Scolys dying, I am desperate for help

I have a meat coral in 1 of my tanks doing the same thing as yours. I’ve tried Kanaplex dips for a few days and a dip in interceptor. So far nothing has worked either. I may try other antibiotic dips.
 
Hi Guys, I really need your help please, I have a few scolys that are dropping like flys, something is going on in my tank, it’s 7 months old right now and I started noticing the issue around Mid December 2019 with my Double head scoly of the tissue receding and a gaping mouth, over a few weeks the coral got worse over time, mouth continued to gap and tissue just kept on receding, funny thing is that it took very long actually for the tissue to reced, I did low light low flow multiple dips and unfortunately 4 months later the coral died , fast track to 2 weeks ago my Superman scoly I noticed was a bit funny and kept his mouth open, the next morning it started receding and FAST!!, I again moved it to low flow low light area and multiple dips but not making any difference, at the same time I noticed my master scoly was doing the same, however the master started to reced in weird way, by the tissue along the outer rim on the skeleton started peeling off and kinda making holes, so I called a fellow reefer to help me out and take the scolys and put it in his QT tank, no improvement in his tank on both the Superman and master scoly. On Saturday I noticed my war paint isn’t to happy, it started to reced in chunks and the again burning holes, what’s interest is there are white squiggly stringy poop almost coming out of the area of wounds, kinda like how people say my clown fish pooped white strings, i dipped the coral and put it back into my display but the next day more receding and more white squiggly stringy poop, so I found this article and decided I am going to give it a shot, I set up a small QT 15l or 5 gallons with a hang on the back filter with bio balls from my main display, FYI I found a dead copepod in my media bag however it was red, it went down the sink before I could take a pic of it, I put in an egg crate and heater, display tank water was added to the QT, I found a article on Ultimate reef about a potential LPS disease, it talks about adding Milbemax dewormer which has a Milbemycin interceptor as well as praziquantel, essentially it kills parasites, please see the link https://www.ultimatereef.net/threads/potential-new-lps-disease.677915/page-6 . I put 1/12 of the Milbemax for dogs, the big tablet and dissolved it in a little tank water, I added the scoly in and now me typing this is about 18 hours later, the receding is still happening on my war paint, my fellow reefer has also purchased the meds and added it to his tank and has said the scolys are still getting worse, I don’t know what else to do, I have over 13 scolys and this is the 5th on going through the same thing, all my other corals, euphyllia, acans, GSP, Chalice, clam, Monte etc are all doing good. My water parameters are 9.5dkh, 425 cal, 1410mag, 2ppm nitrate, 0.04phosphate. My feeding is target feeding reef roids twice a week and it phytogold twice a week. I beg of you all to please can someone help me out, I am destroyed from all of this.

A061DFD4-1828-42FB-9F5C-7CE19D34CA14.jpeg 88EE4CE6-91AA-454C-982F-90298E645DF1.jpeg 71184865-CE7F-41B6-ACFB-163D9F13B8C7.jpeg 15180EE7-D2CB-4490-B0E4-8CD87AD1D8D0.jpeg A5B9DD39-3447-4B81-949D-4B7E198522FC.jpeg 21208AA1-52C3-4F2C-8F53-72C4561F5308.jpeg ED847AC9-0390-46C0-890B-BF3139B22558.jpeg 5A4A5047-DB85-4BFC-BEA4-C287B0AFDA65.jpeg 69B6C449-849D-42AB-895F-F6F8B2C517F6.jpeg 3A5159FD-0A44-460B-98D5-4E504BBAB5B5.jpeg 896FDCAF-2B4A-4148-9492-6B159395D6AD.jpeg 91FE04FA-4BB2-4423-A2CD-8A7AF56831BF.jpeg A90AD374-0A4C-42BF-ADAB-806550C8F074.jpeg 95ED6222-4921-4E95-8FE3-90F2AC333771.jpeg C7F82A8F-8633-465B-B06D-7B6DE989BC3E.jpeg 4A591FA8-9154-436A-9048-C4B13AEE6E5D.jpeg 2D36021C-C31D-4373-8739-042D41C3E41C.jpeg FC40B0B1-D4B2-4E30-B259-4CC263234634.jpeg B6352BBB-4423-4E6B-9EEB-B83F55B66514.jpeg 4D5F8873-DD7A-4587-BDAB-A1B17273C8D3.jpeg 559C99B8-7FDD-41B5-82F4-4F59AD1BFC0D.jpeg
If you have Instagram this guy might be able to help https://instagram.com/coral_fish_zoa?igshid=vlqllu411pj5
 
I have a meat coral in 1 of my tanks doing the same thing as yours. I’ve tried Kanaplex dips for a few days and a dip in interceptor. So far nothing has worked either. I may try other antibiotic dips.

what products are you using for the dips, i know kanaplex is a seachem product, what antibiotic dip are you going to use?
 
Seachem is the only one I'm aware of that offers Antibiotics. (Kanaplex, MetroPlex, Neoplex)
I'm going to grab some of this PolypLab - One - see what that does.
 
