Review of radion diffusers for a shallow sps tank!

tenurepro

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Mar 17, 2017
Messages
845
Reaction score
1,310
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Hi All. I’ve been running gen 3 radion xr15s (3 of them) on my sps dominate Redsea reefer 250. The tank is somewhat shallow and most of the sps are 6 to 12” below the water line. I started with the standard 80 deg lenses on the lights, but that caused a major hotspot of par under the led puck. It was impossible to get even lighting on my top shelf with the 80 deg lenses; ps. The hotspot issue gets worst the higher you go up the tank.

So I swapped out the 80 deg lenses for the 120 deg wide angle lenses a year ago, and that helped spread out the light a bit, but at the expense of overall par levels. I was running the radions at 70% max intensity at the 18.5k spectrum and was getting Par between 200 to 300 over my sps.

Then I saw the new xr15 diffusers and couldn’t resist giving them a shot.

The diffusers obviously impose a reduction in par but the key question is: will the 80 deg lenses + diffuser outperform the 120 deg lenses ?

The short answer is, heck ya!
At the same max intensity (70%), I get substantially more par, better shimmer and about the same spread with 80 deg + diffuser vs 120 deg without diffusers!

Full review here: (a video tells a thousand words :)

 
Great video and great looking Tank. It’s good see see the reviews on these as I know some have been hesitant because of the possible decrease in par. Looks like that isn’t gonna be an issue.
 
Great video and great looking Tank. It’s good see see the reviews on these as I know some have been hesitant because of the possible decrease in par. Looks like that isn’t gonna be an issue.

For me, I actually gained par because the 120 deg lenses are not efficient!
Certainly you do lose some par if you are already running the 80 deg lenses and then stacking a diffuser on it. But for the folks like me who are running the 120 wide angle lenses on a shallow tank, switching to 80 deg lens + diffuser will actually be more efficient; same par for less electricity!
 
@tenurepro : Great info, thanks! I have a similar setup to yours except I am currently running the 80 degree lenses - would it be possible for you to post some PAR measurements taken when the diffusers are removed? I am curious to see the comparison between 80 degree lenses with diffusers compared to 80 degree lenses without diffusers.
 
Thanks! Can you run it without any lenses with the diffuser on?
 
@tenurepro : Great info, thanks! I have a similar setup to yours except I am currently running the 80 degree lenses - would it be possible for you to post some PAR measurements taken when the diffusers are removed? I am curious to see the comparison between 80 degree lenses with diffusers compared to 80 degree lenses without diffusers.

I’ll try to do this experiment on the weekend and report back
 
Wonderful looking tank!

What do you run your Vortechs at? Is that the SPS AB+ setting on the Radions? I just picked up a set of the diffusers for my XR15s...
 
Wonderful looking tank!

What do you run your Vortechs at? Is that the SPS AB+ setting on the Radions? I just picked up a set of the diffusers for my XR15s...

Cool - yep I run the sps ab+ program with a few mods. Here is a little video on my program. But note that the intensity was for 120 wide angle lenses with no diffusers. I turned the max intensity on the 18.5 k phase of the sps ab+ to 58% since I installed the diffusers and 80 Dey lens
 
Thanks for that vid! It's very helpful!
I've been running the Radiant color on my Reefer 250, but want to switch back to the AB+.

What kind of speed do you run your Vortechs at?
 
Thanks for that vid! It's very helpful!
I've been running the Radiant color on my Reefer 250, but want to switch back to the AB+.

What kind of speed do you run your Vortechs at?

Glad you found it useful. I vary my mp10s a bit during the day... this video is old but the cycles are mostly unchanged
 
Hi All. I got several requests for a full comparison of the diffuser on both the 80 and 120 Deg lenses.

In summary
In terms of par, we get
80>80+D>120>120+D (where d= diffuser)
In terms of Best spread of light, we get
120+D>120>80+D>80

For me the best compromise of par and spread came with the 80 deg lens plus diffuser

Here is the vid
 
Good work, I'd like to try these on my G3 pro 30 and go back to 80 deg lens. Thank you for this!
 
Thank you for sharing this! I hope when my diffuser arrives that I have good luck with it as well. I'm concerned about the installation, but hopefully everything will go smoothly.
 
Very cool! I recently installed mine! I love it!
20180219_124101.jpg
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top