PID Temp controller

[alysak6075]

Hi,

Could this be used:

https://www.ink-bird.com/products-PID-controller-ipb16.html

With this probe:

Replacement Probe for Aquarium Temperature Controllers

Keep your Bulk Reef Supply or Ink Bird Temperature Controller operating smoothly. Probe replacement should be done when the existing probe no longer holds calibration. New probes need to be calibrated before operation for proper function. We recommend the use of a separate calibration...

www.bulkreefsupply.com

and this heating element:

Titanium Heater Element

A Reliable Long-Term Heating Element! We have been on the hunt for a reliable heating element that solves a lot of the issues we currently have with other heaters in the hobby. We have always had issues with heaters that have built-in controllers and segregating the controller out from the...

www.bulkreefsupply.com

To keep the temp stable in a tank. Im specifically interested in the PID controllers.

 

[alysak6075]

bump

 

[KStatefan]

@Brew12 might be able to help with this

 

[Brew12]

I'm not sure how much benefit you would actually get from it. PID's are great for controlling temperatures (one of the most useful functions of the derivative) but normally it is used to prevent overshooting a temperature during a change in temperature setpoints.
Since the accuracy is only 0.1C, and you want stability instead of control through changes, I think there would be little to be gained.

 

[alysak6075]

I'm not sure how much benefit you would actually get from it. PID's are great for controlling temperatures (one of the most useful functions of the derivative) but normally it is used to prevent overshooting a temperature during a change in temperature setpoints.
Since the accuracy is only 0.1C, and you want stability instead of control through changes, I think there would be little to be gained.

Thank You for this!!! I appreciate it.

 

[alysak6075]

Would an Apex EB8 be a good idea to use as heater control, it has 6 solid state relays, so can take a lot of on/off cycles?
My issue is: the tank has a 1.7F swing every ~4 hours because the temp controller samples way too slow.

I was thinking of getting an EB8 + Inc-bird that will be set to 1F higher than Apex + BRS heating element = EB8 takes the on/off cycles while Inc-bird is the redundancy. That way i get safety and a stable temp?

 

[Brew12]

It depends on how large your heaters are. I don't recall off the top of my head, but the EB8 solid state relays have a fairly low current limit. They have physical relays for higher current loads. But I found my Apex with EB8 to maintain excellent temperature control.

 

[alysak6075]

i would have to see what elements would work better, but im guessing I would end up with 2 X 300w elements plugged into 2 solid state sockets. Thanks for the help!