Please identity what is growing on my dry rock.

anthonyhdo

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Jan 28, 2020
Messages
71
Reaction score
8
What state or country do you live in
Washington
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Red Sea Max E-170 with protein skimmer and media filter bad and sponge, NO sump.

The tank has cycled and has been running for about 2 months now, but I recently noticed brown patches on my dry rock and sand. The patches look like they contain tiny air bubbles. I did a water 30% water change a couple days ago and recently got some hermit crab, snails to try to combat this situation. I've also added Microbractor7. My parameters is 10ppm Nitrate and I have not tested phosphate yet.

Do I just wait it out or do I need to be proactive.
Could my lighting be causing this algae growth?

Any suggestions or help will be much appreciated!

IMG_0765.jpg IMG_0769.jpg IMG_0770.jpg IMG_0771.jpg IMG_0772.jpg IMG_0774.jpg IMG_0776.PNG
 
Dinoflagellates, its normal.
Yeah its caused by lights and nutrients in your water.
Green hair algae will most likely be next.
Id hold off on any new additions of coral till you weather this storm.
Read up on starting a new reef and what to expect.
 
Last edited:
Here's an outstanding thread on examination, identification and treatment for Dinoflagellates:

 
I might be wrong. But looks more like diatoms rather then Dino to me.

dino is usually seen at ultra low nutrient levels, Diatoms are more often seen with elevate nitrite and phosphate.

being your tank is only a few months old, my guess would be Diatoms. If so then just keep an eye on nutrients and keep them at acceptable levels and it should subside As the tank matures.
 
You might also want to reduce your photo period, 7am to 8pm (13hours) is alot specially in a new tank. Hair algae is going to hit you like a truck. Just remember tanks are closed systems, that much light pumps alot of energy into the system and trust me something in there will use it.
 
I would second diatoms. Alot of silica in dry rock harvested from quarry. Just my 2 cents
 
You might also want to reduce your photo period, 7am to 8pm (13hours) is alot specially in a new tank. Hair algae is going to hit you like a truck. Just remember tanks are closed systems, that much light pumps alot of energy into the system and trust me something in there will use it.
what do you recommend 8-5? I have my blues at 80% whites at 30% and purple at 5%. is that too high?
 
I might be wrong. But looks more like diatoms rather then Dino to me.

dino is usually seen at ultra low nutrient levels, Diatoms are more often seen with elevate nitrite and phosphate.

being your tank is only a few months old, my guess would be Diatoms. If so then just keep an eye on nutrients and keep them at acceptable levels and it should subside As the tank matures.
OK thanks, how can I tell for sure, I just don't want it to get worst then it is. I just did a 30% water change on my 45g tank, also have been feeding less and got a CUC.
 
OK thanks, how can I tell for sure, I just don't want it to get worst then it is. I just did a 30% water change on my 45g tank, also have been feeding less and got a CUC.
It will get worse before it gets better. It’s part of the tank cycling process. You will have diatoms until the silica subsides, will probably transition to cyano, then green hair algae. In about 6-8 months you’ll be through it if you manage properly.
 
I would also say Diatoms which are perfectly normal.
Has your rocks every turned brown like this before or is this the first time?
Also what size tank and light do you have?
You'll usually get the greens on the rocks after the diatom bloom goes away.

I started a recent tank a month ago with dry rock as well and I found that it helped to introduce a bunch of pods from Algae Barn combined with using Bio-spira.
 
Last edited:
Sponge uptakes silica. Last tank I set up I went to my LFS and found a piece of live rock in a low flow zone in their sumps that was covered in sponge and bought it to seed my tank. It sped up the process, or at least I like to think it did.
 
You'll receive many recommendations on duration and intensity. They are great as a starting out point just keep in mind every tank is different, your perfect schedule will have to be found by you. Too much algae dial it back, corals stretching for light dail it up, find your happy medium. How much light you can run depends on alot of things, nutrient export amount, lifestock, amount of corals, age of tank, flow ect.


what do you recommend 8-5? I have my blues at 80% whites at 30% and purple at 5%. is that too high?
 
I would also say Diatoms which are perfectly normal.
Has your rocks every turned brown like this before or is this the first time?
Also what size tank and light do you have?
You'll usually get the greens on the rocks after the diatom bloom goes away.

I started a recent tank a month ago with dry rock as well and I found that it helped to introduce a bunch of pods from Algae Barn combined with using Bio-spira.
tank is about 2 months old and this is the first time my dry rock has turned brown. I just used microbracter7 yesterday. Here is what I use for lighting

IMG_0776.PNG
 
Sponge uptakes silica. Last tank I set up I went to my LFS and found a piece of live rock in a low flow zone in their sumps that was covered in sponge and bought it to seed my tank. It sped up the process, or at least I like to think it did.
no sump, just a AIO tank. when do I get the coral line?
 
What size tank is it? Coraline will have to be introduce in order to jump start it. I used "Coraline Algae in a Bottle" for the extra nitrifying bacteria that comes with it
 
What size tank is it? Coraline will have to be introduce in order to jump start it. I used "Coraline Algae in a Bottle" for the extra nitrifying bacteria that comes with it
45g AIO tank, I heard you take a sample of a live rock then put it on the dry rock to get the coraline. You can use coraline algae in a bottle to achieve the same result? COOL
 
Looks to me like just average initial algae bloom nothing bad crabs and snails should take care of it
 
45g AIO tank, I heard you take a sample of a live rock then put it on the dry rock to get the coraline. You can use coraline algae in a bottle to achieve the same result? COOL
I don't know the height dimension for your tank but i would start maybe around 45% for your peak time with the AI Prime and Weekly ramp up 10% until you get to 80% or how ever much your corals tell you they like. I would try getting a Par meter to better find the sweet spots.

Yeah I used the purple and the pink bottles and they both come with a piece of Coraline algae on a rock that you use to seed the dry rock
 
Nice rock scape! If the brown diatoms bother you, you can lightly brush the spots with a toothbrush.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top