When we buy ethanol in our lab, 100% ethanol is $180 a bottle, denatured ethanol is $5 a bottle. You know why? Pure ethanol is heavily regulated and there is a mandatory government fee attached to it. My guess is, Red Sea buys the denatured ethanol to substantially save on cost. If you are so sure that methanol is good for your reef, please start a thread where you do a daily dose of methanol in your tank. I'm sure your tank will look even more amazing. Let me know if you need some..
I've not said methanol makes the difference, it could very well play a part that makes A difference.. But to mock me with dosing pure methanol and attempting to leave out details is the major shortcoming to which I refer.
So you've never used NMR in your life (I have) and you seem to know more about NMR by reading a manual, than many of the experts here who use NMR for analytical chemistry on a regular basis..
I'm pretty sure the maker of the NMR has accounted more in the use of their machine than someone who merely uses it. To dismiss a higher resolution will show you more is a pretty elementary attitude, which in this case I believe is tainted by pride. Like everything else in the world, 'read the manual' does mean something, and it's fairly important.
You mean "speculating"? Have you heard of Bertrand Russell's celestial teapot analogy? Look it up. Maybe it will help you understand how your unsubstantiated claims about NoPox is just that.
Incorrect. To sum it up:
We know there's more than methanol, ethanol, and acetic acid in nopox
We know other compounds can affect denitrification
We know there's differences in biomass according to the above studies, though it's parallel and not necessarily equally comparable to a marine environment
We know the diy recipe only contains and accounts for acetic acid and ethanol, completely leaving out at least 1 component
We know the NMR was a single, short, student-lead test, at a low resolution
We know that given biological processes and cascading effects of chemistry, the inclusion of a single component (methanol) can completely change the organisms present
We know other organisms can utilize methanol, vs only acetic acid or ethanol
We know the majority of people in this thread shooting down any possibility of nopox being different, have not even used nopox
We know the number of people in this thread being pro-nopox, is more than those against nopox
We know there's more that we DON'T know, than what we do know
So probability clearly dictates that there is more to explore, than not. I would like to explore this, but I get flamed for attempting to expand our understanding?
And I find it hilarious you bring a philosophical aspect into the argument, because like philosophers, you venture away from science into personal opinion. I used to date a philosophy major, so I know how insecure and completely unfounded the responses can be. That's aside from the mental gymnastics they propose to sway people from thinking for themselves.