Red Sea 625xxxl for a noob?

coraldreams

Community Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 6, 2022
Messages
45
Reaction score
29
Location
91390
What state or country do you live in
California
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So I will be a 1st time saltwater tanker, I've been watching videos and reading for weeks upon weeks
I'm feeling like the easiest way for me to start is with the red sea reefer.
Why so big? well, the more volume the fewer variations in water chem and it's the size of the space I want to fill.

I thought about buying the Red sea Tank only and researching each and every part and making a Frankenstein of best parts vs an all in one package
In your opinion. Also am I absolutely crazy to think I can pull this off as a noob I'm good with Math and science so I feel fairly confident.
I plan on moving very slowly and using a slow cycle. Additionally, I think I have decided to not use live sand or live rock to avoid possible contamination.

Thank you for your opinions

p.s I looked at Waterbox / Fiji / Innovative marine - the Red sea fits the space best
 
So I will be a 1st time saltwater tanker, I've been watching videos and reading for weeks upon weeks
I'm feeling like the easiest way for me to start is with the red sea reefer.
Why so big? well, the more volume the fewer variations in water chem and it's the size of the space I want to fill.

I thought about buying the Red sea Tank only and researching each and every part and making a Frankenstein of best parts vs an all in one package
In your opinion. Also am I absolutely crazy to think I can pull this off as a noob I'm good with Math and science so I feel fairly confident.
I plan on moving very slowly and using a slow cycle. Additionally, I think I have decided to not use live sand or live rock to avoid possible contamination.

Thank you for your opinions

p.s I looked at Waterbox / Fiji / Innovative marine - the Red sea fits the space best


Honestly I am more down with the big tank than I am the "no live rock."

I understand why the dry rock seems appealing, but 9/10 dry rock tanks have many more problems, and you end up adding hitch hikers (most of which are not that bad) when you add frags anyway. As a scientist and control freak I understand the appeal, but I personally think you will regret dry rock.

Now the idea of going with a giant kit...I get the logic...but you will learn in the first few months that you do indeed have preferences, and they may or may not be what comes with the kit.

If you're talking about a tank of that size, it's a huge investment and you're in it for the long haul, so here is my advice: try a small tank to launch your hobby, get your hands wet, and learn how to not kill corals. Buy a tank that can be later plumbed in as a frag tank, so it won't go to waste. Use it as an opportunity to learn what kind of equipment you like and make sure that you buy versions that work on the bigger tank too. This will also be a great chance to grow out some tiny frags so they look amazing when you move them to the new system. Just do it for 8 months. It will be worth it. I promise!
 
Honestly I am more down with the big tank than I am the "no live rock."

I understand why the dry rock seems appealing, but 9/10 dry rock tanks have many more problems, and you end up adding hitch hikers (most of which are not that bad) when you add frags anyway. As a scientist and control freak I understand the appeal, but I personally think you will regret dry rock.

Now the idea of going with a giant kit...I get the logic...but you will learn in the first few months that you do indeed have preferences, and they may or may not be what comes with the kit.

If you're talking about a tank of that size, it's a huge investment and you're in it for the long haul, so here is my advice: try a small tank to launch your hobby, get your hands wet, and learn how to not kill corals. Buy a tank that can be later plumbed in as a frag tank, so it won't go to waste. Use it as an opportunity to learn what kind of equipment you like and make sure that you buy versions that work on the bigger tank too. This will also be a great chance to grow out some tiny frags so they look amazing when you move them to the new system. Just do it for 8 months. It will be worth it. I promise!
Thanks for the detailed answer so you think like a 32 gal to 50 gallon?
I was afraid to go small because I'm sometimes gone for a week at a time my goal is to somehow work on an automation and try to either semi-automate water changes or have a ULM tank , I watched this video and it was intriguing. Is it really possible to do minimal monthly work and have good results ?
 
Thanks for the detailed answer so you think like a 32 gal to 50 gallon?
I was afraid to go small because I'm sometimes gone for a week at a time my goal is to somehow work on an automation and try to either semi-automate water changes or have a ULM tank , I watched this video and it was intriguing. Is it really possible to do minimal monthly work and have good results ?
There are many reefers that simply observe their tanks and dont do water changes or dose, basically auto pilot reefing. The. There’s the opposite that do religious water changes and testing. I think the most important variable you’ll find is this hobby is STABILITY. But I agree with @Chrisv. get something that you can utilize later. That is a large tank tbh. Maybe don’t start with a pico, but a larger nano 40ish gallons or jump into a 75gal so your options for swimmer increases heavily. That’s still approx 1/2 your volume and gives you plenty to learn. I used dry rock with a lot of patience, but I DID use live sand. I let my tank ‘cycle’ for 2mo before adding fish. It can be done, but I would find a trusted source and bum a rock off them. It will help your bacteria growth on an entirely other level.
 
