scrubber or skimmer

[merfish101]

Hi all. Seems like my reef octopus skimmer pump is calling it quits. I have been contemplating buying an algae scrubber lately as was wanting a few opinions on which would be a better export option. Any feed back would be appreciated. Thanks

 

[rusty hannon]

Hi all. Seems like my reef octopus skimmer pump is calling it quits. I have been contemplating buying an algae scrubber lately as was wanting a few opinions on which would be a better export option. Any feed back would be appreciated. Thanks

You can also run a scrubber, but don't ditch the skimmer.you need that. If you're pump went out you can just replace pump. Reef octopus is a well known and good skimmer so finding a replacement pump should do the trick.

 

[merfish101]

Thanks. The BRS price is about the same for each item so I'll check the marketplace page and see what I can find. I am definitely still interested in a scrubber though. Was just wondering if one was a better/equal option.

 

[fishguy242]

+1 on needing skimmer

 

[Ippyroy]

Although help with nutrient removal, the skimmer helps in adding oxygen into the water and the ATS would help in CO2 removal at night. Running both would be the best option IMHO. A DIY scrubber is super easy and way cheaper than buying one BTW.

 

[laverda]

I agree both would be better. Replacing the impeller may be all your skimmer pump needs and not cost that much.
You can build an ATS for almost nothing. Look at my DIY thread on ATS for under $30. Mine works fantastic on my 300 gallon. I can drive my nitrates and phosphates to zero in a short period of time by running it 24/7. Not a good idea though.

 

[merfish101]

I agree both would be better. Replacing the impeller may be all your skimmer pump needs and not cost that much.
You can build an ATS for almost nothing. Look at my DIY thread on ATS for under $30. Mine works fantastic on my 300 gallon. I can drive my nitrates and phosphates to zero in a short period of time by running it 24/7. Not a good idea though.

Thanks, I will certainly check your thread out.

 

[Pistondog]

Thanks, I will certainly check your thread out.

which skimmer?
if varios pump, it might be the controller, like mine, which is $75 to replace.

 

[Biglew11]

https://www.coralvue.com/parts for reef octopus skimmer parts.

 

[merfish101]

which skimmer?
if varios pump, it might be the controller, like mine, which is $75 to replace.

The varios is the replacement for my current pump. RODC 5500s