Do you have any extra calibration solutions? If you were to place them back in the solution, what would you read?
For example, I have an old pH probe (no longer in use) that read ~1 lower at all times (hence why it needed to be replaced). I can calibrate it until the cows come home, but my tank will read 7.3 and if I place it back in solution, both will read low. I'm not saying you need a new probe, but I would make sure you are calibrating correcting and your probe is working as intended before you start looking elsewhere. If you are pulling outside air and have tried a CO2 scrubber, I would be pretty surprised if you were reading 7.46 and didn't notice a difference after airing out your residence.
What is the full range. Is the 7.46 the low or is it the average. On Apex, you should be able to see the daily minimum and maximum- can you post those here.