Sick yellow tang

[Marcos Delacamara]

Update:
I place the tang in a fwd following the proper steps. Didn’t have a dark bucket so spotting anything that came off the fish was nearly impossible. I don’t think anything did fall off after the fwd though, seem he looks same.

After the dip I took him straight to the qt and put in the medications. Bellow are some pics of him in the fwd and in the qt.

 

[LAReefer4Life]

Last time My fish had ich I wasn’t able to remove all the fish from the DT, I just removed the coral beauty. I treated him with the treatment I showed above and after 30 days of qt I placed him back in the DT. One other fish also got sick. I tried to qt him with copper and he didn’t make it.

I don’t think I will be able to take all the fish out of the system. I have 6 fish and only one qt. Plus I’m really bad at tank husbandry (reasons as to why I decided to use Triton method since the start of the tank) I’m sure I would stress the fish out through this 76 day process. I’m afraid that this method won’t work for me.

If none of the other fish show symptoms can I leave them in the DT, I know I won’t get rid of ich this way but if they don’t stress out and avoid an outbreak would they be okay?

Many reefers choose ich management vs. eradication. I personally do not recommend it. It will be beneficial for you to read this thread below. One topic noted is proper husbandry as a key component to a successful ich management situation.

https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/ich-eradication-vs-ich-management.188775/

 

[LAReefer4Life]

Update:
I place the tang in a fwd following the proper steps. Didn’t have a dark bucket so spotting anything that came off the fish was nearly impossible. I don’t think anything did fall off after the fwd though, seem he looks same.

After the dip I took him straight to the qt and put in the medications. Bellow are some pics of him in the fwd and in the qt.

What medication did you use? How are you testing? What levels is the meds at?

 

[Marcos Delacamara]

What medication did you use? How are you testing? What levels is the meds at?

I posted a picture of the bottle. It’s called herbtana, I’m dosing 1ml per 5 gallons. It helped me before so I’m giving it a try again.

 

[Mjrenz]

I was just looking back at this post and your pics, it can be very hard to tell on a yellow tang and even harder to tell by the pics but does it look like he has dust all over his body? I just want to make sure you're not dealing with something more serious than ich. Can we get some opinions from @ngoodermuth @HotRocks @4FordFamily and @Big G?

 

[4FordFamily]

I was just looking back at this post and your pics, it can be very hard to tell on a yellow tang and even harder to tell by the pics but does it look like he has dust all over his body? I just want to make sure you're not dealing with something more serious than ich. Can we get some opinions from @ngoodermuth @HotRocks @4FordFamily and @Big G?

I agree I see what appears to be many small spots.

To the op, Herbtana will not clear up velvet, or really much of anything. Typically, products like this at best, improve the slime coat of the fish slowing parasite progression. What generally happens IF they "work", is that the fish build a natural resistance on their own and fight it off. This is most common with minor ich infestations.

Unfortunately, velvet is every bit as common and much more deadly. Very few fish can fight off velvet in a glass cage. I hope this helps

 

[Mjrenz]

I agree I see what appears to be many small spots.

To the op, Herbtana will not clear up velvet, or really much of anything. Typically, products like this at best, improve the slime coat of the fish slowing parasite progression. What generally happens IF they "work", is that the fish build a natural resistance on their own and fight it off. This is most common with minor ich infestations.

Unfortunately, velvet is every bit as common and much more deadly. Very few fish can fight off velvet in a glass cage. I hope this helps

Thank you for the quick reply! I was worried you may agree.

Op, read this, if you are dealing with velvet you need to use another treatment right away

https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/velvet-amyloodinium-ocellatum.217570/

 

[Marcos Delacamara]

I’m really not sure what the fish has. His skin did look a bit fuzzy (not smooth like the other fish). Yet his behavior is still the same. He still eating pellets and other foods. he’s swimming around like crazy (like always/ he’s been the most active fish in the tank) and not hiding between the rocks.
I thought that fish start showing these signs when they are sick, yet the tang has not done any of these.