Polyp lab for ich

[Lonely reefer's]

Have anyone used this successfully?
I'm in a processed of using it
My tangs got ich,but still eat like a pig and healthy
Removing rocks and corals are not an option

 

[Breakthecycle2]

Yup. 4 bottles worth. It does absolutely nothing.

 

[4FordFamily]

Yup. $ bottles worth. It does absolutely nothing.

X2. Also, those spots look more like velvet to me. Pretty numerous..

@Humblefish @melypr1985 @Brew12 you guys agree?

 

[Brew12]

X2. Also, those spots look more like velvet to me. Pretty numerous..

@Humblefish @melypr1985 @Brew12 you guys agree?

It could be the blurry photos but the spots look more oval to me which would be Ich. Looks like a pretty severe case though. I'm not seeing the more circular shape that would lead me to think it is velvet.

 

[Humblefish]

The photos are too blurry to make a determination IMO.

 

[Conway23]

Love this stuff. I had the same with my regal, spotty but eats like a pig. Do a full months treatment at first, then a minimal treatment once every month or two just to keep on top of anything that may have been missed

 

[melypr1985]

The pictures are not good enough to tell exactly which is it. I do agree the polyp lab doesn't do much more than the fish's own immune system can accomplish on it's own. The ich is still there.

 

[ironman20725]

I'm using it now. Actually have a YouTube showing progress. So far my tangs are the only ones showing signs

 

[Brew12]

I have high hopes for products along these lines. It is supposed to work via oxidation which we do know can be effective. I would love to see some studies or testing done that would prove the effectiveness of these products. The question in my mind is if an oxidizer can be dosed at a strong enough level to eradicate parasites while still being reef safe. If it can be, there is a chance H2O2 will become the cheapest reef safe medication ever.

 

[Lonely reefer's]

Thanks you everyone
Since i'm not home during the week to care the tank this's the only best option that i have
All my fish are healthy i have high hope for this product. Wife fed them 6times a day at the monent
I'll report back after 4weeks

 

[klp]

Never saw a report on what happened.

 

[willow659]

Thanks you everyone
Since i'm not home during the week to care the tank this's the only best option that i have
All my fish are healthy i have high hope for this product. Wife fed them 6times a day at the monent
I'll report back after 4weeks

What happened?