Shady YouTube channels.

  • Thread starter Thread starter atoll
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None

atoll

2500 Club Member
View Badges
Joined
Dec 20, 2012
Messages
4,754
Reaction score
8,155
Location
Wales UK
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
I get increasingly concerned about the number of people with their own YouTube channel posing as your average amateur reefer reviewing equipment etc. Here is the uK we have at least 2 such fakers. By fakers. I am referring to those who obviously have been given equipment by a manufacturer or other and told what to say as if reviewing an item. Mostly these people only tell you what is already stated on the manufacturers web site.

These people don't do real reviews at all, no "I have had this piece of equipment for x months and this is what I think of it". No, what they do is an unboxing review and tell you how great it is even though they have not even put it in or on their aquarium. One of these fakers I know has hardly been in the hobby a year yet but puts himself up as some kind of expert. This guy only ever shows his tank in the background as his fish and corals all succumb to poor understanding and maintenance of their aquarium and many die at his hands. Another has had a major crash and lost most of the fish in the tank which was clearly overstocked but blamed a 4 hour power outage as the only reason.

Now many of us here know these people are being supported by manufacturers and even some shops to promote their goods and shop, however, newcomers to the hobby are being conned into thinking these despicable people are in some way more than a thin veneer and know what they are talking about. You can also see they are reading from an autocue of some sort with the blurb written out for them.

I am not suggesting this is a new thing after all we see it on TV adverts where people pretend to be Mr or Mrs average telling us how good something is while being paid to do so. However in this case we are talking keeping animals for which we have a responsibility and people being conned into thinking they need this or that item to have a successful aquarium, strange as they always review sorry unbox an expensive piece of equipment.

I am not however, confusing these people with the genuine reefers out there who do a good job of reviewing an item they bought or an advertisement from a manufacturer that is fair enough no pretense there. You may well have similar in the US and it's a growing cancer in the hobby it seems.
 
Being on youtube and doing it right one can gain follower, sponsors, and that means cash. I am afraid this what the hole reality TV thing as generated. I am glad to see amateurs out there doing reviews and it gives a different view than the company just trying to do full on marketing.
 
Being a Youtube channel owner myself, I can see what you are talking about. I don't like the unboxing videos that really don't give you any real time experience with the product, which is why I tell vendors that I will have to have it for a while before I can do a real review. Also, I'm not paid for my reviews because that seems questionable at best - what is my motivation if I'm paid?

Regarding the reef tank with the fish loss, that wasn't shady. She was so upset when it happened, and we talked about it a week before it was posted on her channel. She was even thinking about quitting the hobby. I wish she'd had a battery backup on that new Vortech pump she just did a video about a few days prior. After all, we all go to sleep but if the power is out for 4 hours or more, those that need a lot of oxygen will be the first to perish. DSBs suck up air quickly in a stagnant tank.
 
Being on youtube and doing it right one can gain follower, sponsors, and that means cash. I am afraid this what the hole reality TV thing as generated. I am glad to see amateurs out there doing reviews and it gives a different view than the company just trying to do full on marketing.

I like to see amateurs doing genuine reviews as well. However doing it wrong like overstocking a tank showing more fish than is reasonable is not good nor is just opening boxes and saying how good something is without any user backup and reviewing after a product has been used for a reasonable length of time. I have my own YouTube channel but I don't just sit in front of the camera and try and sell stuff, in fact, I don't push anything. I don't make money or get freebies either from it so there is nothing commercial there. However, I believe if you get something out of something you enjoy then put something back into it and that is what I do on my YouTube channel and my Facebook groups.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top