Pardigm shift.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 0, Members: 0, Guests: 0)

uniquecorals

UniqueCorals
View Badges
Joined
Nov 23, 2006
Messages
13,377
Reaction score
11,088
Location
Los Angeles
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
par-a-digm noun : a typical example or pattern of something; a model.

An old expression goes, “The more things change, the more they stay the same.†That expression does NOT apply to our hobby any more. Sure the fine art of reefkeeping has stayed basically the same as it has for a generation- water changes are important, careful stocking of reefs is always beneficial, blah, blah, blah….These are more or less “Best Practices†for our hobby and remain as valid now as they ever were.

What have changed are the philosophies and applications of technique behind some of the most vigorously held beliefs in reefkeeping. I must be a frustrated taxonomist. I love to classify things for some reason. I have breached this subject before, and it's more relevant now. I like defining the reef hobby by "era", and I think we're in what I like to call the "Postmodern Era."

In our “Postmodern Era†of reefkeeping, there has been a paradigm shift of sorts. Conventions have been challenged, truths have been questioned, and some former “rules†have been re-written. We have one foot in our past history, and two eyes looking straight ahead to the future.

And that is so COOL.

Want examples of what I mean? I have plenty.

To cite one very near and dear example we've discussed here recently, I just love that we are once again feeding our systems! Not just the fishes, mind you- but the whole system-the corals, inverts, and other macrofauna.

Remember, it was not all that long ago that “nutrient poor†was our mantra, and everyone had his or her fishes-and corals- on a near “starvation dietâ€. It was believed that reefs were a true “nutrient desertâ€, and the only way to assure that we maintain the long-term integrity our little Saltwater Saharas and their inhabitants was to reduce-or in some cases- eliminate altogether-food inputs, in the belief that we would be contributing to conditions that would be detrimental to our corals if we feed them. Nitrates and phosphates were absolute evil, and you were made to feel like a big fat failure as a reefer if you had detectible levels of either. We certainly embraced this outmoded philosophy when we started our business, and our corals very soon told us we were going about things the wrong way.

Now, in this “enlightened eraâ€, reefers realize the many benefits of feeding our systems. Anemic, pallid-looking corals are no longer a common sight in the hobby- replaced by robust, colorful, and vigorously growing colonies. Common sense in feeding has once again returned, and, thanks to some great manufacturers, proper foods are available for almost all the marine life we regularly keep in our systems. If you’ve been in the hobby for the last decade, you have definitely noticed this shift in our thinking.

OK, some of you may not have held a different thought all along, advocating feeding and a more "relaxed" attitude about nutrient control and export..Perhaps you even took heat for it over the years. I'm gonna do it for the hobby- I'm gonna apologize: On behalf of reefers everywhere for the last decade or so, we're sorry. You're right. Corals should be fed- a lot. See? All better.

Paradigm shift.

UC1andquarterinch-rainbow-millie-42.jpg

Food for thought: and coral growth.

Oh, what about lighting? That most hotly-debated topic in reef keeping is no longer a source of pitched battles like it once was. It's agreed that you no longer need massive amounts of energy-wasting, heat-producing lighting to keep most animals healthy and growing-just a few dozen watts of properly configured, effectively placed, energy-efficient lighting in most cases.

Hobbyists and DIY'ers the world over have turned a creative eye towards new lighting applications, and the development of new technologies- particularly LED- has promised to literally change the way we look at our systems. Dramatic increases in energy efficiency from these new technologies will continue to pave the way for the hobby to become more affordable for everyone in the not-to-distant future. Sure, the initial expenses can be high, but the long-term (and for that matter- the short term, too!) operating costs have fallen dramatically. The ongoing operating costs of a reef aquarium- the “dream killer†for many, will once again fall to more sustainable levels with the continued evolution of these more efficient technologies.

I mean, is LED lighting saving the hobby? No, but it is making it potentially more affordable for many reefers. Paradigm shift.

Even the definition of a “reef tank†has changed. The era of defining a “reef tank†as a system dominated solely by “SPS†corals has been replaced with more creative, open-minded thought. Nowadays, it’s not uncommon to see entire systems devoted to non-photosynthetic animals, anemones, “LPS†corals, and even macroalgae. The paradigm has shifted such that all of these systems are acknowledged to be “reef tanks†by the hobby at large. The skills required to maintain any of these types of systems are almost interchangeable. It’s perfectly common to hear a hobbyist say, “That’s a cool reef†when staring enviously into an all-Ricordea-dominated system or a Zoa/Paly tank. We are all “reefers†now!


zoanthids.jpg

Call it what you want- but it's a "reef system" today.

And, for the first time in decades, it's cool to "come out of the aquarium stand" and admit that you keep freshwater systems; in fact, that you LIKE freshwater systems! Many advanced reefers are setting up freshwater planted systems, and being challenged- and even humbled- on occasion by them. The skill set is not only interchangeable with reef keeping- it's beneficial. Great FW hobbyists make awesome reefers. "Aquatic Cross Training" is here to stay. Paradigm shift.

maxresdefault.jpg

No salt in this water, but plenty of blood, sweat and tears invested.