Thanks for the detailed answer so you think like a 32 gal to 50 gallon?
I was afraid to go small because I'm sometimes gone for a week at a time my goal is to somehow work on an automation and try to either semi-automate water changes or have a ULM tank , I watched this video and it was intriguing. Is it really possible to do minimal monthly work and have good results ?

I think that being gone for a week at a time isn't a huge huge issue. As far as manual maintenance goes, the best maintenance is the maintenance you actually do. Get yourself a good RO system from the beginning. A good ATO. Those can both be used on your future big tank. If you have a 40 gallon tank and do a gallon water change a week you will head off many problems.

I'd base the small tank choice on what's available and what could be used for other purposes (e.g. a qt tank). You should buy it second hand from a member of your local reef club. Maybe an all in one would be easy.

My other advice is to go super light on fish stocking and feed less than you think you need to at first.

Also, don't think that a small tank won't be fun. I've been reefing for two and a half decades and I've had big tanks and small tanks. Right now life circumstances dictate that I have two small tanks. They are by far the best looking and healthiest tanks of my time in the hobby. They bring me absolute joy.

Invest in some good testing equipment. It's no fun to buy chemistry supplies when that money could be used to buy cool frags. But you will benefit from testing long term. The Hanna phosphate, alk, and nitrate testers. Also, since you want to automate long term, buy that apex now. I know it sounds nuts but I run an apex on each of two 15 gallon tanks I currently run.
 
All good advice I would go with at least live sand you will have fewer problems down the road.
Unless you go bottomless like I did.
20220122_100731.jpg
 
OMG I've been here for just a few hours and you have all poured a wealth of knowledge into me!!!
I'm so appreciative I found a home that will help me succeed at my new hobby.
I took up Bonsai trees a few years ago and I killed my 1st 3, fast forward and now I have 11 bonsai-style trees and 2 small 1 gallon ponds like tanks with plants only. I want to graduate and you guys are giving me the confidence to do so. I hope to keep this thread alive and post progress
 
I disagree. Strongly recommend a tank WITH a bottom. Water goes straight through otherwise. Hard earned experience.
Oh it is way harder to go bottomless but I have gone flow crazy and the only thing that would not blow around in my tank would be crushed coral and I will not do that again!.
 
Oh it is way harder to go bottomless but I have gone flow crazy and the only thing that would not blow around in my tank would be crushed coral and I will not do that again!.
I was just joking that it would be hard to keep water in a tank with no bottom. Sorry, it's late!
 
don't be afraid to go big! only concern you should have is, 1 can you afford it, 2 can you keep the interest in the hobby after first few problems. knowledge and experience will come with hobby as you get it started.
btw I started with 400gallon tank,
 
Screw gunner raises an important point. The sand you want is carib sea special grade aragonite sand. Not as fine as the sand at the beach, but not as coarse as crushed coral.
 
I started with a 60 gallon tall . Now I have a 125 gallon . I go though 5 gallons of rodi water a week just in evaporation. 400 gallon yikes.
 
I disagree. Strongly recommend a tank WITH a bottom. Water goes straight through otherwise. Hard earned experience.
I think as I read this again the recommendation is at least live sand if not live rock. so I like that live seems better that was my original thought but then I got scared of parasites etc. So any objection to live sand and live rock - go all in to shrink the cycle? p.s. how about bottled bacteria to speed the process

Definitely thinking of a chaeto refugium with copepods and amphipods and keeping it on a light on a timer so I can use this as a phosphate and nitrate controller by playing with the light cycles. I also plan on using a fleecemat roller instead of filter socks - again I'm trying to reduce maintenance needs since I am so busy with day to day life
 
Congratulations and welcome to the hobby. You made an excellent choice with Red Sea. I have enjoyed my Red Sea Aquariums and after much research use all the Red Sea equipment that is available including supplements.

I am still on the fence about using a Roller Mat but if I did it would defiantly the the RS model.

There is a wealth of knowledge here and you will get some great advise here just by asking. In the end you will have to pick and choice what's right for you. Good luck and welcome!
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top