Question for Randy Holmes Farley

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hot2na
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

Hot2na

Valuable Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 5, 2018
Messages
1,108
Reaction score
873
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
You have given us alot of great and helpful information over the years. I don't know if this question has ever been asked of you : what brand of salt do you use on your home aquariums ?

or do you just mix your own ?
 
Thanks! I used normal IO for 20 years. I liked that it has lower calcium (good when using limewater) and no organics like vitamins, which allowed me to store it for a month or more I stirred and ingested (for my automatic water changes).
 
Randy...I hope this is as appropriate a place as any to find you in order to seek your counsel...

I plan on running a top off line that uses a y connection to merge with an alk line terminating as close as possible to the point just before the output reaches the tank (will be going sumpless). The point of this is, even if prophylactically, to try to avoid clogging of the alk line at its terminus.

Anticipating that I may one day add mag to the top off reservoir, and having read your previous cautionary advice against combining mag and alk, I am thinking/hoping/wondering if the amounts might be so diminimis in this potential scenario and combined for so short a period of time (before reaching the tank at which point all would be immediately dissipate after coming into proximity of a powerhead) that this scheme would largely not be problematic. All pumping would be done via various independently run and timed Litermeters so volumes would be slowly delivered (if that is germane). Occasionally, I would anticipate both lines running simultaneously and other times completely separately. The maximum tubing length where the fluids might be combined would be approximately an inch and a half or so and the maximum length of time that small volume might remain combined before ultimately being ejected into the tank would be about ten minutes.

Apologies for the verbose question; I hope it is clear and makes sense.

As always, thanks for your advice, Doc.
 
Randy...I hope this is as appropriate a place as any to find you in order to seek your counsel...

I plan on running a top off line that uses a y connection to merge with an alk line terminating as close as possible to the point just before the output reaches the tank (will be going sumpless). The point of this is, even if prophylactically, to try to avoid clogging of the alk line at its terminus.

Anticipating that I may one day add mag to the top off reservoir, and having read your previous cautionary advice against combining mag and alk, I am thinking/hoping/wondering if the amounts might be so diminimis in this potential scenario and combined for so short a period of time (before reaching the tank at which point all would be immediately dissipate after coming into proximity of a powerhead) that this scheme would largely not be problematic. All pumping would be done via various independently run and timed Litermeters so volumes would be slowly delivered (if that is germane). Occasionally, I would anticipate both lines running simultaneously and other times completely separately. The maximum tubing length where the fluids might be combined would be approximately an inch and a half or so and the maximum length of time that small volume might remain combined before ultimately being ejected into the tank would be about ten minutes.

Apologies for the verbose question; I hope it is clear and makes sense.

As always, thanks for your advice, Doc.

Magnesium hitting the alk will immediately precipitate, even in very small amounts. I think that would be worse than just leaving the alk line alone.

Manual dosing of magnesium once every week or two should be plenty adequate. It's depletion is very slow.
 
Thanks for taking the time to answer. Your accessibility, expertise and willingness to assist any and all is truly a godsend to the entire reefing community. All the best.
 
Hello Randy,

I have a question about pH and coral density. It appears that increases coral density and therefore photosynthesis should also decrease co2 and increase pH during the day. Even with decrease at night it would seems to me that the pH average would be driven upwards.

Thanks,

TTC
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top