"Intelligent" water flow has arrived! Sure, we had powerheads in the hobby as far back as the late 1970’s, but today’s internal pumps are little marvels, cranking out massive amounts of highly controllable flow with efficiencies that previous generations of hobbyists could not even dream of. Sophisticated microprocessor-based controllers are pretty much de rigueur with many of these pumps, helping even the most novice reefer to simulate natural flow patterns, tides, and even seasonal intensities. No longer do you hear of the need for “chaotic, random flow†so commonly espoused in the 1990s. Hobbyists are questioning why you "needed" banks of unsightly powerheads placed in the aquarium to create “flow patternsâ€

Nowadays, the mantra of efficiency is embraced as the flow technique of choice in our hobby. Instead of just taking recommendation to blast our reefs with alternating , inefficient flow patterns, we’re thinking about what actually takes place in the oceans, and why the animals we keep need-and benefit- from flow as much as they do from lighting. Fewer pumps, operating more efficiently-and intelligently- create results once unattainable without a battery of noisy, inefficient pumps. Understanding of “boundry layersâ€, gas exchange, coral feeding patterns, and physiological responses to water motion have driven today’s hobbyists to think about how water movement occurs in nature, and how we can replicate this in our systems to efficiently convey the benefits to the animals we keep. Paradigm shift.

UCMP60_esDriver_Image_1500x1500-300x300 (2)x 720.jpg

"Intelligent flow" has arrived.

Need one more example?

Consider the so-called “nano†tank and how it's evolved. Not just evolved- but ARRIVED! Today's “postmodern†nano has grown up from its nutrient-laden, overstocked, under-equipped, tacky, oxygen- poor deathtrap status of years past. Thanks to pioneering hobbyists and manufacturers, the nano system is no longer being marketed exclusively as the entre into the hobby for hapless, misinformed beginners. Nanos are now being used as “testbeds†for groundbreaking new concepts by all sorts of hobbyists, and have become an engrossing, addictive subculture within the hobby.

With a new generation of hobby manufacturers turning out high quality, high-tech equipment specifically for nano applications, today’s nano tank has become not just a novelty or diversion, but a full-on alternative to the megareefs that many hobbyists felt for decades defined you as an “advanced†aquarist. Discoveries and breakthroughs are being made daily by enthusiastic reefers operating fantastically-maintained, properly-equipped nano systems. Indeed, it’s entirely fair to say that many of today’s nano systems rival some of their much larger brethren from decades past.

Paradigm Shift.


image_full.jpg

Mike Cao's NPS nano. Throwing the "deathtrap" label right out the window.

There are literally hundred more examples of the paradigm shift in our “Postmodern Eraâ€, but you get the picture. With the global community created by forums like this, the most important thing in the hobby has not changed, but merely evolved- the exchange of ideas, support, and inspiration among hobbyists. The very best part of this hobby/lifestyle is the people in it, and the relationships we form as a result of our shared obsession. Sure, we may talk about different things than we did even 5 years ago, but we are still talking!

I've traveled the world and talked at tons of clubs. It's the same everywhere: We geek-out about each other’s tanks, give the occasional constructive criticism or pat on the back when it’s deserved. As reefers, we are typically social by nature, sharing stories, ideas, and more than occasionally, a frag or two (or in the case of many reefers- several dozen frags if they know you need them!). Our culture is strong, interwoven, and vital.

The big difference between today and years past is that we are now able to interact daily on a worldwide scale (Thanks to Al Gore's invention of "the inter webs", of course.), and information and breakthroughs are shared at amazing speed. Crazy rare goby accidentally bred in your reef? Put it on Facebook! Got bit by your triggerfish? Take a "selfie" and get 30 "likes" in minutes! It's a whole new world..

But in the end, it’s still all about the people and the common love we have for this crazy hobby. May that paradigm NEVER shift!

Keep looking forward- and Stay Wet.

What paradigms have you seen shift? And what impact have some of the new ideas had on your personal reef keeping journey. Are we in a truly enlightened era, or just more self aware as hobbyists than before? Discuss.

Regards,


Scott Fellman
Unique Corals


 
How do you come up with this stuff? Another great read. And, thanks for the apology, I'll try to get over my hurt feelings now. (LOL)
 
Scott, great information as always. I really appreciate that you find the time to give back. In today's age of net and the numerous books that seem to either lack the decades of experience which presents all with a large learning curve. Its important to look at how long the hobby took to get to where we are today. Thank you for your sharing and your hoby experience that turned into a great business venture. ENJOY YOUR DAY!
 
I have seen the paradigm shift, correction break and be reborn numerous time over the decades. Who remembers air driven skimmers, ug filters, bleaching dead corals, incandesent bulbs, and fish in tank cycling? things come and go in this hobby, people come and go, but the fact that we can all unite in a community, helping each other after crashes and equipment failures (Poor Turbo lost his tank in a crash), that I hope never goes away.
 
