protein skimmer recommendation

[kyo7878]

protein skimmer recommendation?

I'm looking for an in sump protein skimmer that's rated for 300g and can fit into my tank stand with only about 24.5" of clearance. I have looked around the web but can't seem to find one that will fit...:cry:
I have considered Reef Octopus SUPER SRO 3000INT In-Sump Protein Skimmer, height is right on 24 inches but not sure if theres enough space left to remove the cup. are there any other recommendations?

 

[reeftivo]

may want to check out the skimz sm 201 (21.8") or the JNS SK3 (23). I like the skimz

 

[Reefer831]

go with an ATB 1050 v1.5 deluxe

 

[rkaires]

ATB 1050A is 22"

 

[rkaires]

go with an ATB 1050 v1.5 deluxe

The 10.5 Deluxe is a great skimmer but it's 27" and won't fit his stand.

 

[Bouncingsoul39]

I'd avoid the Super Reef Octopus Xtreme skimmers. I got a SRO XS-200 internal a couple months ago and it's ridiculously loud compared to skimmers I've had in the past. I had to create a DIY silencer on the output, something which it should include but Coralvue decided to sell seperately for $40, and there's much discussion on RC about this problem. The noise was unbearable. Also had to put rubber feet on the bottom. All this to quiet the thing down and it's still very loud. It skims well but IMO not worth the trouble. I'd look into the SWC skimmers or the new WM/Skimz line. I wish I'd gone with one of them.

 

[kyo7878]

After a quick comparison seems like Skimz line is a bit more friendly to my wallet :bigsmile:
Thank you everyone, I really appreciate the inputs, they were very helpful 1smile1


-Andy