Redsea E Max 170 vs Max Nano G2 XL

[big_fish16]

Hey ya'll, I was wondering if you guys could help me in determining the right tank for me? Out of these two tanks which would be best to keep around 6 small fish (banggai cardinal size) and a couple shrimp with some coral? I prefer the Max Nano because of the wonderful filtration, but the E 170 is a little more DIY with the optional sump. What do you guys think?

 

[littlefoxx]

I personally will never get another red sea tank. Way too many seam failures. My seam was starting to go at the year mark. Got rid of it and I wont be going back to a red sea ever again to be honest