Should i use a clown to cycle my tank?

Yeah, I will probably end up just getting some ammonia chloride from my lfs. I was thinking just to have a constant source for the bacteria to feed on. The store I usually go to is about 45 minutes away so it's kind of a hassle. Plus he only lets one person in at a time so if anyone is there before me I could be waiting a while.
 
I used Seachem Stability which is a bacteria start up like Dr. Tim's but so much less expensive. Then I put a pinch of fish food in every day. Got some small live rock and sand from the LFS. I was ready to add my first clownfish in two weeks. I also had my Fiji Pink Coralsea live sand.
 
I used stability my first time cycling. Worked great. I've heard a lot of good things about brightwell's bacteria so I thought I would give them a try.
 
Yeah, I will probably end up just getting some ammonia chloride from my lfs. I was thinking just to have a constant source for the bacteria to feed on. The store I usually go to is about 45 minutes away so it's kind of a hassle. Plus he only lets one person in at a time so if anyone is there before me I could be waiting a while.

more humane and cheaper.

bacteria do not need a "constant" source of ammonia to feed and stay alive. Modern reefing has debunked the idea that the nitrogen cycle in our tanks needs constant input to survive. brandon429 has some great knowledge on this subject.

I just cycled my tank a couple months ago, dr tims and brightwell are exactly what I used to seed it, and then bottled ammonium chloride. Took very close to a month before I could pass the 24 hour test.
 
Last edited:
this is my honest take on the matter, built solely from hundreds of web posts we could all easily search up and scan for patterns:

-adding clownfish to an uncycled reef results in dead clownfish in two days. We have never had a single person on this planet do a fish-in cycle using a seneye ammonia meter to tell if fish in cycles are burning fish.

-burnt fish can't breathe, they dont feed and they hover at the top panting/can't breathe/dying

-i have never seen that condition in any skip cycle thread on any forum not once. fish swim, act normal, api shows .25 forever, and this differs from a fully cycled reef in no way I can find.

so those patterns are neat to consider.

*fish in cycling must be a fallower's nightmare however.

trying to make inference about what cycling bacteria can tolerate without having a seneye as the ref is exactly like an MLB umpire who must wear distortion goggles for all calls. the crowd will revolt eventually.
 
what is nitrate doing in a fish-in cycle? dont care. nitrate is for algae tuning.

what is nitrite doing in a fish in cycle? dont care. nitrite is neutral in reefing and in cycling, no, it can't stall ammonia production ability in a reef tank as claimed by bac sellers who do lab experiments, without seneye, to shape sales context.

what is ammonia doing during a fish in cycle? whats your meter? seneye or not? hows the bioload acting, water clarity, able to tolerate feed? is the only thing differing the visual results of your aquarium from that of a 5 yr old system a non seneye test kit> patterns

how in the world do reef conventions with a million dollars in reef life all set up tanks that do not vary on a given start date? even seen anyone lug a 2000lb reef tank into a convention, three days late?

forum cycles vary. reef convention cycles never ever ever vary all entrants meet the start date


can this tank here share any setup similarities to convention reefs>?
 
Its just pointless.

It is so unbelievably easy to cycle a tank now a days. Squirt in some ammonium chloride, it doesnt have to be a specific concentration, I shoot for 0.5-2.0ppm total. And then dump in whatever bacteria in a bottle. You will be cycled in 2-4 days, no fish stress and much faster than any other method.
 

anemone on day 1. plus updates.

no burning occurred here/handy just to keep perspective. the crowd direction on forum evaluations tends to omit evidence for opposite outcomes: the instant ability to control ammonia vs a delayed one.

forum evaluations will always harbor the unspoken view that harm is occurring. That there's no indication of it in the fish at all doesnt factor.

that doesnt give anyone the right to go spreading crypto or velvet. providing quick ammonia control is not a challenging barrier/they ship aquatic bacteria in bottles of water, they transfer fine per Dr. Reef's thread on bottle bac efficacy.
we lose 70% of fallow-skipped fish to disease, stats show.


So Im saying fish in cycles are something we're going to have to accept.

They dont burn fish, but that doesnt mean you should do them. If you did however, there are ways of hedging your odds :)

so in the end, I guess Im against unprepared fish-in cycling. If someone is using fiber internet vs dialup, Im ok with that too. There is a moore's law for reef cycling just like there's one for computer processing speed. its prudent to verify one didn't receive dead bottle bac before adding fish; easy ammonia lowering pre test w determine that.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for everyone's input! Didn't know this would strike up such a lively conversation.
 
I do advocate pre testing for ammonia/ not full on wild west :)

If ammonia can be shown moved down overnite after adding suspected live cycling bac, that's a confirm can start if normal surface area is present

That we keep getting away with fish in cycles without pre verification is a hidden compliment to bottled bacteria ability. Reliability
 
It took me three months to get my display so I started cycling rock that far out. After about 4-6 weeks my ammonia, nitrite and nitrate were all at 0. At that point, I added two clowns to further cycle my rock in my sump. My intent was to get as much of the “ugly phase” done with as I could before my tank arrived. A week after my clowns, I added a bicolor blenny, a gramma loretto, and a hippo tang plus two handfuls of hermits and snails to start clearing algae (my sump is a 6’ long 175 gallon plywood tank I built filled with 125 gallons of water and 200 pounds of rock). I also started growing algae for my refugium.

My 115 gallon display tank showed up about a week ago, I got it filled by Saturday evening, and Sunday morning I moved over 75 pounds of rock, my fish, and everything else I could find to the display.

The fish/rock/everything is doing just fine. I have to deal with no cycle in the display, and I’m ready to add more fish as soon as I get paid.

image.jpg
 
nice. we can mix n match them all day long. to move into the next room is the same thing as moving into a new home across town is the same biology as moving out of state and keeping all the current animals alive. or from a pet store to home

thats a clean nice roomy setup.
 
nice. we can mix n match them all day long. to move into the next room is the same thing as moving into a new home across town is the same biology as moving out of state and keeping all the current animals alive. or from a pet store to home

thats a clean nice roomy setup.

Thanks.

It’s my third system in 14 years and I kind of figured out a few things over the years. I really wanted to make the aquarium be the focus of the room.

23642D9A-A89B-43EF-959E-9842690B61FA.jpeg
 
So I'm still waiting on my tank to get in but in the meantime I want to go ahead and cycle my rock. Currently I have it in a 20gal long that I had lying around. I have heard of people cycling with clowns since they are quite hardy. Anyone have experience with this?
No use bottled bacteria why put a fish through unnecessary stress
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top