Are they as unfriendly as everyone says they are?
Sixline Wrasse?
- Thread starter NanaReefer
- Start date
- Tagged users None
DaveMorris
MACNA2016 Co-Chair
I must be the odd man out because I have always had a sixline and never had any problems with them.
- Joined
- Sep 21, 2012
- Messages
- 11,636
- Reaction score
- 1,056
I have probably had around 6 of this Fish in Various Tanks throughout the Years.
And every one of them was Perfect.
This "They are the Devil" thing is Crap!
eatbreakfast
Fish Nerd
A small percentage of them are fine, most are mean.
ritter6788
Coral Fraud Private Eye
My experience with them is about the same as any other territorial fish. There are certain other fish (shapes/colors/personalities) that likely won't do well with an aggressive six line such as Royal Grammas, fairy/flasher wrasses. Other fish can be kept with a six line with no problem like clowns, tangs, damsels etc. There are fish that can hold their own with aggressive fish and some that won't do well at all. My six line beat up a mandarin and chased my gramma constantly unless it hid behind the overflow. I moved it to a smaller tank with clowns and damsels and it never caused another problem.
If a sixline finds a fish it doesn't care for it's not going to leave it alone until either you rarely/never see it or it's dead. They are great aquarium fish if you can find the right combo of fish that can live with it. I wish I still had mine. It would fan it's fins out and do a dance along the glass when I would view the tank.
If a sixline finds a fish it doesn't care for it's not going to leave it alone until either you rarely/never see it or it's dead. They are great aquarium fish if you can find the right combo of fish that can live with it. I wish I still had mine. It would fan it's fins out and do a dance along the glass when I would view the tank.
mfinn
likes zoanthids
I had one years ago and it was the smallest fish in the tank and it did get a little aggressive.
Everything I've read about them makes me want to stay away from them, especially with other small fish.
Everything I've read about them makes me want to stay away from them, especially with other small fish.
saltyphish
Certified Sand Groomer
I have a sixline with 2 clowns, a midas blenny , and a green clown goby and have no problems. He was the last fish added though, which I hear is very important when adding a sixline. I hear any fish added after will not make it but have not tried since my sixline is the last fish to go into my tank.
OP
OP
My current fish are Royal Gramma, Bi-Colored Blenny, Banggai Cardinal and a Yellow Watchman. All but the Watchman have been in the tank for 10 months.
Quite the differences in experiences with this fish.
Quite the differences in experiences with this fish.
- Joined
- Sep 21, 2012
- Messages
- 11,636
- Reaction score
- 1,056
So you are saying I am super super lucky since all 6 of mine are Perfect and I have never had a single mean one?
I find that hard to believe?
ritter6788
Coral Fraud Private Eye
It would be tough with that fish list especially the gramma. I would give it a try if it's the fish you want but be prepared to remove it again if it caused problems. If you won't be able to remove the fish I'd be hesitant to add a sixline. I agree though there are other nice wrasses you could add and likely not take much if any risk with your other fish.
4FordFamily
Tang, Angel, and Wrasse Nerd!
Mine were always terrors. Never again.
However, I do think that like the Sohal tang, people just reiterate other people's stories without any real experience and then what was one person's actual experience is reiterated and reinforced by 20 more people.
Not saying Sohal aren't aggressive, they can be, but they're not the devil. Ime and IMO purple tangs, some PBT, and other tangs are just as bad or worse.
My sixline always bullied my dottybacks when I used to keep both. They left my melanarus wrasses but the melanarus were first and much larger. I've also not been able to keep them for longer than a year. Not sure why, when they died I didn't care at all though. Many fish I would rather have. Mysteri would be my choice if I was shopping in that genus again.
However, I do think that like the Sohal tang, people just reiterate other people's stories without any real experience and then what was one person's actual experience is reiterated and reinforced by 20 more people.
Not saying Sohal aren't aggressive, they can be, but they're not the devil. Ime and IMO purple tangs, some PBT, and other tangs are just as bad or worse.
My sixline always bullied my dottybacks when I used to keep both. They left my melanarus wrasses but the melanarus were first and much larger. I've also not been able to keep them for longer than a year. Not sure why, when they died I didn't care at all though. Many fish I would rather have. Mysteri would be my choice if I was shopping in that genus again.
