I have 5 tanks above 100 gallons, 3 tanks between 40-100 gallons, 2 smaller nanos and a 2g pico. I skim 24/7/365 on all of them but my 2 gallon pico at work, no room for a skimmer, and it is all shrooms and zoas anyways they like it dirty. Even though on all but one tank (excluding the pico), I have to dose nitrate and phosphate. This is even with a huge bio-load in all of them, tons of feedings, and numerous things to feed my corals and huge haddonis. I did try the no skimmer route a few times on different tanks, but it was not for me or my corals.
I do think one thing that needs to be added to this, is if you are running a skimmer, do you run wet or dry? Do you have a fuge? Do you perform "regular water changes"? These may show a little more of a pattern for those who skim and those who do not.
I run all of my skimmers more to the dry side of things, all tanks but pico have a fuge, and what is a regular water change? lol. Dose a little here, dose a little there, it is alive and pretty "All Good in the Reef Hood".