them that indicate that this PL-L lamps are of the type that catalyze H2O2.

The Ich parasite is hatch in the sand or substrate. UV-C without combination with peroxide can only kill the larvae inside the UV-C - it means that the newly hatched larvae must be sucked up by the UV-C before they hit a fish. If the intake to the UV-C is in the bottom of the aquarium and you have a stream in the bottom forward to the inlet - the chance that the newly hatched parasite will be sucked up and killed is much, much higher

If you temporary put the oxidator in the DT - it could be more effective. You will see on the corals if you have a too high amount of non catalyst H2O2 coming out from the oxydator.

Sincerely Lasse
I just read your post from 2018 again.
that one where you replied to Atoll. You said that in high concentration the activated oxygen could weaken the parasite.
I really believe it the advantages of the oxidator and using H2O2. It all sounds logical to me. So my question is, what would be the maximum dosage before I hurt corals or my anemone. And what are the signs of them being not happy.
Please have in mind that for me as a beginner, a deflated anemone that is basically sleeping doesn’t look much different to an unhappy one, if you know what I mean. So, if thinks go south with the fish, I would be ok to go a little towards trying the max dose but of course it would be really important to know what to look out for when it comes to unhappy (unhealthy) corals and anemones.

I just placed the oxidator next to the return pump for now to optimize the efficiency. Putting it in the DT now would cause a lot of stress, because everybody is sleeping.

Thank you
Chris
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top