Are you 100% sure they are not being eaten? I had lost a scoly and had a trachy that was down to the skeleton in places. I noticed that my Klein's butterfly and flame angel were picking at the scoly skeleton and acans one night. When I set up a frag tank, I moved the trachy there, together with my other fleshy corals that had not been doing well (pectinia, acans, remaining scoly). They are now doing very well.
 
Seachem is the only one I'm aware of that offers Antibiotics. (Kanaplex, MetroPlex, Neoplex)
I'm going to grab some of this PolypLab - One - see what that does.

okay thanks i have all of that stuff already, ive used the polyp lab primer, didnt really help this issue. ( Polyp lab one is ALK, CAL and Mag) all in one dosing
 
Are you 100% sure they are not being eaten? I had lost a scoly and had a trachy that was down to the skeleton in places. I noticed that my Klein's butterfly and flame angel were picking at the scoly skeleton and acans one night. When I set up a frag tank, I moved the trachy there, together with my other fleshy corals that had not been doing well (pectinia, acans, remaining scoly). They are now doing very well.

i have a nano tank, i have a clown and a dotty back in the tank thats all, definitely no fish picking on them
 
the only thing maybe, if someone could correct me is over feeding? i have 12 other scolys doing very well still
 
I ordered it earlier today - guess it won't hurt to try it now!
 
whats your iodine level at , do you dose Iodide? , it is essential you know this if your going to attempt to collect these effectively and yeah your overfeeding
 
whats your iodine level at , do you dose Iodide? , it is essential you know this if your going to attempt to collect these effectively and yeah your overfeeding

i dont dose iodine, ICP showed 36.00ug/l which is range. i do weekly water changes
 
the only thing maybe, if someone could correct me is over feeding? i have 12 other scolys doing very well still
If I feed “too much” my scoly just takes a bigger poop the next day!
CA1D92EA-6A98-4E87-92FC-F83628D41364.jpeg


Also - have you made any changes to lighting? Any chance you have an overdeveloped pod population? I’ve heard of some species of amphipods eating coral before.
 
If I feed “too much” my scoly just takes a bigger poop the next day!
CA1D92EA-6A98-4E87-92FC-F83628D41364.jpeg


Also - have you made any changes to lighting? Any chance you have an overdeveloped pod population? I’ve heard of some species of amphipods eating coral before.
its awesome yours does that, no changes with lighting, my lighting has been the same for 4 months, regarding the pods i am not sure, i have a clam in my tank and i feed phytoplankton every second day and i know pods feed off phytoplankton
 
i have an AI prime, this is my schedule

WhatsApp Image 2020-03-19 at 09.41.01.jpeg
 
I don't know if you have multiple tanks, but one thing that helped at a different time, was I moved an LPS to my office system( ~ 2 months old) after dipping in Bayer then Iodine. Worked for 1x of my LPS, but, so far, not the meat coral.
 
its awesome yours does that, no changes with lighting, my lighting has been the same for 4 months, regarding the pods i am not sure, i have a clam in my tank and i feed phytoplankton every second day and i know pods feed off phytoplankton
thanks! I’ve only managed to get pictures the one time, he doesn’t take long ;)

if you have no natural predators for the pods they can reproduce to the point that they turn to other food sources. Perhaps a pink streak wrasse would help in that regard? It’s a small tank so your options are limited.

but in regards to lighting - you said it had been the same for 4 months. December 2019 was about 4 months ago and that’s when you first started noticing the problem.
 
I would like to go to the flow in the tank too. As pointed out another time the torches look like they are really flowing. It also looks like the skeleton on the warpaint scoly is showing on the edge the water would be coming from to me. Do you notice if it's the scolys in one particular spot or if they are receding along the same edges where the flow might be hitting them? It looks like one is pulling back on the side facing the glass which could be from flow coming off the glass or even light bouncing off the face of the glass. Have you looked at par values during peak light output?

Small tank too? Parameters can swing faster so maybe there is an issue there?
 
I would like to go to the flow in the tank too. As pointed out another time the torches look like they are really flowing. It also looks like the skeleton on the warpaint scoly is showing on the edge the water would be coming from to me. Do you notice if it's the scolys in one particular spot or if they are receding along the same edges where the flow might be hitting them? It looks like one is pulling back on the side facing the glass which could be from flow coming off the glass or even light bouncing off the face of the glass. Have you looked at par values during peak light output?

Small tank too? Parameters can swing faster so maybe there is an issue there?
Regarding the flow, in the pic where you see the torch’s, I only moved the scoly there for picture purposes, the scolys aren’t getting much flow as my wave maker pushes flow towards the glass and circulates the tank. The war paint that had the original damage was a lot worse and was healing for a while in my tank up until recently. Regarding light par values, my highest scoly in my tank get 160 par and lowest is 90. Yes small tank so it can swing, the only element I dose is alk, daily consumption is 0.1 per day, the rest of my elements get taken care of with a 20% water change every friday.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top