Wow...I just missed you as we went in 2003. Its just a guess at this point but the only location that looks familiar from the photos is Pirates Point, small world.
Little Cayman was my first dive experience after earning my certification, 14-16 dives. The wall dives there were equal parts amazing and intimidating. Abyss below you and open ocean is humbling.
What kept you in Little Cayman so long? That's quite a stretch. What is the biggest/most interesting thing you experienced down there?
Later days,
B-Kind