Hmmm...I just had a thought. I have been replacing some of the sand that gets sucked up in my vacuuming with the "live" sand that I bought a year ago that is still in the bag. I've been putting in a few handfuls at a time, but have just realized that I haven't been rinsing the sand. The sand in the bag doesn't stink, but I highly doubt there is anything "live" in that sand. Could that be contributing to the excess nutrients? The only change I've made in quite a long time to the tank has been adding a tuxedo urchin.