Scott, great information as always. I really appreciate that you find the time to give back. In today's age of net and the numerous books that seem to either lack the decades of experience which presents all with a large learning curve. Its important to look at how long the hobby took to get to where we are today. Thank you for your sharing and your hoby experience that turned into a great business venture. ENJOY YOUR DAY!

Thanks for the kind words..There are plenty of great books and writers out there, and lots of good reef keeping information to be had. I think the real larger issue is to glean bits of knowledge wherever possible...I learn something new almost every day, and every time I go to a club or conference to give a talk, I get some little gem that I incorporate into my own practices. The key is to be open minded, progressive, and thoughtful, without forgetting to look back and see where we've come from- and to remember that there is plenty of great stuff that is NOT outdated just because its from a few years back. One of the best reef keeping books ever, IMO, is John Tullock's "Natural Reef Aquariums"- absolutely a "bible" for any reefer. And it's from the 1990's!

And enjoy YOUR day, too

-Scott
 
I have seen the paradigm shift, correction break and be reborn numerous time over the decades. Who remembers air driven skimmers, ug filters, bleaching dead corals, incandesent bulbs, and fish in tank cycling? things come and go in this hobby, people come and go, but the fact that we can all unite in a community, helping each other after crashes and equipment failures (Poor Turbo lost his tank in a crash), that I hope never goes away.
:

rockon:

Well said! Much to be learned from the past. Sometimes it's recycled, re-imagined, and re-engineered, but there have been numerous "discoveries" and revisions made over the years that were visited many times before in the dim past (oh, 20 or so years ago- another epoch in reef keeping parlance!), all of which contributed something. Nothing is ever wasted...A bad idea can always serve as an example of what NOT to do!

-Scott
 
Speaking of that crash....I am SO gonna start quarantining my corals. To avoid a disaster like that...from a single bad bottle of flatworm exit...yup. It's worth it.

Aaaanyway....
You pretty much summed up what I know about the changes. I'd say there's been a shift in whether or not to change water....

I can happily say I keep a freshwater aquarium. It's been a bit neglected as of late...it needs some TLC...but I'm working on it. :)
1391538173824.jpg
 
I can also remember the brief period when corals started to be kept, where people said you couldnt mix corals. Bali corals would kill carribean corals, which were incompatable with Solomon islands, and Hawaiian corals, ect, and fish in coral tanks had to be from the same area as the corals you stocked. Seems foolish now, but back in the day it was the gospel truth. Many of the "rules of the reef" are actually based on outdated often factually wrong information. Bioballs were the rage for a while, and now there is more misinformation floating around about them than there is factual info. One day high flow could be labeled as bad of an idea as Under Gravel filters, and Corraline could be as big a no no as Mojano. Change is hard, but I hope the paradigm shifts farther, cause without people expieramenting with new ways of doing things, how will we ever know if what we are doing today is the reason why we have tank crashes, and maybe the best husbandry we know of, is actualy killing our beloved animals.
 
Great article as always.

I must admit I had a small amount of terror when I read your title. I hear all about paradigm shifts in my graduate classes lol.
 
Speaking of that crash....I am SO gonna start quarantining my corals. To avoid a disaster like that...from a single bad bottle of flatworm exit...yup. It's worth it.

Aaaanyway....
You pretty much summed up what I know about the changes. I'd say there's been a shift in whether or not to change water....

I can happily say I keep a freshwater aquarium. It's been a bit neglected as of late...it needs some TLC...but I'm working on it. :)
1391538173824.jpg

You're "out" now! How good does that feel?

-Scott
 
I can also remember the brief period when corals started to be kept, where people said you couldnt mix corals. Bali corals would kill carribean corals, which were incompatable with Solomon islands, and Hawaiian corals, ect, and fish in coral tanks had to be from the same area as the corals you stocked. Seems foolish now, but back in the day it was the gospel truth. Many of the "rules of the reef" are actually based on outdated often factually wrong information. Bioballs were the rage for a while, and now there is more misinformation floating around about them than there is factual info. One day high flow could be labeled as bad of an idea as Under Gravel filters, and Corraline could be as big a no no as Mojano. Change is hard, but I hope the paradigm shifts farther, cause without people expieramenting with new ways of doing things, how will we ever know if what we are doing today is the reason why we have tank crashes, and maybe the best husbandry we know of, is actualy killing our beloved animals.

Well said!

-Scott
 
Great article as always.

I must admit I had a small amount of terror when I read your title. I hear all about paradigm shifts in my graduate classes lol.

LOL, yeah- coincidentally unfortunate language choice, huh? Sorry to scare you :Cry:

-Scott
 
One of the best reef keeping books ever, IMO, is John Tullock's "Natural Reef Aquariums"- absolutely a "bible" for any reefer. And it's from the 1990's!
-Scott

This book is still a great read and I always recommend it as my first choice to any new reefer. 'Less technology, more biology'...
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%

New Posts

Back
Top