Borrow another hanna checker from someone you're sure is calibrated correctly, use it and also use a couple of standard reagent/vial tests. See how close or how far off those tests are from your own equipment.
Even hanna checker can be calibrated incorrect or just be incorrect. And tests on the same one can vary drastically even the same day. Make sure it's clean and your reagent hasn't gotten over 90 degrees or less than 50 or so. Companies often don't tell you to store at X temp because they assume you're keeping everything in the house or that you keep you house around 72 degrees.
When testing, using any kind of test, if you get a good result you should still retest. Those incorrect reading run both ways. And the more ways you test, the better chance you have for accurate results.