Soft Coral Food
- Thread starter viper1972
- Start date
- Tagged users None
revhtree
Owner Administrator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Reef Squad
Partner Member 2024
Excellence Award
RGB
Photo of the Month
Article Contributor
R2R TV Featured
Hospitality Award
Article Administrator
Black Friday Sponsor
Industry Professional
2nd Monthly Contributor
My Tank Thread
My Aquarium Showcase
- Joined
- May 8, 2006
- Messages
- 49,235
- Reaction score
- 98,071
Honestly I have never fed my soft corals. I would think that goo lighting and great water quality would be the key to fast growth.
viper1972
Community Member
Thats all I have ever done also. I am running T-5s and the water is excellent. I feed with marine cuisine and I know some of the ricordea and musrooms and palys catch stuff from that. Actually soft corals likes the water a little dirty. I have ran without a skimmer for years and tried them for years and had better growth without one.
mfinn
likes zoanthids
I tried feeding my soft coral tanks back in the early 90's, but always seemed to be battling algae. Once I stopped, and just did water changes, good skimmer, and good lighting, I had good growth and very little algae.
I don't buy the myth that any coral likes dirty water.
I don't buy the myth that any coral likes dirty water.
I'm trying to get a tank covered in Xenia and Kenya Tree that doesn't have any fish so I'm feeding a squirt of RotiFeast every night. I don't wanna see rocks, just soft coral so hopefully it speeds up the process. They close up shortly after feeding so hopefully they are eating it.
For those not feeding the softies, what do you think are the most important elements to add to the tank? It seems my corals even with T5 and good water quality don't spread much. I have green hairy mushrooms, purple mushrooms, various polyps, star polyps and galaxea. Thanks!
ritter6788
Coral Fraud Private Eye
I've never directly any softies. There are many I wish I could keep from growing/spreading.
mfinn
likes zoanthids
Connie
Valuable Member
I have had a little clump of green star polyps for 2 years that has never grown at all. It hasn't died, it just hasnt encrusted onto the rock. I started using Pohl's Extra and Coral Vitalizer and in two months it has encrusted on the rock and doubled in size. I have always had a problem with soft coral. I couldn't grow mushrooms, or star polyps or xenia or leathers.....I don't know if it's true or not, but the kid at one of my lfs said high calcium levels will stunt their growth?
That is interesting Connie. I would think good calcium levels would be beneficial to helping them adhere to the rock...Thanks for the info....so besides Coral Vit, i am chiming in with BentonB...would like to know what elements promote the most growth. I use RO/DI water...i have no algae and zero nitrates (i have a refugium and the algae in there seems to keep things nice looking in the tank) i just don't have a lot of growth!
ritter6788
Coral Fraud Private Eye
"High" calcium levels will stunt any coral growth because the water chemistry is out of whack. Higher end calcium in the acceptable range does not inhibit soft coral growth.
Calcium, alkalinity, magnesium but ONLY when needed. Testing often and replenishing those elements will support coral growth. Soft corals are large element consumers so with water changes you may not ever need to dose anything to your tank. All 3 are plentiful in most salt mixes.
Connie
Valuable Member
So Ritter, how can I lower the calcium level in my tank? I tested it yesterday and it was 540. I never add calcium. My mag was at 1400. I just did a water change 4 days ago and I do one biweekly.
ritter6788
Coral Fraud Private Eye
Using Coralife salt by chance?
If not then which salt are you using? If you're unhappy with the higher calcium then it may be just as easy as switching to a different salt. If you're not dosing anything then it has to be that high in your salt mix. 540 calcium is high but not detrimental to soft coral growth IMO. What is your alkalinity?
ritter6788
Coral Fraud Private Eye
Coralife is known to have inflated calcium numbers. There are many other good salts to use my personal favorite is Reef Crystals but I used Coralife for a long period with no issues.
